Quote Originally Posted by bradymc View Post
I double and triple checked the closing div... manually and with Dreamweaver. I'm not seeing where I'm missing one.
You are missing a closing div. I found it out by checking your site with an HTML validator.

Look again:

Code:
<div id="headerWrapper">
  <!--bof-navigation display-->
    <div id="navMainWrapper">
       <div id="navMain">
           <div id="navMainLinks">
              <ul class="back">
                 <li><a href="http://www.toned4life.com/cart/">Home</a></li>
                  <li><a href="https://www.toned4life.com/cart/index.php?main_page=login">Log In</a></li>
              </ul>
           </div><!--CLOSE navMainLinks-->
              <div id="navMainSearch"></div>
       </div><!-- CLOSE navMain-->
    </div><!-- CLOSE navMainWrapper-->
  <div class="clearBoth"></div>
  <!--eof-navigation display-->
  <!--bof-branding display-->
  <div id="logoWrapperOuter">
      <div id="logoWrapper">
          <div id="logo"><a href="http://www.toned4life.com/cart/"><img src="includes/templates/apple_zen/images/logo.gif" alt="Toned 4 Life" title=" Toned 4 Life " /></a>
          </div><!--CLOSE logo-->
       </div><!--CLOSE logoWrapper-->
  </div><!--CLOSE logoWrapperOuter-->
There is no closing </div> for #headerWRAPPER.

I even tested in Firefox with the devloper tools. Adding the closing div fixes your issue.