Taking a look at texaslonestartamalesDOTcom, one might be inclined to agree that Zen Cart is lacking. That is one sharp site. I'll wait while you take a look.....
This store is built with shopify and is one of the better ones I've seen. Visually. But just like car shopping years ago, I like to look under the hood.
Let's take the home page. I like to look at sites with an incognito Chrome window. That way the 200 or so extensions don't get in the way of the evaluation.
Lighthouse check for desktop: The score is 38, 90, 83, 92 and in order, they represent Performance, Accessibility, Best Practices, and SEO. Right away you can see that they are trying to respond to the current "things". Accessibility and SEO. But at what cost? Time to Interactive clocks in at 9.4 Seconds! :shocking:
Maybe they wanted it to really kick in mobile. Let's see. Lighthouse mobile comes up with..... Ladies and gentlemen, your first lotto number from the lighthouse is..... ?
Yep, it's a question mark with a statement that took too long to wake up and Lighthoused baled. BUT, Accessibility and SEO are 90 and 92 respectively. Yay!
Well, let's look a little deeper. When it comes to CSS, the site has 212 errors and 1,106 warnings. Even with CSS being one of the most forgiving parts of a website creation, there's going to be problems.
An HTML check shows just seventeen mentions on the page BUT, the last says:
Fatal Error: Cannot recover after last error. Any further errors will be ignored.
A simple look at WebAIM's WAVE shows 45 errors, 56 Contrast Errors, and 95 alerts. You can't run axe DevTools incognito but, run in regular chrome, it shows 18 critical, 20 serious, and 32 moderate violations of ADA/WCAG. Oh, and, 102 other items "need review." Not a glowing resume if you ask me. I bet they don't offer a Display Log Files mod. It would be a good reason to charge more though. Every other day, you could say, "You're running out of disk space....Want to add more?"
You seem to think that ZC will not keep running or that the brain pool will dry up. I felt somewhat the same way when ceon (conor) passed. Actually, if the dates in the membership list are correct, I've been here almost the longest. I'm in the top five of "oldtimers" at least. So, I feel I can speak of what was, what is, and what will be.
I've see more exciting things in the last two years than all the others here with ZC. Prior to this, the PCI certification was the highlight and something never before accomplished by any e-commerce platform that i know of. We could probably still have it today if we had the money.
What we do have is dedicated folks that step up to fill the gaps. GitHub is far more active than before. And producing more.
I'm just not so sure that folks who don't ever "check their oil" are going to realize the size of engine under our hood.
There's a site called Top10 that, for some reason, could only come up with six platforms that they consider the best.
Being involved with ADA/WCAG for many years, I decided to do a survey of those six platforms. In several, I was able to find sites using the product. In some cases, I had to rely on the home page of the company. If anybody should get it right......
I invite you to view a PDF of the test results between those six and 1.5.8's recent drop. jeandretDOTcom/download/zenCartStats.pdf just might make you feel better. It might even surprise you a bunch.
Ever since the branch off from OSC, ZC maintenance has been like changing a tire, at speed, on the freeway. Changing PHP versions have been the shredded tire in the middle of the road in that process. Just when you think you missed one....
IMHO, we're getting closer to all tires rotated, balanced, and operational. With a new acrylic wrap, the massive engine underneath will keep ZC rolling for quite some time.
LMK