If this is your first visit, check our documentation. To post, register or login.
Forums / Other Business Topics / Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Started by feznizzle on 21 Dec 2012, 12:30 PM · Views: 6,356

Results 41 to 60 of 624
30 Dec 2012, 9:05 PM
#41
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

RodG,

I'm not a SEO guy. Just a normal Zencart user trying to survive in a very competitive area where it seems that now everyone and their grandmother have formal dress sites. And now the Chinese, often with impressive zencarts and Ultimate SEO URL and copy/fake dresses at half price or less.

I wish I were a SEO guy. My sister's main site was going like gang busters in our field, getting the attention of the older, established sites. Under the help of her ex-SEO guy. Then she apparently got hit with the first Panda and has not yet recovered. Now, also, google warnings of unnatural links...which we've had thousands removed but reconsideration requests just state there are more. I'm thinking of the new link disavow.

My main site, prommart.com, I put on the commercial Magic SEO URL some years ago, following the ex-SEO guy on my sister's sites. That worked great and it was this period I had my most dramatic rise. But then I upgraded to 1.3.9 series and didn't re-do Magic SEO for several reasons. Back to dynamic urls, nose dive and never really recovered. But I used to dominate searches using the product name.

We began with and still have a brick and mortar store. Early ecommerce included a couple of simple commercial carts. Looked around and found Zencart. Best thing we've done re ecommerce. Only real contenders at the time, for us, was Cubecart and OsCommerce. Wasn't really aware of Prestashop or Opencart; don't know if they existed at the time. But had I gone with them I'm sure I would have liked them also.

I've read, and even from Matt Cutts, that in an extreme case one might just have to abandon a domain for another. I'm thinking of that. Or, to shake things up, pop-up a different cart.

Desperation....

Steve
prommart.com

30 Dec 2012, 9:10 PM
#42
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle,

I've tried adwords in the past and again fairly recently with a free coupon on a secondary site. Although visits increased I don't know that I ever received one sale through adwords.

What's with that?

Steve
prommart.com

30 Dec 2012, 9:36 PM
#43
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Bummer! My experience with adwords was very positive. Mind you it has been years and I primarily used it to jump start a site. I had a budget of $50 per month, sold a downloadable PDF for $48. I used it for about a year, did quite well, stopped when my product hit the top of the naturals.

But apparel, I would guess, has to be a lot tougher. (Nice looking site, btw!) It's far more expensive and the type of thing that I would imagine that the girls want to try on before committing. Where I could turn 1 in 15 visits into a sale and did not get huge traffic (it was a very specialized product, but those who looked for it needed it; and there was nothing else like it on the market), you probably have to turn hundreds of visits to get a sale. Unless your cust already knows what designer and specific dress they want, and have turned to the web to find a good deal. Then your prices have to be good. I wonder how you stack up against comp with pricing (legit competition, not knock off)?

Your links not getting indexed hints at something gone awry, so maybe its not a market thing? But I should think Adwords would help to overcome that. It does sound like you need some help though. You should track down your sis's guy? Might be worth it pay to get the mess untangled, then all you have to do is maintain.

Did you style the site yourself? CSS, slide show, etc?

30 Dec 2012, 9:49 PM
#44
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Steve,
Most of this posting of yours doesn't really need a response mainly because it deals with ancedotal evidence. Something we'll never be able to agree on.

Nonetherless you still managed to raise a few good points. Always a good thing :)

SPH:

Later on I realized that my idea of having idential sites, the only difference being the url, wouldn't work. Because the very domain name could be a ranking factor

This is one thing I can confirm. The domain name itself** is** a ranking factor and it appears to carry a lot more weight than anything in the rest of the URL.
For example: http://blackduck.com/ will almost always make top ranking when 'black duck' is used as the search query, regardless of actual site content.

However, since none of us will be using a domain name anything like our test product this is going to be a non issue in regards to the experiments.

SPH:

and it would be difficult getting identical domain names. Only possibility would be two carts on subdomains with nearly identical subdomain names: cart-1 and cart-2

Actually, it's not that difficult (well it never used to be). If we do wish to take the experiment down this path, I have the following domains available to me:
vcsweb.com, vcsweb.net & vcsweb.com.au.

'course, to be actually 'useful' for test purposes I'd need to create a product called 'vcsweb' as well :)

SPH:

Wouldn't mind joining the experiment if offer is open.

Sure... The more the merrier.

SPH:

I would consider putting the test product on my main site, prommart.com. I have a couple of secondary carts not really doing anything. Then I have a couple of test zencarts and should still have a Prestashop and Opencart, both relatively recent versions. But I recently restored my computer back to factor settings so would have to hunt them down online.

Initially I'd like to keep the tests limited to zencart, but if you wish to use zencart and one of the other stores as well I'll have no objections and would be very interested to see how they fare.

SPH:

I am neither for nor against re-writing.

I've nothing against rewriting/redirects when used as intended. I'm vehemently against it's use for 'SEO' purposes though (else I wouldn't be having 'issues' with it and we wouldn't be having this discussion).

SPH:

Just what works best for search engines and customers.

We don't actually 'know' what works best yet... We still all have out opinions about this, and I still hope to show that redirects are** bad **for SEO.

SPH:

In the end it has to be a business decision.

Whilst I agree with this completely, my stance is that a business decision based on flawed data/information is never going to end up well, and that you SEO redirection promoting guys are providing your clients with flawed data. Something I'm hoping I'll be able to rectify :)

SPH:

Just as it is with the cart itself. As much as we love Zencart, should a head-to-head experiment show Prestashop or Opencart superior for search engines and customer satisfaction, that would seem to settle it.

Sorry, but I don't follow this logic. We aren't trying to prove which is the better cart, we are trying to show whether URL redirects are in any way beneficial to a search engine or not... (that was the original intent). I've now gone out on a limb and instead of expecting you guys to demonstrate the benefits I'm pretty confident I'll be able to show you quite clearly that it is 1) Completely ineffective, and with lesser confidence Detrimental.

Anyway, welcome aboard :)

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

30 Dec 2012, 11:03 PM
#45
fairestcape avatar

fairestcape

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Mar 2008
Location:
Cape Town & London (depends on the season)
Posts:
2,957
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

I agree with Rod totally. There is so much misunderstanding and (to put it mildly - CRAP) discussed about "SEO" that most people end up not seeing the wood for the trees.

Google wants a site to be as "useful and relevant" to visitors as possible, and considers scores (if not hundreds) of parameters when evaluating a site for indexing and page-ranking.

Only a SMALL PART of this is the code system used to generate the page content. What is more important is the quality of the content, and the general efficiency and reliability of the HTML into which it is embedded.

In Google's webmaster tools, you can render a page "as Google sees it". One of the most important things Google wants to see is the Headers (not visible to viewers - even when looking at source) and it really likes it if these headers are giving the resultant page a "clean bill of health".

Users of Zencart can rest assured that there is nothing they need do to the code, the URL's the core logic, etc... of Zencart, in some vain attempt to make it more "SEO-friendly". Zencart generates extremely clean HTML, and its dynamic URL's are very easily indexed and followed by even the most rudimentary search engines.

We have many customers - and a few of them do the right thing when it comes to "SEO". They focus on providing a site that is full of useful information for its visitors, that keeps the visitors engaged, and attracts an increasing number of them. We have one customer (in quite a specialist field admittedly), who has 374 products on his site. 362 of these get to Google number 1 spot for searches on the products' make and model. The site sells spare parts, so shoppers will almost always use the part number and manufacturer in their search. And on this site, as I said, 362 of the 375 products in the webshop will find themselves at the TOP of Google page one. The remaining 13 products are generally within the first five results on a Google search.

And guess what?

This site is plain, vanilla Zencart... NO additional modules, no "URL re-write", no other stupid tinkering with custom meta tag content... Just plain zencart left entirely to do what it was designed to do.

Now... why does this site do so well on Google?

  1. It is in a specialist field - there are only about 2000 competitors in the UK doing the same sort of business.
  2. Customers will (99% of the time) use very specific search terms (part number, make, model).
  3. The site owner has ensured that these critical phrases are well-represented in the content, and form part of the page title, meta description H1 tags, Alt tags, Title tags and are found in the body content of the product_info pages. He lets zencart build all of this HTML just using CORE zencart settings... nothing fancy, no tinkering.
  4. The site's content is informative and comprehensive.

So... this proves that you need do ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to zencart to get to Google number one spot for 95% of your content, when critical search terms are entered into Google.

Stop worrying about things that do not matter. Focus on CONTENT and the USER EXPERIENCE. Do it BETTER THAN your competitors are doing it, and keep the content fresh, relevant and vital.

31 Dec 2012, 12:16 AM
#46
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

My understanding of your view has gone thru phases.

This is good. It shows that you are actually learning something (err, I mean that with no disrespect).
I've learned stuff as this conversation has progressed too, in particular why there is apparent confusion between a redirect and a natively generated URL in regards to SE results.

Feznizzle:

First I thought you believed there was zero point to keyword loading and that it was just a method for unscrupulous developers to extract more money from clients (sadly true, more often than not).

Not so. I've NEVER been against SEO as a concept. My position has been and remains that using redirects for SEO purposes is pointless, and even detrimental.

Feznizzle:

Then I thought this softened to "well its not as effective as it used to be, therefore it is a pointless endeavor." .

I can certainly understand you you came to that conclusion if the topic was related to 'keyword packing' only, because taking my scenarios' B & C only that is still my stance.. the problem is, this is a lot more difficult to prove than the A & B scenario's.

Feznizzle:

Then I thought it was a performance issue (very valid, worthy of experiment) based upon redirect penalties,

This still stands. There is a performance issue. There simply is no way around this one. Redirects affect performance.

Feznizzle:

something I felt was overcome by 1) the way google treats those URLs (bold) and 2) the human factor. Those two reasons being those that explain why I implement the strategy by default, feeling that they override all else (again a reasoned position IMHO, worthy of experiment).

Alas, at its core operation, google is no different than any other web browser/client. Just because its a 'search engine' doesn't mean the servers it connects to will treat it any differently (robots rules excepted). I fail to understand how 'the human factor' can have any effect on server performance though. Was there any particular reason why you 'felt' it could?

Feznizzle:

I was pretty confused when you didn't seem aware of that google factors server performance in,

Tell me about it... That piece of 'new education' really came as a shock to me (incidentally, after being given the initial link detailing this I also took the time/effort to verify the claims from other sources). If I'd only seen the one reference I'd still be debating this one, but I finally found enough to convince me it was factual, and as you now know, I've updated my views/opinions to include this new information. I hope and trust that when the time comes you'll also have a change of opinion (trust me, it really doesn't hurt. All it takes as a swallowing of pride) <g>
Sadly, it is human nature to hold onto our beliefs for as long as possible though, and as we all know, some people will never change their opinion about anything, regardless of any evidence to the contrary.

I don't mean to imply that you are one of those that will never change opinions, in fact you have already shown a little evidence that you can/will.

Feznizzle:

which to me would surely factor in all the 301 bouncing around (which I thought was your objection).

I guess one of the reasons I found it so 'easy' to change my opinion on this one is because it actually works to help my case (rather than harm it). The redirects do have a performance hit (simply no way to avoid it), and since Google will rank the poorer performing sites lower, then this fact alone is telling us that redirects ARE bad for Search engines.

In short, my case has just been proven on this fact alone. I guess the next question is will the points 'gained' from creating the friendly URL's outweigh the points lost as a result of the performance hit?

I fear that this is another thing that will be untestable, so for the sake of the rest of the discussion, if agreeable, I'm quite happy to forgo this point in my favour and assume that it is simply cancelled out by the other factor(s). There is a far bigger fish for us to fry (The one where I intend/hope to show redirects are completely ineffective in regards to SEO).

Feznizzle:

Anyway, now I feel like I have a solid grasp on your position, thanks.

As I stated in another posting, I've had the revelation that this entire debate is the result of us discussing somewhat different things, and rather than concentrating on the URL's themselves (with much debate) we should be (are?) discussing whether a redirect to emulate a human friendly URL is the same, or has the same beneficial effects as an identical URL natively generated.

I claim that they are nothing alike, and there is no comparison. The native generated friendly URL will 'work' as intended, and all else being equal it will produce higher rankings. The redirected emulation of the friendly URL being ineffective, bad news, and something to be avoided.

Please confirm that you are of the opinion that these are effectively equal.

Feznizzle:

So to your 3 possibles scenarios, I would be delighted to add a 4th:
D) http://mysite.com/complex_URL_with_keywords (Application generated)

Rather than add this 4th (which doesn't really change things) would you be happy/happier if we just replaced my scenario C with your scenario D ?

The reason I state this doesn't change things is because when we get back to the core of this debate/discussion, it is really all about the merits/gains/pitfalls of redirects vs natively generated URL's. (irrespective of URL content).

Feznizzle:

Anyway, I'm with SPH on this. For me, this is simply business. I simply don't care what works, I just want to know.

Same here, but more importantly, I hope to demonstrate what doesn't work and why. Can you ask more than that?

Feznizzle:

I don't think we should standardize the content,

I consider it essential that we do, simply because this is what google ranks most highly. We are not trying to demonstrate that good content beats all else, that is (or should be) a given.

Feznizzle:

but I do think some things should be controlled:
1. I think we should all use EZ page rather than a product page (eliminates question of category).

If its all the same to you, I still prefer to add our test product as a product. I don't see the relevance of category making any difference whatsoever.
Consider the links Zencart generates for products vs EZ pages: (example)

/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=34_79_70&products_id=1666
/index.php?main_page=page&id=1

To a search engine, these are both simply complex URL's ... There is nothing in the 'product' URL to indicate a 'category' and nothing to really allow the SE to distinquish which of these two is a product, an EZpage, or some other page entirely.

OK, if there is no difference you may well ask why do I prefer to enter it as a 'product' rather than a 'page'. Two reasons, 1) because it is a product and 2) An EZpage would place the test product on the front page of our site(s) where people are more likely to find it and do what people do (get confused, ask pointless questions about it, and who knows what else).
In contrast, as a product it'll blend in with all the other products and this issue can be avoided.

Feznizzle:

  1. Think we should all add the page to the footer of our site (rather then bury it completely).

Why? I thought we were going to keep this simple. We have a new product, why not just add it to our stores just like any other product? If we start adding it to headers, footers and sidebars all it is doing is creating more work for ourselves and it'll tell us nothing of the merits/pitfalls of the redirects.

There is also a possibility that doing this will negate what I hope to be able to show you.

Feznizzle:

  1. I like the 2 or 3 paragraph limitation, but think we should standardize keyword reference:
    • "Wurlitzer Debobulator" should be referenced together 3 times.
    • "Wurlitzer" and "Debobulator" should each be referenced twice, not together.

This falls in line with my view that we should all use the exact same description. This way we don't need to 'standardize' specific words or phrases. Don't forget, the aim isn't to see who can get the highest ranking in google, the aim is to demonstrate the (in)effectiveness of using redirects to emulate natively generated URL's.

Feznizzle:

  1. No images (for now)

Agreed. For no other reason than I can't be bothered creating one <g>. Besides, this isn't going to effect what we are trying to prove/disprove. We haven't even mentioned whether images will affect SEO - that'll be a whole new discussion (one that I have no intention of getting involved in).

Feznizzle:

This will give us a mildly standardized page without appearing to duplicate each other.

If you are really worried about the effects of duplicate content you need to avoid redirects at all costs. The mere act of using them will create duplicate content. Using my scenario A) http://mysite.com/user_freindly_URL & the redirected http://mysite.com/complex_URL are two distinctly different URL's that serve up the exact same page.. You can't get any more duplicate than that.

Feznizzle:

I'm still pretty concerned about the age of the domains and the established SE reputation of the sites and the performance of various servers…

This doesn't really concern me at all. I'm expecting all of our test sites to show up in Google with roughly equal ranking on the sole basis of content alone (which is why I'm going to insist that we all use identical content for the product description).

Feznizzle:

but anyway, I'm in.

Good, me too, and hopefully Steve will also join the party.

Feznizzle:

Another thought, does anybody have access to an active adwords account?

Not I.

Feznizzle:

How does Jan 2 sound to you guys? Just stick it up when you find a moment...

Sounds good to me. Jan 2 it is (Unless unsuitable for Steve).

OK, so next question... Do you wish to create the product description or shall I go ahead and use my 'random text' idea? (with keywords inserted of course).

If you wish to create it, simply paste a copy into one of these postings and we'll take a copy. If you wish me to create it, just say the word and I'll do the same.

I think we are good to go, and I'm pretty sure that we are now all on the same page in discussing the merits/pitfalls of scenario A) vs scenario B) and that scenario C (or D)) doesn't even come into play with our testing (To do that we'd need to use a different shopping cart)

Are we all good and on the same page so far? Any questions or clarifications needed?

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

31 Dec 2012, 12:30 AM
#47
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

RodG,
I'm not a SEO guy.

Yes you are, you just don't realise it <g>

Seriously though, in regards to your part of this experiment, will you be using redirects or do you plan to go zen native?

It'd be great if two of us used redirects and two went native, but that's not possible with only 3 of us involved in the testing, so you get to choose :)

Cheers
Rod.

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

31 Dec 2012, 12:40 AM
#48
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

fairestcape:

I agree with Rod totally.

Thanks for the input and vote of confidence. Hopefully it isn't misplaced ;-)

fairestcape:

And guess what?

This site is plain, vanilla Zencart... NO additional modules, no "URL re-write", no other stupid tinkering with custom meta tag content... Just plain zencart left entirely to do what it was designed to do.

Sweet... Can we encourage you to join this experiment? That way we'll have two sites using redirects and two running native. All you'll need to do is add our 'wurlitzer' as another item to your cart, and wait for the results. The other guys have it harder, they've got to create their SE pointless redirects <g>

Just to be clear though, this experiment isn't designed to show how 'good' zencart is (we all know its the best). It is to demonstrate the effectiveness (or lack of) in using redirects as a viable SEO method.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

31 Dec 2012, 12:41 AM
#49
dbltoe avatar

dbltoe

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2004
Location:
N of San Antonio TX
Posts:
9,904
Plugin Contributions:
23

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Might I humbly propose an excellent image for this test?

[Attachment no longer available]

Need a hand with Zen Cart? Hire the team at myZenCartZone.com for upgrades, repairs, and custom plugins.
Zen Cart Certified hosting at myZenCartHost.com

31 Dec 2012, 12:54 AM
#50
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle,

Yes, I've always thought it a numbers game. You need so many visitors to the site. Out of those, only so many will try to order. And of those orders, only so many orders can actually be fulfilled (we don't have the dress & neither does the designer...at least in time for when customer needs it.) At the end of the season I often have more failed orders than completed orders on Prommart. Now, if I could acquire the art of cross-selling it would be different. But usually the customer is so focused that even the same dress in a different color will not work. So they presumably shop around the web, looking for a dress that may no longer be available anywhere. I often wonder what they finally do.

But dresses do sell online. Often customers try on dresses in a local bridal store then try to find it "cheaper" online. Sometimes you can hear them in our dressing rooms saying that, but my sis tries to catch all going out the door on that. The problem is that the dress designers set the lowest price at keystone, where if a store advertised below that price they can have their account pulled. So in theory all dresses should be priced the same across the web and they usually are (although there is "price matching" and I'm sure under-the-table deals.) But the wholsesale and shipping costs preclude too much of a discount.

So, with prices the same, my sis actually started the concept of "free gifts" with a dress purchase, now pretty common in our industry. (She's actually an ecommerce leader of sorts...having really been at the top of the heap thanks to her ex-SEO guy...and her.)

Thanks for the compliment on the latest template. One of Picaflor's latest. My big Zencart quest has always been the lookout for the ultimate template or "look". Hope I'm getting there. With prices virtually the same at every legit dress site other factors must come in to play: free stuff, the look and usability of the site, customer service, etc.

And the numbers game. Prommart's google webmasters says that I have 3,791 links submitted and 3,229 indexed. However, many of those are deleted dresses. Current sitemap shows 1,865 submitted and 1,585 indexed. I recall the ex-SEO guy recommended not deleting old, non-available dresses. Better to leave them and look bigger. Don't know about that.

I think my issue now may be content. But it's hard writing "unique" content for a couple thousand dresses (more coming.) And much of the content I see in our biz looks like crap to me; and I wonder what exactly content means. Example: "Look runway fabulous in this s e x y, drop dead dress...." What's with that?

Funny thing: my sis's main SEO'd site, despite it being crippled, overall still outperforms our other sites. Except for one: her original store site, a zencart that has little by way of SEO except for Magic SEO URL. It just floats around for years, doing better all the time.

I suspect my main problem now may be content. It's hard to write good content for several thousand products

Steve
prommart.com

31 Dec 2012, 1:27 AM
#51
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Since this thread is about picking brains, here's something I find interesting, this google result:

https://www.google.com/#hl=en&tbo=d&sclient=psy-ab&q=alyce+6004&oq=alyce+6004&gs_l=hp.3..0l4.1885.4798.0.5145.10.8.0.1.1.0.765.3250.2-2j0j2j2j1.7.0.les%3B..0.0...1c.1.jc2CmxN7_xQ&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&bvm=bv.1355534169,d.b2I&fp=e233eb1ee8f7df5&bpcl=40096503&biw=1680&bih=945

If you're seeing what I'm seeing, NewYorkDress is at the top of the organic result, but also does pay per click. I've noticed that alot with NYD and wonder why they'd do that. But they are also heavily in all kinds of online advertising and where ever I go I see them in site ads.

NYD is now a major competitor, although I don't recall them from the early days. And we've noticed that alot of the big early players have been falling back, or appear to be so.

Perhaps with prices being the same everywhere for us, just being recognized everywhere is where its at.

Oh, my sis's two sites, optimized findmypromdress and store site promstobeaches, should be at bottom page one for this search result. My prommart is, alas, page two.

Also note the rewritten urls most everyone uses in our biz. So I guess going to dynamic urls should put me ahead of the pack?

Steve
prommart.com

31 Dec 2012, 1:29 AM
#52
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

I recall the ex-SEO guy recommended not deleting old, non-available dresses. Better to leave them and look bigger. Don't know about that

A very good recommendation IMO. Since google and co are mainly interested in 'content' then the more content a site has the more likely it is to get higher rankings. Not only that, each product in a store provides google with another link back to the store, and considering the entire WWW is based on sites linking to each other (something people often forget) the more links a store has going to it, the better it will rank (It is my understanding that google only counts the number of links to a site without taking the origin of the links into consideration).

Each and every product in the store therefore becomes a 'vote' for the store's popularity.

Even if this weren't true, almost any database administrator on the planet will tell you that deleting data is always a risky business. It is far safer to mark the records as 'unavailable' or even 'deleted', without actually doing any deletions.

Simply put, there is nothing to gain by deleting records, but a heck of a lot to lose.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

31 Dec 2012, 1:34 AM
#53
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

dbltoe:

Might I humbly propose an excellent image for this test?

[Attachment no longer available]

Eeeek... A lurker...... <g>

LOL... I guess it does kinda look like a Wurlitzer Debobulator. If/when we add an image I'm quite happy with this one.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

31 Dec 2012, 1:54 AM
#54
lankeeyankee avatar

lankeeyankee

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Posts:
1,514
Plugin Contributions:
1

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

I am really interested in the outcome of this experiment and am happy to be the 4th test with a stock zc site. I think the URL rewriting is rubbish frankly, we tried Magic SEO early on but I gave it up because I wasn't convinced and not all URLs were rewritten the same. We are approaching seven figures/year in sales with our plain ol' dynamic URLs.

If you had dynamic or rewritten URLs and then changed one way or the other it's basically like starting from scratch for SE ranking.

For the experiment, if all else is not equal then the experiment is invalid. Basic scientific theory. So, everything needs to be the same. If one uses a sitemap like the Sitemap XML mod then all need to use it, etc. Everything, every little common detail, needs to be identical for this to be really useful for determining the sole objective of native URL vs redirected/rewritten URL otherwise there is 0 point.

I have to 100% agree with both Rod and Fairestcape, CONTENT is king. Relevant content, that is. We rank #1 for many search terms solely through real SEO techniques, making sure our product titles and descriptions match what potential customers are looking for. Use of H1, H2, H3 tags, and bold text in both category and product descriptions. Etc.

There has been the repeatedly hammered point about human friendly URLs in the top of search results, but what you don't know and likely will never know, is if these are natively generated or from rewrites like the "SEO URL" mods from this site. So in my opinion these points are irrelevant because as Rob points out, it seems as though some argument is from is B & C comparison and not the A & B comparison (which is really the ONLY argument in this discussion). Sure, I would love it if native zen cart did the human friendly URLs, and maybe this discussion will help bring more attention to the devs. Simply having more bolded relevant words in the SE result would be helpful to our human customers. But that is not the issue in this discussion, it's simply will redirected dynamic URLs be more effective in SE results. I don't think so but am eager to see the results.


Zen Cart and it's community are the best!!

31 Dec 2012, 3:05 AM
#55
dbltoe avatar

dbltoe

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2004
Location:
N of San Antonio TX
Posts:
9,904
Plugin Contributions:
23

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

<unlurking> I hope you are going to include W3C validation as a requirement for, at least, the particular product page. I am pleased to see this going forward. We long ago abandoned the idea of messing with Zen Cart's resulting content other than validation and valid content for defined pages, categories, and pages. We had one site get a cease and desist order for taking clients from other distributors in the company. All had the same price and several had Zen Cart. The sole difference was content. We charge triple fees to repair or remove SEO "fixes." And, the idea that it doesn't hurt? One in a thousand MIGHT get it working correctly. The others WILL hurt their standing. </unlurking>

Need a hand with Zen Cart? Hire the team at myZenCartZone.com for upgrades, repairs, and custom plugins.
Zen Cart Certified hosting at myZenCartHost.com

31 Dec 2012, 4:10 AM
#56
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

RodG:

A very good recommendation IMO. Simply put, there is nothing to gain by deleting records, but a heck of a lot to lose.

Cheers
Rod

I'm about ready to easypopulate up more dresses but did a spot check and notice that some major players still have dresses that are no longer available, and they state this on the dress. I guess they get the point.

We've been inconsistent. Sometimes deleting dresses. Other times using Zencart's excellent product sort function to move them to the rear of the category. We've even experimented with a separate category for all non-available dresses. I think I'll sort my older dresses in this cateogry to the rear and keep them for now.

I recall discussing this with dbltoe not long ago. I was wondering what keeping non-available products does for google's customer experience factor. But perhaps google doesn't know they are no longer available?

Also, knocking on wood: just noticed this dress uploaded not long ago is now no. 2 on my google result, behind what is probably the no. one competition:

https://www.google.com/#hl=en&tbo=d&output=search&sclient=psy-ab&q=Alyce+Short+Prom+Dress+3525&oq=Alyce+Short+Prom+Dress+3525&gs_l=hp.12...2298.2298.0.3754.1.1.0.0.0.0.454.454.4-1.1.0.les%3B..0.0...1c.kILD93CZUb4&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&bvm=bv.1355534169,d.b2U&fp=e233eb1ee8f7df5&bpcl=40096503&biw=1680&bih=945

Hope I've chosen a good search term and product name.

Steve
prommart.com

31 Dec 2012, 4:43 AM
#57
lankeeyankee avatar

lankeeyankee

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Posts:
1,514
Plugin Contributions:
1

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Totally off topic, but I notice that the #1 listing is for a category and yours is for a product listing. We have experienced great success by promoting our categories vs products, and if I remove the 3525 from the search string you are nowhere to be found. How many people search for that dress with 3235 at the end? Many? I know nothing about your industry and consumer base. I know some folks don't give much weight to Alexa rank, but that site is #42xxx and yours is 3.7 million and something.

I always stress the importance of categories, in my sitemap xml the categories are given a higher priority than products, this tells the SE that categories are more important. In your case I would definitely recommend trying adwords to get you on page 1. Also, and I know this is even more off-topic, but you need a better, more call-to-action add to cart button and you should have a view size chart button instead of un-underlined link to stand out. Read Steve Krug's Don't Make Me Think. It's my ecommerce bible, it really really works. Every ecommerce owner should absorb it, live it, breath it. Focus on your competition, their category structure, category descriptions, product layout and descriptions to gain insight on how you can do better. And read Steve's book!!!:D

And, most importantly, focus on the content and more content rather than the distraction of human friendly URLs!! There is no easy way, only hard work and long hours!!:D You mention being able to create unique content for so many products, my solution has been to hire someone to do it through spreadsheets and Easy Populate (which should be a core function in my opinion). Colleges are a great resource!!!


Zen Cart and it's community are the best!!

31 Dec 2012, 2:00 PM
#58
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

dbltoe:

Might I humbly propose an excellent image for this test?
Most excellent!

lankeeyankee:

For the experiment, if all else is not equal then the experiment is invalid. Basic scientific theory. So, everything needs to be the same. If one uses a sitemap like the Sitemap XML mod then all need to use it, etc. Everything, every little common detail, needs to be identical for this to be really useful for determining the sole objective of native URL vs redirected/rewritten URL otherwise there is 0 point.

This is a big concern for me. I do have multiple carts on the same VPS, both optimized and vanilla. I would run the experiment in both flavors, but looks like we are limiting this to just 4 sample pages. :(

something I felt was overcome by 1) the way google treats those URLs (bold) and 2) the human factor. Those two reasons being those that explain why I implement the strategy by default, feeling that they override all else (again a reasoned position IMHO, worthy of experiment).
Alas, at its core operation, google is no different than any other web browser/client. Just because its a 'search engine' doesn't mean the servers it connects to will treat it any differently (robots rules excepted). I fail to understand how 'the human factor' can have any effect on server performance though. Was there any particular reason why you 'felt' it could?
Perhaps a better choice of words would have been 'outweigh' or 'trump'?

I guess the next question is will the points 'gained' from creating the ** friendly URL's** outweigh the points lost as a result of the performance hit? I fear that this is another thing that will be untestable, so for the sake of the rest of the discussion, if agreeable, I'm quite happy to forgo
Not to put fine a point on it, but 'friendly urls' misrepresents the question. A better term would be 'keyword loaded url'. But your question is THE heart of my point, effectively snuffed by the direction this is now headed.

The naysayers are all interested in wether or not a 301 will inflict a hit on ranking. This is should be an immediate thing, one that I am almost willing to concede to as well, though I am very curious about it.

I would like to add a request to this experiment, in big bold red letters (if you agree), that no one (this includes any lurkers) click on any of the links. Just give it a week or so for all pages to get indexed, refraining from the urge to visit via google results. If you want to see the actual pages on the google search result, PLEASE paste the URL's into your browser. After all pages are indexed, we can choose the lowest ranked result and then ask everyone to search and click on it via google.

This will test your point first and, assuming nobody steps out, will test mine as well.

With regard to using the exact same description, I misread you when you suggested creating a random description, thought you meant we should do that on our own. I concur that it should be exactly the same. I'll let you do the creating.

(We are) discussing whether a redirect to emulate a human friendly URL is the same, or has the same beneficial effects as an identical URL natively generated.

I claim that they are nothing alike, and there is no comparison. The native generated friendly URL will 'work' as intended, and all else being equal it will produce higher rankings. The redirected emulation of the friendly URL being ineffective, bad news, and something to be avoided.

Please confirm that you are of the opinion that these are effectively equal.
Sorry, can't do that. I have always known that the redirects cause 301 bounces that negatively effect SE indexing (1st major drawback to the strategy). This is further exacerbated by google preference for server performance (2nd major drawback). For these reasons (plus my own sanity), I pay a premium to host via VPS on fast servers on high quality networks.

What I can confirm for you is that I think the penalties suffered thru redirected URL are relatively negligible and that they will stand up to natively generated URLs.

31 Dec 2012, 2:22 PM
#59
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Steve, I think you are getting some good advice. :)

Content is definitely king, removing things probably does more harm than good. What about adding "Sorry, out of stock! See these similar dresses" links?

This, in particular, is another spectacular nugget:

Totally off topic, but I notice that the #1 listing is for a category and yours is for a product listing. We have experienced great success by promoting our categories vs products, and if I remove the 3525 from the search string you are nowhere to be found. How many people search for that dress with 3235 at the end? Many? I know nothing about your industry and consumer base.

Steve, you said you are having problems getting indexed (google errors, etc), correct?

I wonder if this experiment might be better served by adding (or replacing) someone else who uses URL rewriting (preferably Ceon) and whose site is not problematic? Are there any re-writing lurkers out there willing to stick their nose into this?

31 Dec 2012, 2:35 PM
#60
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Woops! Sorry, I posted an incomplete thought on this.

lankeeyankee:

For the experiment, if all else is not equal then the experiment is invalid. Basic scientific theory. So, everything needs to be the same. If one uses a sitemap like the Sitemap XML mod then all need to use it, etc. Everything, every little common detail, needs to be identical for this to be really useful for determining the sole objective of native URL vs redirected/rewritten URL otherwise there is 0 point.

When using a re-write mod, sitemapXML is essential. You have to provide the bots with a roadmap to find your imaginary URL. To compare apples to apples, this should be in place (IMHO).

That said, if the consensus is that I shouldn't, I won't add the new prod to my sitemap. But this presents a problem. I already have it in place on all sites that have rewriting capability. I don't want to remove the mod or even just the generated xml files files just for this experiment. And if I leave it off intentionally, this will certainly skew the results.

I am open to whatever you guys think should be done, but, in my opinion, not having an XML map massively hobbles any re-writing efforts.