If this is your first visit, check our documentation. To post, register or login.
Forums / Other Business Topics / Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Started by feznizzle on 21 Dec 2012, 12:30 PM · Views: 6,356

Results 1 to 20 of 624
21 Dec 2012, 12:30 PM
#1
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Hello,

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

I am about to install a zc (probably v151) for a client. This will be a heavily modified cart with tons of goodies. It will feature numerous manufacturers and thousands of products.

I figure this will take me around 2 months to complete, so I am EXTREMELY interested in thinking it out before I start.

I am currently trying to figure out the most efficient way to streamline the entire project. Here is the current order I am thinking:

  1. Install ZC
  2. Install a lean template
  3. Install mods (below are the main ones, roughly in the order I'm thinking):
  • EZ Page Meta
  • Ceon URI
  • Image Handler
  • Lightbox
  • Google Merchant Feeder
  • XML sitemap
  • EZ populate
  • UPS, Fedex, Fedex LTL
  • Sales Tax Lookup
  1. Turn on payment mods (authorize.net & Paypal)
  2. Site content
  • Basic pages (About Us, Contact Us, Privacy Policy, etc)
  • Manufacturer pages
  • Products
  1. Customize CSS

I think that pretty much covers the basic process. The only major thing I might consider is moving #5 up to #3. But I expect my client to bog me down during the Content phase, I can kill time playing with CSS and working out kinks. Plus this order gives me 3 relatively fast/clean spots to get paid (1st to initiate, 2nd after backend finished, 3rd upon completion).

Do you think this is a good order of operations? Do you have another method you finds works well? Any suggestions for me?

Thanks,
Mike

21 Dec 2012, 1:04 PM
#2
schoolboy avatar

schoolboy

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jun 2005
Location:
Cumbria, UK
Posts:
10,327
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

1,2, and 3 are logical... As for the rest, it doesn't really matter. I wouldn't bother with the URI mapping either. It serves no functionally useful purpose and makes zero contribution to "seo". Many sad people still believe that it does - but it doesn't. However... if you want "pretty url's", then CEON URI Mapping is probably the safest mod to use. All the other so-called "SEO URL" modules are extremely unreliable and very, very risky. They can do untold damage to your site.

20 years a Zencart User

21 Dec 2012, 2:03 PM
#3
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Good stuff, thanks.

With regard to the URI mapping, clients want what clients want. I have experience with CEON URI, agree it is the best of the bunch, and will be cautious.

22 Dec 2012, 12:50 PM
#4
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

With regard to the URI mapping, clients want what clients want.

Consider your clients as though they were kids in a toy store.

They are naturally going to want a ton of stuff that isn't good or suitable for them. As a person that should know better than to give into their whims, it is your job to educate them why they shouldn't play with some toys, at least until they get a little older and wiser, by which time they'll have probably grown out of it anyway.

Also bear in mind that your clients' aren't 'customers' in the traditional sense. They aren't 'always right', and some clients may wish you to do something unethical or illegal. Just because they want it doesn't mean you should do it, especially when it is your head on the chopping block.

As for the planned upgrade, that's pretty much the order I do things, so nothing wrong there. I'm somewhat amused at your anticipated timeframe though. Steps#1 & 2 should take no more than an hour or so. Tops.

Step#3
8 or 9 mods ... lets say 60 mins each, on average, including possible troubleshooting. (an experienced zenner could probably only allow 15-20mins each and still have time to spare).

Step#4.
5 seconds (I love this one) <g>

Step#5.
Allow half day (minimum).
Assuming the site isn't static, and new products are continually being added, this particular step never really ends.

Step#6 (customise CSS)... as you suggested, I'd be inclined to move this up to step#3, because it has as much to do with appearance/layout as the templates. Best to get the look & feel right before adding products.

So, there's a good day's or weekend's work involved there (taking it kinda leisurely, and allowing for one or two hiccups), so that's going to give you 2 months minus two days to add content... Sounds good to me :)

Seriously, I'm not trying to stir you up here, but I do expect that once you actually start the project it will go a LOT easier than you are anticipating (doubly so considering you are taking the precaution of documenting what add-ons, etc, you will be needing), as this will go a long way to helping ensure things are done in an orderly fashion.

I'd wish you good luck, but it's really not needed :)

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

22 Dec 2012, 4:49 PM
#5
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Glad I could provide you with a spot of entertainment, Rod! :)

Not to ruin the fun for you, but the only items that appear on my list above are those that directly effect Zen. Time will get eaten up between the lines. My interest (reason for posting the question) was in getting the Order of Operation for Zen correct. The reason I decided to ask is that, as you so happily point out, I am not an overly experienced Zenner… I have only installed ZC on sites 6 or 7 times, spread out over a few years.

Why try to get Order of Ops right? Trial and error can get excruciating. Probably the most painful lesson I have learned with Zen is this: Template BEFORE mods.

You have no idea how many bloody tears that one little tidbit cost me! Oh man oh man. :)

As you point out, back end stuff (even allowing for everything not on my list above) should go pretty quick. I expect it will take me only about 3 weeks before I can turn my focus to content.

That in mind, I think I agree with you on moving the CSS up. I should have plenty of time to do the majority of styling. I just always have a hard time with that when I don't have real content to apply styles to. :(

With regard to your sermon on ethics, I more or less agree with you. But what my client wants is actually immaterial in this case since the truth of the matter is that Ceon URI was my suggestion. I firmly believe that the dynamic gobblety gook url's generated by ZC are a messy waste of a potential opportunity. I think that key word loading of URL's most likely does help with SE rankings and has a positive psychological effect on human eyes. And even if it doesn't actual influence SE rankings, "cleaned up" url's that provide clues about the destination are MUCH better.

I am not alone in my opinions. If you look at the URL of this page, you will see that the folks who run this forum also load key words into the URL. So I am in good company.

Further I think the gentleman who wrote this particular mod is brilliant. I find the mod to be elegant, having minimal effect on performance causing next to no problems (I have yet to find a conflict that was not my own fault). Having found no real reason NOT to use this mod, I have chosen to use it.

So why did I say "clients want what clients want"?

Because I have a very deep respect for Schoolboy. He has helped me personally on numerous occasions. For each time he answered me directly, there are probably 20 times he helped me without even knowing it by answering other people. Having followed many, many threads up here, I have become quite familiar with his positions on SEO matters… particularly URL and meta tagging, two subjects I tend to disagree with him on.

Three opinions I have: I am indeed a novice (but getting better) at Zen; I'm alright with ethics (won't make sites that sell AR-15's to children); and I'm a badass when it comes to SEO.

But I respect Schoolboys well stated stance on the matter of keyword loading of URLs. Schoolboy freely gives so much of his time advising all us poor lost novices on this forum. I don't see the logic in engaging and possibly irritating the man. I'd rather just let it slide quietly.

So pawning the responsibility off on my client was an effort to respectfully obviate the subject without challenging the validity of anyone's core beliefs.

Sorry, Schoolboy, but I do disagree on the subject. Hope you understand why I wasn't more forthcoming about it, though.

Thanks a lot, Rod. Why'd you have to call me out? :)

22 Dec 2012, 4:51 PM
#6
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

BTW, hope the tone of that came thru with smiles! I neglected to thank you for your input Rod.... thanks! I will be following your suggestion and moving the CSS up.

TTFN,
Mike

23 Dec 2012, 3:30 AM
#7
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

The reason I decided to ask is that, as you so happily point out, I am not an overly experienced Zenner… I have only installed ZC on sites 6 or 7 times, spread out over a few years.

I pointed out no such thing. I had no idea what your experience level was, which is why I indicated 2 possible timeframes.. One for the more experienced zenner, one for the less experienced. I left it entirely up to you to decide which category best suited you.

Feznizzle:

Why try to get Order of Ops right? Trial and error can get excruciating. Probably the most painful lesson I have learned with Zen is this: Template BEFORE mods.

Did I dispute this, or suggest it was a waste of time, or similar? Not that I'm aware of. I suggested this was a good thing, and will probably save you a few headaches in the longer term.

Feznizzle:

You have no idea how many bloody tears that one little tidbit cost me! Oh man oh man. :)

Oh, but I do. Most of us have already gone this same route and made the exact same mistakes. I know I have.

Feznizzle:

As you point out, back end stuff (even allowing for everything not on my list above) should go pretty quick. I expect it will take me only about 3 weeks before I can turn my focus to content.

I still say it'll take you no longer than a weekend :)

Feznizzle:

With regard to your sermon on ethics, I more or less agree with you.

I don't care if you agree or not. Just as I don't care if people dissagree with me when I say 2+2=4 and they claim 2+2=5.
It frustrates me no end that these people ignore facts in order to hang on to their own beliefs, and I'll often go out of my way teach the facts to those that haven't yet been blinded, but the bottom line is, if people wish to believe in myths then who am I to destroy their faith?

Feznizzle:

But what my client wants is actually immaterial in this case since the truth of the matter is that Ceon URI was my suggestion.

Now this annoys me. As a developer you should know better.

Feznizzle:

I firmly believe that the dynamic gobblety gook url's generated by ZC are a messy waste of a potential opportunity.

There's that word 'believe' again. I really don't know how to state this in any other way than being blunt, but what you, I or anyone else 'believes' is totally irrelevant. Facts don't change according to beliefs.

Feznizzle:

I think that key word loading of URL's most likely does help with SE rankings

This was a valid statement a decade ago. Fact.
Keyword loading in todays environment doesn't help with SE rankings. Fact.
Keyword loading (especially invalid keywords) in URL's can have a detrimental effect on SE rankings. Fact.

Feznizzle:

and has a positive psychological effect on human eyes.

Interesting how you imply that both of these can be true. They can't. They pretty much cancel each other out. Keywords in URL's are good for humans, but very, very bad in regards to SE rankings. The human unfriendly URL's (such as a link to a particular cart/category/item) are where the search engines 'shine'.

Feznizzle:

And even if it doesn't actual influence SE rankings,

Is this an actual admission that you aren't really sure if it helps or not? That's the way I'm reading it.
Now contrast this to what people such as myself state... We don't have these same doubts. Nor should we. Fact are facts.

Feznizzle:

"cleaned up" url's that provide clues about the destination are MUCH better.

Fact: Most people don't look at the google links before clicking. Most don't CARE what a URL looks like (unless asked to type it in, which considering we are discussing the use of search engines, is something they will never be asked/required to do)

Feznizzle:

I am not alone in my opinions.

No you are not. Guess what. you are all wrong. This really has nothing to do with 'opinions', simply because computers don't have 'opinions'. Google doesn't have an opinion, neither does bing, nor the others.

A site achieves good (and bad) rankings based on solid mathematical principles. 2+2=4 regardless of whether it is believed or not.

Feznizzle:

If you look at the URL of this page, you will see that the folks who run this forum also load key words into the URL. So I am in good company.

I'm a little confused here in that I'm not quite sure whether you are saying the URL for this page
http://www.zen-cart.com/showthread.php?203958-Most-efficient-order-of-install-%28site-template-mods-then-products-%29
is a 'good' one or a 'bad' one? It has elements of being both SE friendly and Human Friendly.

Feznizzle:

Further I think the gentleman who wrote this particular mod is brilliant.

He is also recently deceased :( (4th Dec 2012 as I recall)

Feznizzle:

I find the mod to be elegant, having minimal effect on performance

Is this a measured minimal effect, or a perceived minimal effect?
Not that this is particularly important these days (computer processing speeds are magnitudes faster than networking speeds), but in times gone past, even a moderate amount of URL rewriting could have a noticeable effect on a sites performance. It's all very well to argue that todays faster computers have pretty much eliminated this problem, but it still means the site is performing at well below what it is actually capable of.

Feznizzle:

causing next to no problems (I have yet to find a conflict that was not my own fault). Having found no real reason NOT to use this mod, I have chosen to use it.

So, if I create a mod that I claim will boost your site performance by 50%, you would be happy to use it because you haven't found a reason not to? even if/when I tell you that under the hood the module isn't actually doing anything useful?

OK, you probably won't fall for this one... unless perhaps I recruit a few friends to start telling people how great it is.... :)

This is exactly where you appear to be with this module. You have no real proof that it works. In fact several times now you have unintentionally acknowledged that there is the possibility it doesn't work, yet you still choose to hang on to this belief... probably to the detriment of your clients.

I recently expounded in another thread that one of the worst things a person can do is to set up a brand new website and then immediately start to add redirection to it, yet this is exactly what many people do. Common sense would suggest that it would be far better to set things up correctly in the first place so that redirection are not needed. SE's really don't like redirections as they invariably result in duplicate content, and every SEO expert I know will tell you (rightly or wrongly) that duplicated content will get a site penalized.

I just love the way SEO experts continually contradict themselves in this manner :)

Feznizzle:

So why did I say "clients want what clients want"?

Easy. People Lie.

Feznizzle:

Because I have a very deep respect for Schoolboy. He has helped me personally on numerous occasions. For each time he answered me directly, there are probably 20 times he helped me without even knowing it by answering other people. Having followed many, many threads up here, I have become quite familiar with his positions on SEO matters… particularly URL and meta tagging, two subjects I tend to disagree with him on.

I'm kinda surprised you haven't come across my views on this matter too then. Schoolboy and I have very similar views in this regard. Like Schoolboy I was around long before Google was even thought of, we've grown up seeing search engines come and go.
Unlike Schoolboy though, I've been a coder/developer most of this time, and much of my early work revolved around creating and/or working with indexing software for our own site (this was quite a big deal 15years ago).
As a result I do have quite a good understanding as to how the search engines actually work, how they assign various values to things like keywords, metadata, content, URL length, domains vs subdomains vs folders, and a lot of the other stuff that gets collectively grouped under the "SEO" banner.

It's not a religion. It's a science, based on hard solid facts.
We can present the facts to you, we can't make you accept them.

Feznizzle:

Three opinions I have: I am indeed a novice (but getting better) at Zen; I'm alright with ethics (won't make sites that sell AR-15's to children); and I'm a badass when it comes to SEO.

Shame that you have the priority wrong. To benefit your clients you need to be an expert at Zen and a complete novice at SEO.

Feznizzle:

But I respect Schoolboys well stated stance on the matter of keyword loading of URLs. Schoolboy freely gives so much of his time advising all us poor lost novices on this forum. I don't see the logic in engaging and possibly irritating the man. I'd rather just let it slide quietly.)

Pity. If you've already learned so much from him, what makes you so adamant that he is wrong about this?

Feznizzle:

So pawning the responsibility off on my client was an effort to respectfully obviate the subject without challenging the validity of anyone's core beliefs.

People need their core belief’s to be challenged, how else are they supposed to maintain their faith?

Thankfully, belief doesn't play a part here. It's science and numbers.

Feznizzle:

Sorry, Schoolboy, but I do disagree on the subject. Hope you understand why I wasn't more forthcoming about it, though.)

You were ashamed to stand up for your beliefs? <g>

That's the nice thing about facts. It doesn't matter whether they are believed or not. The simply are!

Feznizzle:

Thanks a lot, Rod. Why'd you have to call me out? :)

LOL... because that's my nature :)

Seriously though, I don't/didn't do so with any ill intent or malice, and I know I come across as being very arrogant (but this is only true when I'm 99.9% sure of my facts), my intent has been, and always will be to share some of my many, many years of knowledge and experience (and perhaps learn a bit more as I go). It is hard for me to be wishy-washy and make statements like "I beleive" when 'belief' doesn't enter the equation, so I don't apologise for this.

Anyway, in closing, consider this:

The aim of Google, etc is to present people with the most suitable match(es) for any search query, correct?

In order to do this it needs to perform two functions:

  1. Index the most relevant data.
  2. Ignore the least relevant data.

In order to do this, each site and page is indexed to produce a rated score.
With no 'SEO' in place all sites are effectively equal, other than the site content. This is the aim of all search engines... to provide a balanced playing field according to content. That's how they started.

Now, along comes a few enterprising individuals that discover they can 'do things' to give their site a higher ranking than it would normally achieve.. This is the essence of SEO.

The google/SE maintainers started to see the things that the SEO 'experts' were doing to artificially increase their rankings, and took steps to re-level the playing field by penalizing these 'optimised' sites.
The SEO experts then started looking at other methods to give thier stores an unfair advantage, Google picked up on these and the algorithms were again changed to prevent the unfair advantage.
This same scenario has now been going on for years.... with the SEO experts trying to 'cheat' the system, and the SE maintainers in a constant battle to keep the field level (content is king). It is a never ending battle that the SEO experts can never win... They are for all intents and purposes working against the aims of the search engines.. How can this be a "good" thing?
At best, the end result is that a site gets a bit of a boost as new 'cheats' are discovered, only to be penalised for using them a short while later when the SE's cotton on to whats going on and take steps to prevent further cheats of a similar nature.

Meanwhile, there are millions of sites out there with no SEO whatsover.. Google will come along and index these sites and give them higher rankings because they are not using any of the SEO 'cheat' methods.

Now, with this (mostly factual) situation in mind, who is going to come out better of in the long term, the sites that rely on nothing more than good content in order to get good rankings, or those sites that are playing the eternal cat-n-mouse 'lets beat the system' type sites?

My money says that those that concentrate on site content, rather than chasing after rankings are going to end up in a far, far better position than the others.
This is already a well known fact.

Important caveat: Please don't confuse "SEO optimisition" with Google's "Site recommendations". They are not the same thing (although unsurprisingly many of the suggestions are identical for both).

SEO's are/were designed to give sites an unfair advantage. Site recommendations are designed to give the best site exposure without resorting to 'cheats'. A big difference.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

23 Dec 2012, 5:32 AM
#8
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Rod,

I came in, saw how long your post was. I got all excited, expected a witty exchange. And then I had to stop...

RodG:

He is also recently deceased :( (4th Dec 2012 as I recall)

I had not heard. Last time I talked to Conor (months ago) he seemed to be in a better spirits. Man. #$%@. Wow. That really bites.

I really didn't know him well, only enough to know that he was a very sweet guy. And, as I alluded to early, I think he is... was a brilliant guy. :(

That more or less took the wind out of my sails. It is after midnight here in the states, so I'm going to hit the sack.

I will read the rest now, reply in the morn. I'm sure you wait will with bated breath! :)

23 Dec 2012, 6:32 AM
#9
drbyte avatar

drbyte

Sensei

Join Date:
Jan 2004
Posts:
63,512
Plugin Contributions:
176

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

.
Zen Cart - putting the dream of business ownership within reach of anyone!
Donate to: DrByte directly or to the Zen Cart team as a whole

Remember: Any code suggestions you see here are merely suggestions. You assume full responsibility for your use of any such suggestions, including any impact ANY alterations you make to your site may have on your PCI compliance.
Furthermore, any advice you see here about PCI matters is merely an opinion, and should not be relied upon as "official". Official PCI information should be obtained from the PCI Security Council directly or from one of their authorized Assessors.

23 Dec 2012, 6:36 AM
#10
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Thanks, DrByte.

23 Dec 2012, 9:12 PM
#11
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Ok, I guess I'm ready to deal with this now.

Seriously though, I don't/didn't do so with any ill intent or malice, and I know I come across as being very arrogant (but this is only true when I'm 99.9% sure of my facts), my intent has been, and always will be to share some of my many, many years of knowledge and experience (and perhaps learn a bit more as I go). It is hard for me to be wishy-washy and make statements like "I beleive" when 'belief' doesn't enter the equation, so I don't apologise for this.

I can admit, you ruffled my feathers a bit. But thanks for owning the arrogant tone, that was big of you. I mean that sincerely. You are clearly a thinker and not just trying to be mean.

** **

People need their core belief’s to be challenged, how else are they supposed to maintain their faith?

Thankfully, belief doesn't play a part here. It's science and numbers.

The first part seems like an invitation ("people need their core belief’s to be challenged"). The second part sounds like certitude that your core beliefs will stand up to challenge. And of course, the core belief is that you know as FACT that key word loaded URLs make no difference at all to people making searches on Google. Correct?

Hmm. A wager? No. That might offend. Let me ponder.

You know, you bring up religion. I find this interesting, especially in how you apply it here. I bet you either believe in God… or don't believe in a God. Yea. I think there is a good chance you are an atheist. Or maybe a good Christian (though my first guess would be atheist). But is there any other choice? Either there is a God or there isn't, right?

Yes, there is another choice, one which recognizes a huge weakness in the question itself: impossibility of absolute (perfect) knowledge. I approach life, everything from business opportunities to love to web work, with a grain of agnosticism. This includes SEO (maybe especially).

Sorry, I digress. Nothing like a death to get me waxing philosophic.

Anyway.

Yea, I like the idea of a wager. A gentleman's wager. If you take my challenge and I can prove that 2+2 is indeed 5 in my very next post on the subject, then you have to make a change on your Zen-Cart forum profile and leave it up there for one month. But if my next post does not convince you that key word loading of URLs does indeed help to bring traffic from Google, then I will make the same change and leave it up for a month.

Whoever loses the wager must add the following words to their profile (can be added by hitting the "interest" button):
"My Argument is Invalid"

:)

What do you think, mate? You've got math and science on your side, right? This is an honor thing, all you have to do is simply say: "You are still dead wrong. Key word loading URL's does not positively influence SE traffic in even the tinniest of ways."

I will take your word as a gentleman and cheerfully advertise the fact that "My Argument is Invalid" on my profile.

It is my hope that you are open to the possibility of imperfect knowledge and that, if I demonstrate this theory in a manner that is crystal clear and undeniable, you won't sputter things like "but Jesus loves me, I have faith" or "it's impossible to prove a negative". :)

Accept my wager and I will prove to you that 2+2=5 and then I will take that 5, divide it by ZERO, and prove that it equals 7.

What say you good sir?

23 Dec 2012, 9:29 PM
#12
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

While I wait to see if you will accept the wager, I'd like to respond to a few things.

I want to tackle the first phase timing optimism first since you keep hitting that.

I still say it'll take you no longer than a weekend :)

I was not trying to be coy by avoiding the subject, just thought it was immaterial. My client sells electronic manufacturing equipment to electronic manufacturers, everything from solder to microscopes and X-rays for board testing right down to tables for assembly lines and electrostatic controlled chairs for workers.

Here are four of the more time consuming things on my list during the first phase:

  • Industry research & competitive analysis (who sells what, how are they selling it, what are the SEO strategies being used, and where are the opportunities for my client?)
  • Developing a marketing strategy
  • Compiling an ULTRA comprehensive To Do list for a couple of not so web savvy executives

That last one is gonna be mega rough. Before I can even think about starting the content phase, I have to have mountains of information available. They have numerous mfg's with thousands of products. Along with the basics, I will need point of origin zip codes for each product (some to be drop shipped from all over the map, some coming from the main facility; many products will be LTL; I will need volumes, weights, and/or shipping class on everything. Many of their products have numerous variations, options, configurations, etc. Also before I start that phase, I have to have a pretty good idea about categories, a comprehensive list of them at a minimum.

Anyway, I am still in agreement that the first phase should move along quickly, especially the ZC portion. But where I earn my money happens between the lines (unrelated to ZC).

Moving on….

If you look at the URL of this page, you will see that the folks who run this forum also load key words into the URL. So I am in good company.
I'm a little confused here in that I'm not quite sure whether you are saying the URL for this page
http://www.zen-cart.com/showthread.php?203958-Most-efficient-order-of-install-%28site-template-mods-then-products-%29
is a 'good' one or a 'bad' one? It has elements of being both SE friendly and Human Friendly.

Your reply seems a little disingenuous. The following words in the URL are plainly visible: Most-efficient-order-of-install-(site-template-mods-then-products-). Those are key words, it's that simple. They appear in the URL. Therefore it is a key word loaded URL. 2+2=4.

Disagreeing with that simple, undeniable truth is downright silly.

Perhaps the official ZC stance is the keyword loading is bad, but that reminds me of my dad's favorite saying: "Do as I say, not as I do."

I have become quite familiar with his positions on SEO matters… particularly URL and meta tagging, two subjects I tend to disagree with him on.
I'm kinda surprised you haven't come across my views on this matter too then. Schoolboy and I have very similar views in this regard.
It's not a religion. It's a science, based on hard solid facts.
We can present the facts to you, we can't make you accept them.

Actually, I'm pretty sure I have read your views on the subject. In fact it has been quite a while, but I'm pretty sure I sparred a bit with you guys a year or two ago on the subject. Hence the reason I tried to avoid getting into the subject (blaming the client). I was trying to avoid lengthy conversations about religion.

Strategic, well written meta titles and meta descriptions ARE beneficial to SEO. That is a simple fact. (I think you guys disagreed… right?)

Three opinions I have: I am indeed a novice (but getting better) at Zen; I'm alright with ethics (won't make sites that sell AR-15's to children); and I'm a badass when it comes to SEO.
Shame that you have the priority wrong. To benefit your clients you need to be an expert at Zen and a complete novice at SEO.

Shame? Really? Come on man! As you point out, ZC equals a weekend… barely a blip on what really matters. I listed 3 things pertinent to the conversation. Once again, my value is between the lines friend. Ranking much higher would be the ability build/implement strategy and ability to crunch huge volumes of information into simplicity. My customers pay me because I can take an off the shelf software, bend it until it rivals sites that much bigger firms have. I build money making machines. Zen Cart is background noise.

My money says that those that concentrate on site content, rather than chasing after rankings are going to end up in a far, far better position than the others.
This is already a well known fact.

I completely agree with you. However, if done properly, SEO can help to expedite the process. Things like XML site maps, summoning of SE bots when new content arrives, maintaining Google Webmaster type accounts, etc, are all positive things that can help to groom a site for success.

I notice that you several times you've gone back to damage that can be done thru improperly used key words, etc. For the sake of this conversation, assume that SEO efforts are being done properly. My meta titles all score 100% relevancy to page content, meta descriptions 90% or better. My URLs also score 100% (typically just the title of the page or a category+product name).

Yes, I was around when google bombing first came out and I am very aware of many other black hate methods. But I have always been white hat, period. I have had some pretty spectacular success flying strait, no plans to change that.

If you build a site with good content, it will eventually get indexed. If you take that good content and groom it, you can increase the speed of index and beneficially influence the climbing of ranks.

ZC is one aspect of what I am doing. SEO is one aspect of what I do. But if you combine them, there is about 90% left over. Lately, about 60% of what I do seems to be defending what I do… hahaha! :)

24 Dec 2012, 2:02 AM
#13
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

Ok, I guess I'm ready to deal with this now.

Sweet.

Feznizzle:

I can admit, you ruffled my feathers a bit.

I seem to have a knack for this, even though it's mostly unintentional. I believe it is part of the principle that if there are two ways to take someones words many people will choose the way that offends them the most.

Feznizzle:

But thanks for owning the arrogant tone, that was big of you. I mean that sincerely. You are clearly a thinker and not just trying to be mean.

I know what I am (or what I've grown into). I'm not always proud of it, but on the other hand I'm not ashamed either.

Feznizzle:

The first part seems like an invitation ("people need their core belief’s to be challenged").

Just another statement of fact. :)

Feznizzle:

The second part sounds like certitude that your core beliefs will stand up to challenge.

In regards to my beliefs, I change those all the time... I consider this as a willingness to learn. As for mathemetics (the language of computers) these will forever be a constant. 2+2=4.

Feznizzle:

And of course, the core belief is that you know as FACT that key word loaded URLs make no difference at all to people making searches on Google. Correct?

I need to answer this with great care, because it can make a difference... No, I'll even go as far to say it does make a difference. Whether that difference is positive or negative is another matter.... if you load a URL with a keyword such as 'stopwatch' and the page itself doesn't contain any other reference to 'stopwatch' this will have a negative affect. On the same token, because the same mathematical principles are applied to a URL where the page itself has the same keyword there will be a positive effect.

10-15 years ago this was very significant. These days there is so little 'weight' placed on the URL content (compared to all other SEO methods) the best it can do is tip the scales between 2 stores with identical content. The frustrating part is there is no way to tell which way the scales will actually be tipped.
Does the site with the keyword URL get the higher score because of the keyword, or does it get a lesser score because such URL's lead to duplicate content, which apparently gets the site penalised? I guess that this is probably the core of this debate.

Feznizzle:

Hmm. A wager? No. That might offend. Let me ponder.

Didn't offend me.... I often use the same terminology in this situation.

A word of warning though... The zencart team tend to frown on this kind of 'challenge' in these forums, so all discussion must be kept at a civil level else we will find ourselves being banned.

Feznizzle:

You know, you bring up religion. I find this interesting, especially in how you apply it here.

I only bring it up because from experience I know SEO discussions/arguments can quickly deteriorate into an all out war, with neither side willing to accept the others ideas.

Feznizzle:

I bet you either believe in God… or don't believe in a God.

Is this like stating I either believe the world is flat, or I don't believe it's flat? <g>

Feznizzle:

But is there any other choice? Either there is a God or there isn't, right?.

“Now it is such a bizarrely improbable coincidence that anything so mindboggingly useful could have evolved purely by chance that some thinkers have chosen to see it as the final and clinching proof of the non-existence of God.
“The argument goes something like this: ‘I refuse to prove that I exist,’ says God, ‘for proof denies faith, and without faith I am nothing.’
“‘But,’ says Man, ‘The Babel fish is a dead giveaway, isn’t it? It could not have evolved by chance. It proves you exist, and so therefore, by your own arguments, you don’t. QED.’
“‘Oh dear,’ says God, ‘I hadn’t thought of that,’ and promptly vanished in a puff of logic.
“‘Oh, that was easy,’ says Man, and for an encore goes on to prove that black is white and gets himself killed on the next zebra crossing.

Feznizzle:

Anyway.

Yea, I like the idea of a wager. A gentleman's wager. If you take my challenge and I can prove that 2+2 is indeed 5 in my very next post on the subject, then you have to make a change on your Zen-Cart forum profile and leave it up there for one month. But if my next post does not convince you that key word loading of URLs does indeed help to bring traffic from Google, then I will make the same change and leave it up for a month.

Whoever loses the wager must add the following words to their profile (can be added by hitting the "interest" button):
"My Argument is Invalid"

:)

What do you think, mate?

LOL. I love it :)

Feznizzle:

You've got math and science on your side, right? This is an honor thing, all you have to do is simply say: "You are still dead wrong. Key word loading URL's does not positively influence SE traffic in even the tinniest of ways."

You are still dead wrong. Key word loading URL's does not positively influence SE traffic in even the tinniest of ways, all else being equal.

Feznizzle:

I will take your word as a gentleman

But I'm not a gentleman. In fact most times I'm quite the opposite of 'gentle'. :)

Feznizzle:

It is my hope that you are open to the possibility of imperfect knowledge

I have no idea what 'imperfect knowledge' is.
I'm quite happy to acknowledge that my knowledge is often incomplete and until taught otherwise, generally wrong, in which case I'm happy to adapt

Feznizzle:

and that, if I demonstrate this theory in a manner that is crystal clear and undeniable, you won't sputter things like "but Jesus loves me, I have faith" or "it's impossible to prove a negative". :)

I understand what you are saying, and no I won't sputter such things. I have already changed my mind in this regard once already (I used to be a firm supporter of keyword packing in URL's), but this has changed over the last 5years or so. There's no reason why I'm not prepared to change again if/when the circumstances require it.

Feznizzle:

Accept my wager and I will prove to you that 2+2=5 and then I will take that 5, divide it by ZERO, and prove that it equals 7.
What say you good sir?

I say it's an interesting challenge, but alas, providing proof isn't going to be easy (either way), because there are too many other variables that will have a far greater effect than the keyword packing... For example, these days Google will sway its search results based on the geolocation of the person doing the searching which can negate many other considerations. As such it is going to be difficult (at best), and I can easily see that even these comments can be considered as 'sputtering', and that is **before **either of us has present 'proof' of our claims.

Nonetherless, I still think it could be interesting to try to prove/disprove the claims... So how about we try something like this.....

I assume you have access to a live ZenCart store? How about we invent a new product... for example a "Wurlitzer debobulator". We each place this item in our relevant stores, both using the same description text & metatags. I'll leave my store with no URL keyword packing, and you can create your keyword packed URL.
After a short period, say 2 days, 7 days and 14 days, we each do a google search for "Wurlitzer debobulator" and compare where our sites rank.

I suggest the three sample periods just to help eliminate time factor influences.

At the end of the day, Google should only show about three results... one for each of our stores, and another for this forum.

Does this sound reasonable to you, or do you have another/better idea?

Perhaps others with an interest in SEO would also like to take part in this experiment? Same deal ... We all use the same item and description, some of using native zencart URL's, others using the keyword packed (redirected) URL's.

At time of writing this, Google returns ZERO results for "Wurlitzer debobulator" (perhaps someone would like to confirm this).

How are we all for time at the moment? Can we get this item in out stores by (say) boxing day? (Dec 26th), or shall we wait until Jan 1st?

It is important we all add the item to our stores on the same day because I understand that one of the checks Google does is to compare the dates of pages, with older pages having a slight edge (all else being equal). Like the URL packing though, I have no idea how significant this is going to be on the end results.. I suspect it will be minimal, but greater than the keyword packing... just a suspicion though.

Rather than 'challenging' each other, I consider this to be more of a social experiment, and the more I think about it, the more 'fun' it seems......

Over to you....

Cheers
Rod.

ps. I've 'invented' the product, I feel it fair that you create the description... make it as long, or short as you like..

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

24 Dec 2012, 4:27 AM
#14
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

While I wait to see if you will accept the wager, I'd like to respond to a few things.

Sure. I really do like good civil discussions (on almost any matter).

Feznizzle:

I want to tackle the first phase timing optimism first since you keep hitting that.
I was not trying to be coy by avoiding the subject, just thought it was immaterial. My client sells electronic manufacturing equipment to electronic manufacturers, everything from solder to microscopes and X-rays for board testing right down to tables for assembly lines and electrostatic controlled chairs for workers.

I don't see this as particularly relevant... It takes me about the same time to install a new zencart no matter if the store is selling electronics, homewares or whatever.

Feznizzle:

Here are four of the more time consuming things on my list during the first phase:

  • Industry research & competitive analysis (who sells what, how are they selling it, what are the SEO strategies being used, and where are the opportunities for my client?)
  • Developing a marketing strategy
  • Compiling an ULTRA comprehensive To Do list for a couple of not so web savvy executives

OK, now I see where you are coming from... and the time you allowed for this obviously depends on the scope of the project. I was approaching it from the practical side of setting up the store itself and nothing more.

It appeared to me that you were/are expecting this aspect of things to take you a week or more. My mistake. :(

Feznizzle:

That last one is gonna be mega rough. Before I can even think about starting the content phase, I have to have mountains of information available. They have numerous mfg's with thousands of products. Along with the basics, I will need point of origin zip codes for each product (some to be drop shipped from all over the map, some coming from the main facility; many products will be LTL; I will need volumes, weights, and/or shipping class on everything. Many of their products have numerous variations, options, configurations, etc.

OK, I can see how this'll easily take a couple of months... or longer...... Apologies, but although all this planning is the right thing to do, it is rare to come across a developer that actually does it. At least that's the way it appears, and obviously I didn't expect you to be the exception rather than the rule.

Ooeer... isn't that a scary thought.... the implication being that most developers don't do what they should be doing, and basically just 'wing' it...

I'm not sure if this is just my (developed) cynicism showing, or whether it actually has the numbers to match. I suspect I'm swayed towards cynicism because the developers that do it correctly rarely have any problems so I/we hardly ever hear from them. On the other hand, those that 'wing it' tend to end up with more strife and questions, so they are the ones that stand out most..

Feznizzle:

Moving on….
Your reply seems a little disingenuous.

I actually had to look this up. You are correct. It is/was.

Feznizzle:

The following words in the URL are plainly visible: Most-efficient-order-of-install-(site-template-mods-then-products-). Those are key words, it's that simple. They appear in the URL. Therefore it is a key word loaded URL. 2+2=4.
Disagreeing with that simple, undeniable truth is downright silly.

Agreed (both counts).

Feznizzle:

Perhaps the official ZC stance is the keyword loading is bad,

Mind if we take a step back here a little.
Firstly I have no idea what the official ZC stance is... it isn't really important (at least not to me)
Secondly ' keyword loading is bad' would only be a valid content if taken in context.

For example: If the website software generates URL's with keywords this is most certainly a good thing. Google likes 'em, people like them. All good stuff and I've no problem with this whatsoever.

HOWEVER: If the website software doesn't generate URL's with keywords (for example, ZenCart's native behaviour) the only way to get a keyword packed URL is via a redirect or a rewrite. Both of these have a gross negative effect on google (and the server itself). Firstly for the simple fact the page is being redirected (an automatic loss in rankings. The target site will be the one with the higher ranking, rather than the keyword packed URL which really is nothing more than a pointer to the real page), and the second reason (one that I'm NOT convinced of, but most SEO experts seem to agree is factual) is that both pages will suffer a loss in rankings because it amounts to duplicate content.

Either way, assuming both of the negative affects are true, then clearly in this case keyword loading **is **bad.

Feznizzle:

Strategic, well written meta titles and meta descriptions ARE beneficial to SEO. That is a simple fact. (I think you guys disagreed… right?),

No, I don't think we did dissagree on this one... I know I certainly agree with you.

This is another problem with "SEO" - It can mean a lot of things to a lot of people, and yes, there are most certainly positive benefits to good SEO practices.. Even Google details many of them.

MY gripe isn't really with SEO as a concept, it is just that some aspects of it (especially URI mapping) doesn't (or no longer does) work to provide the same advantages it gave a few years ago, and as often suggested, can now even have a negative effect.
I have moved on and kept with the times, but it appears most SEO 'experts' are still stuck promoting old technology that no longer works.

Without wishing to offend, but I suspect you may be a person in this category.
OTOH, I haven't been keeping up with SEO (like I should be) for over a year now.... so perhaps things have changed yet again (although I seriously doubt it, this method has simply run its course). As per my earlier response, this has been, and always will be a game of 'cat n mouse' with SEO experts trying to 'cheat' the google rankings, and google trying to keep a level playing field, with URL content no longer a significant factor. (Well, at least this is the point we are wanting to prove).

Feznizzle:

However, if done properly, SEO can help to expedite the process. Things like XML site maps, summoning of SE bots when new content arrives, maintaining Google Webmaster type accounts, etc, are all positive things that can help to groom a site for success.

Heck, yes... I agree, and please make no mistake, I really have nothing against SEO as such, not even when offered as a paid service. I even have a bit of an admiration of SEO experts that know their stuff, it is NOT an 'easy' task to get right, and can be positively detrimental when got wrong. Really, my only gripe is when it comes to URI mapping, redirects and rewrites, all of which are server functions that were designed and created for a specific purpose, and SEO was never one of those purposes.

The fact that the SEO experts were able to take advantage of these to give themselves an edge over their competitors was seen as a blessing by some (the store owners), but a curse by others (few people actually realise the true impact on server performance when using these functions).

Feznizzle:

I notice that you several times you've gone back to damage that can be done thru improperly used key words, etc.

This is true. A surefire way to get a site placed into google hell is to try to cheat it... and this could be something as simple as using a meta-tag that doesn't appear in the page content.

Feznizzle:

Yes, I was around when google bombing first came out and I am very aware of many other black hate methods. But I have always been white hat, period. I have had some pretty spectacular success flying strait, no plans to change that.

10 years ago, URL keyword packing via redirects was perfectly acceptable. In many ways it still is, but the significance of it is so much less these days, at least as far as SE rankings are concerned.

Feznizzle:

If you build a site with good content, it will eventually get indexed. If you take that good content and groom it, you can increase the speed of index and beneficially influence the climbing of ranks.

Agreed, and if you can do all that without URL rewriting the site(s) will almost certainly get top rankings. So why on earth detract from these rankings by adding a needless redirects?

Feznizzle:

Lately, about 60% of what I do seems to be defending what I do… hahaha! :)

Tell me about it.

Ooer, I've come to the end of your post, and I must say, I really am enjoying this (I hope you are too)... it's not easy discussing SEO without things turning into a 'religous' war.

I hope you are starting to get a clearer picture of where I'm coming from though. Clearly I have very strong views and opinions about SEO (It's mostly a good thing, and the true experts are worth their weight in sales), but there this** one **aspect that I find positively(?) bad. Alas, it is also the one thing that seems to have minimal to no positive effect (in my experience) and ends up causing more people more problems than almost any other aspect of running an online store.
Now, as my final thought for this post.. perhaps you could explain something for me.
It is well known that Google etc, find sites by following weblinks. That is simply how they work. If a person sets up a site and doesn't post the URL anywhere it'll never get indexed, agreed? (this itself can be a whole new discussion, but lets not get hung up on that at the moment).

Now take this scenario:
A person sets up a zencart with a product that has a URL something like:
http://shop.vcsweb.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=3&products_id=4

Now lets assume this person got ONE link into google via manual submission... lets say this link is to the store root.. http://shop.vcsweb.com/index.php.
Google now has its 'hook' and will proceed to index the site. It will do so using Zencarts native URL format as above, after all, that is all ZenCart is capable of providing... so sooner or later http://shop.vcsweb.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=3&products_id=4 will be indexed along with the item description, etc... this is exactly what we want, correct?

Now what if the store owner decides to use keyword packing for this product by adding a redirect on the server so that requests to
"http://shop.vcsweb.com/demo_product" gets redirected to "http://shop.vcsweb.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=3&products_id=4", this is quite a common scenario for "SEO" wouldn't you agree?

Now tell me friend, how, or by what mechanism is google going to use to 'discover' the URL of "http://shop.vcsweb.com/demo_product"? There will be no links on the site itself, or any other site that will let google know that "http://shop.vcsweb.com/demo_product" even exists.
This URL will never get indexed unless Google is made aware of its existence by some other means.

On this basis, exactly where is the possible benefit of creating the redirect in the first place if the search engines themselves have no way of finding them?
For all the good they'll do they simply might as well not exist.

If left at that, it would be the end of the story, using this technique simply cannot work. The only reason it does work, is if/when the store owner publishes the shortened URL in a place where Google will find it, such as these forums. How many people actually do this though? Sure, a few merchants may provide one or two such links as and when asked, but how many will publish all of their shortened (or keyword packed) links into a place where google will find them?

Really, unless these URL's that do nothing other than a redirect are published somewhere they are simply deadweight... you can't have a RE-direct unless there is a known place to redirect from.

Hopefully this makes sense, and I'm really interested in your take/views on this one (since it is directly related to our main (only?) area of disagreement.

Anyways, 3pm Xmas eve.... time for to to get outa here to do the family xmas malarky. :)

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

24 Dec 2012, 9:04 PM
#15
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Merry Christmas! Hope you enjoyed family time. My father and his wife are coming in town soon, will spend the evening and then xmas morning here with my gang.

Yes, I'm enjoying the conversation, too. Like you, I'm not married to any of my constructs. And I, too, worry that my words will not come across well and create unintended ire. No worries!

I really like the proposed experiment. I think we could do a whole mini-series of similar tests, be very interesting. I've never actually done such a controlled experiment with SEO, think it would be fascinating. Like you, I'm caught up in a ton of xmas fun at the moment, maybe we can start a new thread after the new year so others can contribute. We are so far off the title of this topic that I fear we won't get good input.

I notice that someone has already moved the conversation. Odd that it has become 'Private'… can only be read after logging in. What is that all about?

I need to answer this with great care, because it can make a difference... No, I'll even go as far to say it does make a difference. Whether that difference is positive or negative is another matter.... if you load a URL with a keyword such as 'stopwatch' and the page itself doesn't contain any other reference to 'stopwatch' this will have a negative affect. On the same token, because the same mathematical principles are applied to a URL where the page itself has the same keyword there will be a positive effect.

Ya know, you're kind of taking the wind out of my sails with this. You say that your thinking can change from day to day, but that was super fast. A little bummed that I can claim no credit for swaying you. :)

If this is how you felt in the beginning, kind of wish you had led out with this!

I understand what you say about possible negative effects of redirects. A decade ago when this practice first began, that was a major concern to me. The first key word loaded urls I put up would have an extension at the end(html, etc). Not sure who I was fooling, haha! But where I am in agreement with the fact that keyword loading URLs is nowhere near as effective as it once was, I think that that it has become status quo and is expected by SE. I think they now do a better job at discerning between malicious intent and the simple desire to practice SEO. I suspect that it is now a bit more difficult to get penalized, unless you are really stupid (using words that have nothing to do with your page) or clearly up to no good.

Yes, the value of an optimized URL is not what it once was. But it seems to me that it has become a standard thing to do. If you perform a few random searches on google, you will find at least one or two key word loaded URLs on the first page of result almost every time. This is not to say those listings are there because of their URLs, rather I'm just pointing out that it is a very common practice.

The fact that such a large number show on the first page of results suggests one of two things: a huge percentage of websites do it, indicating that it is an accepted standard element of today's SEO; or those who do it are climbing faster than those who don't (hence why they are on page 1 so often).

Quick question w/ regard to google algorithms (since you seem to have your finger on that pulse)… all else being equal, if 10 listings show up for the same google search 100 times, but only 2 of those listings get clicked on every time, will those 2 listings climb to the top of the 10? No other difference, just by virtue of votes by traffic? And assume all 100 searches were performed by separate individuals (unique ip's). Not trying to be silly, my understanding of that has been clouded because of all the click scamming, hijacking, whatever that has gone on… I really am not very clear on whether or not actual traffic generated still constitutes a "vote" for a given result.

Make sense? I think I know the answer...

Crap. Gotta run. I will tell you my main logic (answer I was going to give if you had accepted my silly wager) for key word loading urls in my next post. I hinted at it very early on, but I have not explained it yet.

26 Dec 2012, 7:28 AM
#16
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

To the OP, as you may have noticed, the matter of url re-writing can create an almost religious frenzy here at Zencart. Zencart is about the only cart that I know of that doesn't include some form of re-writing in it's core default and which may contribute to the frenzy, but there are a couple of good and free rewriters for zencart. Although zencart's dynamic urls can and do work well with google/SE's, I would like to see more testing head-to-head in an extremely competitive area such as ours, where most of our competition use various carts with url rewriting.

For that matter, test different carts head-to-head.

If you really rock at SEO it would be nice if you can be a frequent contributor to the forums on that.

Any way, as for your order of installation and thousands of products. The most products we've had on any of our sites are probably around 5,000 products and I currently only have some 1,800 on prommart.com (with more coming and some coming down.) But to put up thousands of products, or even hundreds at a time, I assume you will be using an Easy Populate? Since Easy Populate 4 was the first available for zencart 1.5.x, I have used it and now have come to prefer it. Although an earlier easypopulate we've use now looks to be 1.5.x ready.

One thing I like about Easy Populate 4 is that you can download and work by category.

Steve
prommart.com

26 Dec 2012, 7:59 AM
#17
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

RodG, you've posted alot of very useful information. Thanks!

Steve
prommart.com

26 Dec 2012, 9:22 AM
#18
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

I really like the proposed experiment. I think we could do a whole mini-series of similar tests, be very interesting. I've never actually done such a controlled experiment with SEO, think it would be fascinating.

I've never done such an experiment either, and as far as I can tell, no one else has either. I'm actually looking forward to this... Between us we could end this religous war. <LOL>.

Feznizzle:

Like you, I'm caught up in a ton of xmas fun at the moment, maybe we can start a new thread after the new year so others can contribute. We are so far off the title of this topic that I fear we won't get good input..

The New year is good for me. Not New Years day though... I've managed to skip this day for the last few years... something to do with a massive hangover I beleive <g>

Feznizzle:

I notice that someone has already moved the conversation. Odd that it has become 'Private'… can only be read after logging in. What is that all about?

I hadn't noticed myself, but only the forum moderators can do this. I assume it was done so because this is/can be a very contentious issue, which generally speaking isn't good for the forums, and by extension, Zencart itself.
I know from precious experience that 'challenges' among forum members are frowned upon too, so I assume it was probably for one or both of these reasons.
I'll also assume that since the thread hasn't been completely closed and the moderators have made no objection to the proposal and/or current discussion, that it's their way of telling us to proceed with caution and civility.

'Course I could be way off the mark with this too...

Feznizzle:

I need to answer this with great care, because it can make a difference... No, I'll even go as far to say it does make a difference. Whether that difference is positive or negative is another matter.... if you load a URL with a keyword such as 'stopwatch' and the page itself doesn't contain any other reference to 'stopwatch' this will have a negative affect. On the same token, because the same mathematical principles are applied to a URL where the page itself has the same keyword there will be a positive effect.
Ya know, you're kind of taking the wind out of my sails with this. You say that your thinking can change from day to day, but that was super fast. A little bummed that I can claim no credit for swaying you. :)

If this is how you felt in the beginning, kind of wish you had led out with this!

Sorry, I didn't mean to take the wind out of your sails, we do both still have opposing views about this (I think), in that although I acknowledge it can have a positive effect as well as a negative effect, in the overall scheme of things the effect will be negligible regardless which way it swings. I'm hoping that this is what our experiments will prove/disprove... not whether it is a positive/negative result, but whether it is** significant **either way.
In fact this is about the only thing we will be able to determine with any degree of confidence, because if my stance is correct, then I'd expect all stores in the experiment will end up with roughly equal rankings. If my stance is incorrect then I'd be expecting quite a noticeable difference in rankings, with the SEO optimised sites taking top spots.

If we can't observe this differential effect then it must be assumed that this form of SEO doesn't work, or is insignificant.

As someone that promotes this method as having positive SEO benefits you don't have the same luxury as I do, because like many of the 'god exists' arguments, it is for you to prove the SEO claims do work, not for me to prove they don't.
It has been stated a number of times in the past that some people will use this 'because it does no harm'. I don't consider this to be a valid reason to promote this method of SEO... Doing no harm is a lot different than doing positive good.

Feznizzle:

I understand what you say about possible negative effects of redirects.

I don't think you do. I didn't say redirects have a possible negative affect... I state that it DOES have a negative effect (in regards to SEO). I doubt that I'll ever change my view on this because it goes right to the core of how computers and networks function. It really is no different than giving a person directions to a particular place, but once they get they they find a notice saying the event has moved to a different location (redirected). No matter how you look at this, the redirect is far from being the most efficient way of getting to the final destination.

Feznizzle:

But where I am in agreement with the fact that keyword loading URLs is nowhere near as effective as it once was,

Is this a bit of caving in from an SEO expert that I'm reading? :)

Feznizzle:

I think that that it has become status quo and is expected by SE.

Nah, I have to dissagree with this.... It is expected by people. The search engines don't give much of a damn either way.
At least this is what I hope to prove.

Feznizzle:

I think they now do a better job at discerning between malicious intent and the simple desire to practice SEO.

Heck yes. Again, a point I'm trying to make... Search engines have evolved a lot since URL keyword packing was a significant factor in the rankings.

Feznizzle:

I suspect that it is now a bit more difficult to get penalized, unless you are really stupid (using words that have nothing to do with your page) or clearl up to no good.

There are a lot of really stupid people out there... many of them call themselves 'SEO experts'. <evil grin> <seriously, just kidding, stirring>

Feznizzle:

Yes, the value of an optimized URL is not what it once was. But it seems to me that it has become a standard thing to do.

Agreed, but that doesn't make it the right thing to do.

Feznizzle:

If you perform a few random searches on google, you will find at least one or two key word loaded URLs on the first page of result almost every time. This is not to say those listings are there because of their URLs, rather I'm just pointing out that it is a very common practice.

You aren't doing much to help your position with this statement, because I'm quite happy to accept what you say, which written in a slightly different way is akin to saying that if only one or two of these make the first page, the rest of the 1st page results don't have the keyword loaded URL's.

Surely if key word loading URLs (an apparently common practice) had any benefit whatsoever then the majority of the 1st page results will consist if this type of URL instead of just 'one or two' of them?

Feznizzle:

The fact that such a large number show on the first page of results suggests one of two things:

"at least one or two" hardly makes a 'large number' - and it is certainly a long way from being the majority.

Feznizzle:

a huge percentage of websites do it,

A huge percentage of users needlessly add "www" to their domains too. That doesn't make it the right thing to do.

A few hundred years ago the majority of people thought the world was flat. It didn't make them right either.
a hundred years ago the majority of people used to think electricity flowed from positive to negative (some people still do). We got that wrong too.

Feznizzle:

or those who do it are climbing faster than those who don't (hence why they are on page 1 so often).

We both still pontificating, and will continue to do so until we run our experiement.

Feznizzle:

Quick question w/ regard to google algorithms (since you seem to have your finger on that pulse)…

Hmmm, not really... the google algorithms are a closely guarded secret... What I do know are the principles behind how sites are crawled and the kinds of things that are recorded, which are then used by the algorithms to produce a given result.

Feznizzle:

all else being equal, if 10 listings show up for the same google search 100 times, but only 2 of those listings get clicked on every time, will those 2 listings climb to the top of the 10? No other difference, just by virtue of votes by traffic? And assume all 100 searches were performed by separate individuals (unique ip's). Not trying to be silly, my understanding of that has been clouded because of all the click scamming, hijacking, whatever that has gone on… I really am not very clear on whether or not actual traffic generated still constitutes a "vote" for a given result.

I honestly don't know the answer to this one. I do know that the clicks are counted and monitored, but I've no idea how much weight would be given to the search results.

I think we'll have to place a liitle trust in each other when we do our experiments, and try to avoid excessive clicking, just in case it can skew the results.

Feznizzle:

Crap. Gotta run. I will tell you my main logic (answer I was going to give if you had accepted my silly wager) for key word loading urls in my next post. I hinted at it very early on, but I have not explained it yet.

OK, in your own time.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

26 Dec 2012, 8:02 PM
#19
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

I've done an informal url test of sorts some time ago. I had one dress in particular on several sites that I closely monitored. One site was my main site, Prommart.com, which at the time was back on dynamic urls*. Another site was using Simple SEO URL (and still does). Another domain no longer existing I used CEON URL.

CEON URL quickly trounced both. I was excited and even posted this on CEON's forum, and notified my sister's ex-SEO guy. But this domain was an unused domain and perhaps it was having an initial boost, can't say. But I felt that something about CEON, maybe the way it does things, gave it an edge. But never did use CEON on a production site.

I think the only real test would have the exact same template, category and product names, and content. (Which my informal test may have had.) Then, as I understand it, the balance of the content on the sites would have to be the same. In short, the only difference being the url.

But then there's a possibility that one, or both, may be slammed anyway for duplicate content?

Then pop-up a Prestashop and Opencart using their default templates and the same product with their re-writing enabled. For the definitive test. ;)

*Having come from the commercial Magic SEO URL, which did work. In fact, my best seasons/years were when using this on the Ic-Atheme template.

Steve
prommart.com

26 Dec 2012, 8:09 PM
#20
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

A thought on spammy urls. Re-writers typically use the category and product names. So if the url is spammy, then so are the category and product names?

My main site, prommart.com, is now on Ultimate SEO URL. One of the reasons I don't enable the categories to show in the product link is for this reason.

Steve
prommart.com