Not to say this can not be corrected with where you are but would be much easier if you created yopur own template set of files based on the template default files over the classic combo...

Another easy way to get there is to upgrade to 1.3.5 now...

I see that you created your own folder for your template includes/templates/carolinas/ but used the stylesheet new and original from the classic template instead of the ones that are in the template_default files.