I added a discount coupon to make a certain product free, and only with orders over $50.

The minimum order is 50
No zone restrictions
shipping unchecked
uses per coupon 999
uses per customer 1

Restrictions:
ALL - Deny
Product restrictions:
My selected product - Allow

When i look up my discount coupon i get the following:
Discount Coupon Restrictions

Category Restrictions:


(Not allowed on this category)
Product Restrictions:


Panola Bat`s Brew (Valid for this product)
My issue is when it comes to step 3 in checkout - I get the confirmation "your discount coupon has been applied" But down under order total is is NOT applied. I have found through hours of testing that if i allow the entire category it will apply and add the discount, so i have not found a way to sucessfuly set this up.

IDEALLY - i would like a way to automaticaly make this product FREE ONLY with orders over $50 without having to enter the coupon code, OR upon entering a coupon code have the product added to cart with no charge.

Any help is greatly appriciated! Thank you!