If this is your first visit, check our documentation. To post, register or login.
Forums / Upgrading to 1.5.x / Beta over protected?

Beta over protected?

Locked

Started by asekeris on 14 Aug 2011, 12:07 PM · Views: 7,757

Results 1 to 20 of 40
This thread is locked. New replies are disabled.
14 Aug 2011, 12:07 PM
#1
asekeris avatar

asekeris

New Zenner

Join Date:
Mar 2006
Location:
Zevenbergen, NL
Posts:
40
Plugin Contributions:
0

Beta over protected?

After playing around for a while with the Beta 1.5 i have some concerns about the new protection model and it appears to me as over-protected.

First i will make clear that i am thankfull for all the work the developers are putting in ZC and that this in no way is an attack but just some considerations that may or may not appeal to other users.

While i never used credit-cards and do not intend to use them in the future i see the fixed password renewal period of 90 days as very restrictive.
I am not against this forced renewal but 90 days is to short and an adjustable period should be appreciated.
It gives a high load maintaning double passwords (user/super user) for multiple stores.

I always used the admin-profiles addon to cleanup the admin from unused menu items to keep it usable on lower screen resolutions and not for additional users.
In the new implementation i am forced to create a second user to get this behaviour meaning i have to remember a second username/password multiplied by the number of stores that has to be renewed every 90 days.
(I think my most visited page will be 'password forgotten' in the future.)

So a config setting for this PA-DSS (on/off) and password renewal time (90-365) would be appreciated.
Also making the the profile of the super-user editable would make sense to me.

In al those years i never locked out myself by changing the profile and some self discipline may be expected from the users.
(Do you refuse to learn your kid how to walk just because of the risk that he could fall.)

14 Aug 2011, 12:32 PM
#2
kuroi avatar

kuroi

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2006
Location:
London, UK
Posts:
10,475
Plugin Contributions:
11

Re: Beta over protected?

I don't think you'll find many people that disagree with your sentiments. Trouble is, if Zen Cart is to be PA-DSS-compliant, it's the view of the people writing and interpreting the PA-DSS requirements that end up making the decisions.

However ...

Minimum password renewal frequency is mandated by the regs. Zen Cart is already using the longest allowable, so any adjustment period would need to be capped at 90 days.

And a config setting that allowed the features that had to be built in to meet PA-DSS requirements be turned off would prevent PA-DSS compliance from be granted.

On the question of the Superuser profile being editable, that's not technically possible as super users (you can have more than one) bypass the profile system when accessing menus and pages - that's what makes them super users.

There has to be one, in that one is created during installation / upgrade, and it's not possible to delete the last one for user protection. I appreciate your diligence in never locking yourself out, but other people do make mistakes and there are regular forum requests from users in a panic on this specific issue. There's a reason why the relevant FAQ article was the second to be added.

But that doesn't mean that you have to maintain a superuser. If you're not going to use it, create the user profile you want and just forget about the super user.

Kuroi Web Design and Development | Twitter

(Questions answered in the forum only - so that any forum member can benefit - not by personal message)

14 Aug 2011, 1:10 PM
#3
asekeris avatar

asekeris

New Zenner

Join Date:
Mar 2006
Location:
Zevenbergen, NL
Posts:
40
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

I understand that regs have to be followed to get the certification and again i see a beautfull open source project killed by external regulations.
Not dived into the source code yet but this over burocratic ruleset leaving no room for other applications of the software package is asking for a tweake branch of the main program.
(I have read all the docs regarding this issue so i know the limitations imposed by it)
This certification is killing for showcase only application and those not using credit cards in any way.

I will wait for the final release and then see if i can make an uncertified version because i love ZC to much to abandon it.

14 Aug 2011, 5:33 PM
#4
rstevenson avatar

rstevenson

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Nov 2006
Location:
Dartmouth, NS Canada
Posts:
2,400
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

I too feel the 90 day rollover for admin passwords is awful. But the 'crats in control of PA-DSS have made up their minds and musn't be confused with other opinions. But let's take a poll: hold your hand up if you think a password requirement that forces people to write the password down is a good idea. ... Nobody? Right!

Rob

Breakfast: the most important donut of the day.

14 Aug 2011, 6:00 PM
#5
asekeris avatar

asekeris

New Zenner

Join Date:
Mar 2006
Location:
Zevenbergen, NL
Posts:
40
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

kuroi:

But that doesn't mean that you have to maintain a superuser. If you're not going to use it, create the user profile you want and just forget about the super user.

I do not think that it will work that way because afer installing a mod that creates an extra admin page access has to be granted by..... right the superuser.

And that was the main reason for using the old add-on to make room in the menu's for extra menu points for those who dont use a 32" screen or bigger.
(My mainly used screen is only 10" with a resolution of 1024x600pixels)

14 Aug 2011, 6:16 PM
#6
kuroi avatar

kuroi

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2006
Location:
London, UK
Posts:
10,475
Plugin Contributions:
11

Re: Beta over protected?

asekeris:

I do not think that it will work that way because afer installing a mod that creates an extra admin page access has to be granted by..... right the superuser.That's not correct. Access can be granted by anybody who has the profiles page in their profile. There's no need for them to be a superuser.

Kuroi Web Design and Development | Twitter

(Questions answered in the forum only - so that any forum member can benefit - not by personal message)

14 Aug 2011, 11:45 PM
#7
design75 avatar

design75

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Dec 2009
Location:
Amersfoort, The Netherlands
Posts:
2,862
Plugin Contributions:
5

Re: Beta over protected?

Why not make it optional to make zen PA-DSS-compliant. I don't care it is compliant but love zen cart. To renew my password every 90 days seems to be ridiculous.

The easiest way would be to make an admin option with a warning not being PA-DSS-compliant, and let me choose to be compliant or not, or am I missing something in the big picture?

14 Aug 2011, 11:58 PM
#8
Kim avatar

Kim

Obaa-san

Join Date:
Jun 2003
Location:
West Coast, North America
Posts:
26,747
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

Perhaps you'll complain to the PCI/credit card folks? It is their rule and to get PA-DSS Certified, we have to follow the rules.

Please do not PM for support issues: a private solution doesn't benefit the community.

Be careful with unsolicited advice via email or PM - Make sure the person you are talking to is a reliable source.

15 Aug 2011, 7:45 AM
#9
asekeris avatar

asekeris

New Zenner

Join Date:
Mar 2006
Location:
Zevenbergen, NL
Posts:
40
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

This ask for a new mod for those not willing to follow the PA-DSS rules where some settings could be altered and keep the core system ready for certification.

Most of the rules make sense and should be left untouched where others beg for tweaking if you don't need this certification.
Let the team do their good work and when it is released dive in the code to make a nice tweak for this point because everything what smells like relaxation of the rules would prevent certification.

15 Aug 2011, 12:13 PM
#10
vger avatar

vger

Past Contributor

Join Date:
Nov 2004
Location:
Norfolk, United Kingdom
Posts:
3,189
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

Trying to have a cart which can maintain PA/DSS Certification may not be so much a "Holy Grail" as a "Poisoned Chalice". Why? Because they keep changing their requirements - always increasing security levels - and so the cart will have to be constantly updated to keep up with their changes. And site owners, who already have a lamentable record when it comes to upgrading, will have to constantly upgrade to maintain PA/DSS Certification.

It's only my 2c worth, so feel free to ignore it, but my view is that only commercial software such as Magento Enterprise Edition (where site owners pay big bucks to keep it updated for them) will be able to keep up with these requirements. I can't see an Open Source cart being able to do it.

Vger

16 Aug 2011, 9:51 AM
#13
dutchy avatar

dutchy

Zen Follower

Join Date:
May 2010
Location:
London
Posts:
324
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

I said a while back when the plans for for 1.5 were released that I didn’t think it was a good idea. Yeah it's great ZC will be the first open source free cart system that will be PCI Certified. But that surely sets a precedent for all ZC versions, 1.5a … 1.5k … 1.6.3b ...1.9.9z. Or whatever the version numbers are that will come.

If the devs don't mind maintaining this additional millstone around their neck, then it's great for the ZC community, brand, product and a brilliant idea. But as Vger pointed out, it is only the big players that offer PCI certified versions. I would imagine that is a resource hungry process, possibly the reason behind the ZC financial restructuring?

Is this PCI Certified move an attempt to attract big multimillion pound/dollar/euro companies into the fold of ZC? I believe many have 1.3.9h PCI certified up to level 3? I personally would like to think that once my online stores moved into the requirements of PCI level 2 certification I would either be retired and out of the 'hands on' online side, or be able to employ an in house team, using either a bespoke system or Magento Enterprise as the core. :ohmy:

Almost all decent add-ons are now broken, which isn’t a problem if the add-on developers can rewrite them to suit 1.5. But more critically, are the bosses in charge of ZC going to implement a system that all add-ons for 1.5 must pass / not break PCI Certification. Otherwise, many peoples ZC site will not be PCI certified. And a standard 'out of the box' ZC install lacks too many features of other 'out of the box' installs from rivals, thus many add-ons are required to provide a modern dynamic online business.

While I think the 1.5 security focused rewrite is a good idea to force better security procedures, like Mr Kuroi's Admin Profiles system, I cannot help but wonder if better time, effort, money and energy would not be better placed on the development of 2.0? Unless, as I stated many many months ago, is this a means of giving a few years breathing space for the release of 2.0? As all add-ons etc will have to be rewritten from the ground up for 2.0 :shocking:

Sorry, I know many will disagree, but I can't help but feel that the focus to be PCI certified is pissing into the wind.

You may now open fire.

16 Aug 2011, 10:06 AM
#14
kuroi avatar

kuroi

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2006
Location:
London, UK
Posts:
10,475
Plugin Contributions:
11

Re: Beta over protected?

I share yours and Vger's concerns about the additional overhead, as well as the sometimes counter-productive restrictions that it seems to place on the functionality required or forbidden; but I think you've got the motivations backwards.

This is bringing a level of security previously only available to the big boys down to stores of any size. It's not at all an attempt to attract big stores to Zen Cart. Personally I'd like to see more of that anyway, as the combination of rich functionality and a relatively efficient engine means that it's capable of supporting them.

I wouldn't overplay the "all decent mods are broken" concern either. They're only really affected if they add admin pages and even then it just means that pages now need to be registered by a small bit of SQL rather than a box file.

Ideally mods would also be upgraded to meet the new security standards, and I think that will happen over time as mod authors get used to them. But just adding the SQL will be enough to get most running as they did before.

Kuroi Web Design and Development | Twitter

(Questions answered in the forum only - so that any forum member can benefit - not by personal message)

16 Aug 2011, 10:14 AM
#15
dutchy avatar

dutchy

Zen Follower

Join Date:
May 2010
Location:
London
Posts:
324
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

Actually, I never thought about it in that way. Giving the smaller stores the same security muscles as the big stores. Nice pointer.

And for the OP, I force password changes on admin's every 30 days and rename my admin every quarter or when an admin level member of staff leaves. There should be no need to write passwords down! A bit of mental effort from them to remember it is not that hard. In fact, it's just lazy of them to not try and remember a password.

16 Aug 2011, 10:56 AM
#16
frank18 avatar

frank18

Deceased

Join Date:
Nov 2007
Location:
Sunny Coast, Australia
Posts:
3,427
Plugin Contributions:
2

Re: Beta over protected?

ZC 1.5 Beta over protected?

I don't think so. In the "cyber world" you can never have enough protection. It really is a matter of being ahead of the game. What is safe today may not be that safe anymore tomorrow - thanks to some malicious individuals.

Bear in mind that you need the trust of your customers to shop with you. If you (or the software that you are running) are your customer's money at risk then that can easily be the end of your business and indeed the end of your reputation.

Building trust and confidence with customers is tough enough, getting either of them back is a mighty hard task.

ZC 1.5 Beta over protected? Definitely not!

NOTE: We are sorry that Frank is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

16 Aug 2011, 7:01 PM
#17
mshultise avatar

mshultise

Zen Follower

Join Date:
Feb 2005
Location:
Captain Cook, Hawaii
Posts:
172
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

I wonder if ZC could be modified to not include CC modules and have a different version number, thus it would not be a PCI compliant version.

I well understand the needs of PCI for credit cards and other security items added to make the carts secure, but we all know that with a 90 day password requirement, SOMEBODY will be writing down the current password on their screens. (Somebody is not me, but I'm just saying).

I manage perhaps 10 carts at this time and will have to come up with some type of system. Often I have to access these systems remotely while traveling.

I still like the idea of the ID KEY I use for Paypal. The website tells me enter in the secret code which my phone app generates (similar to a security key token).

Aloha from Hawaii! (its a dirty job, but SOMEBODY has to live here...)

16 Aug 2011, 7:11 PM
#18
drbyte avatar

drbyte

Sensei

Join Date:
Jan 2004
Posts:
63,512
Plugin Contributions:
176

Re: Beta over protected?

mshultise:

I wonder if ZC could be modified to not include CC modules and have a different version number, thus it would not be a PCI compliant version.That still doesn't negate the need for PCI compliance.

mshultise:

I still like the idea of the ID KEY I use for Paypal. The website tells me enter in the secret code which my phone app generates (similar to a security key token).And you can do that with Zen Cart too. You'll have to write your own integration for it, but two-factor authentication mechanisms are supported. But that's going completely off topic. And you'd still need your password :P

.
Zen Cart - putting the dream of business ownership within reach of anyone!
Donate to: DrByte directly or to the Zen Cart team as a whole

Remember: Any code suggestions you see here are merely suggestions. You assume full responsibility for your use of any such suggestions, including any impact ANY alterations you make to your site may have on your PCI compliance.
Furthermore, any advice you see here about PCI matters is merely an opinion, and should not be relied upon as "official". Official PCI information should be obtained from the PCI Security Council directly or from one of their authorized Assessors.

17 Aug 2011, 1:21 PM
#19
jund avatar

jund

Zen Follower

Join Date:
Sep 2006
Location:
Ruckersville, VA, USA
Posts:
276
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

For the past 4 weeks I have been working - reworking a 1.3.8 site that was hacked. This morning I installed a test site using 1.50 beta. Congratulations to the ZENCART Team for really doing it right. The install was SMOOOOTH - thank you!
Why am I stating this on this forum. The protection afforded our customers (PCI compiance etc) is EXTREMELY important. Hackers really do not care - however, we acting as web developers want to always ensure our customers - and all ZENCART "customers" are afforded the best possible security. Perhaps I am preaching to the choir, but the choir knows the song!
Thank you ZENCART team. I still have only one question - do you ever sleep? (the hackers certainly do not).
Respectfully,
jund (John Underwood)

17 Aug 2011, 2:37 PM
#20
vger avatar

vger

Past Contributor

Join Date:
Nov 2004
Location:
Norfolk, United Kingdom
Posts:
3,189
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Beta over protected?

do you ever sleep? (the hackers certainly do not)

Hackers do sleep, but unfortunately they exist in every time zone around the world. So unless you can montor your site 24/7/365 then they have an edge on you.

Vger