
Originally Posted by
RodG
Yes, it was. There are much easier and simpler ways to do what you wanted. I was *sure* someone else would have mentioned at least one
STOP: Attention. Alert!!!!
If you'd so much as mentioned 'SEO' in your original post we probably wouldn't be having this conversation. I'd have given a the easier solution, along with a lecture.
I'll save the lecture, but to Stevesh, and possibly others, I feel I owe a bit more of an explanation as to why I recommended a product/module/technology that many assume I have an unreasonable(?) hatred for.
My stance on URI mapping in regards to any 'SEO' benefits still hasn't changed.
The deal is, the problem presented only really has two solutions (albeit, with many methods of implementation).
Only one of these solutions are available to most end users, and that is, to utilise the redirect and/or rewrite features of the webserver by modifying the .htaccess file (the other method is via the global settings for the web server, which is only good for those with VPN's or other private server).
OK, so since the *only* solution to the business case presented is to modify the .htaccess file, the question then became what is the *best* way to modify this file.
I felt quite comfortable in suggesting the CEON mod because I knew it'd do the job (and then some) and that coner was around to help support any issues the OP may come across in implementing the solution to his specific problem.
The business case presented is the core reason why this technology was 'invented'. It was never intended to benefit search engines, but sadly, that is all they seem to be used for these days (even though the gains are debatable).
If you aren't clear of my logic/reasoning, please ask, because I'm sure I could explain myself even better. Or perhaps not.
Cheers
Rod