Ok so whoever I talked to at GoDaddy was an idiot. I found out he didn't work in the hosting dept, but in the SSL dept so he really didn't know anything about technical support. I talked with someone new and we were able to figure out that if the .htaccess file was renamed in the html file (left the .htaccess file in the Admin file alone), the Contact Us page began working fine. It also changed all the website pages to non-secure, but as soon as something was added to the shopping cart, it automatically switched into SSL mode, so the entire checkout procedure was secure. Everything appears to be working properly!