Ok, I've worked on this a bit. I cloned the Priority Handling Module and reworded everything and now I have an option to select each of the "Upgrades"- It's not pretty but it works~ I'm excited now!!

One thing that I'd like to do is, only allow one of the options to be selected- like when you are selecting a shipping service. Any ideas on what I could add to get this to work?

Thanks!
Nancy