If this is your first visit, check our documentation. To post, register or login.
Forums / Other Business Topics / Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Started by feznizzle on 21 Dec 2012, 12:30 PM · Views: 6,356

Results 81 to 100 of 624
2 Jan 2013, 10:02 AM
#81
niccol avatar

niccol

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2009
Posts:
2,138
Plugin Contributions:
1

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

This is my favourite thread ever. It is like watching old television shows over Christmas. There is a warm feeling of nostalgia about it.

If you are going to test against each other then you need to reduce the other variables as much as you can. The way that most people do that is to run two sub-domains with identical installs. If you do not do that, or something similar, then nothing is going to be demonstrated at all and the chat will still go on for ever and ever. Really, this theme has been worked over so many times before that unless you at least match the thoroughness of previous investigations then you are just muddying the waters even further.

Or alternatively, you could just accept the results of much investigation over many years about whether dynamic URLs are a problem or not. And equally if re-writing is a problem or not. Or, while not wanting to appear like some kind of weird heretic, you might listen to what the search engines say about it. And find other things to talk about ...

But I'd rather you didn't because this is my favourite thread ever .....

Nick
iszent.com

2 Jan 2013, 11:57 AM
#82
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

JEEEEEEEZUS AGE CRIMEY!!! Do I speak English?

Aww, C.mon Feznizzle, we've been doing really well so far without this kind of emotional outburst. Please don't spoil it.

Feznizzle:

Who are you talking to? You cannot possibly be talking to me?

Yes, I was talking to you, and yes, you do speak English, but apparently I don't. I asked a very simple question that needed a simple Yes/No response.
Alas, you still didn't confirm, so you have left me/us to assume that your answer was 'Yes'.

Feznizzle:

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARG!!!

My sentiments exactly. You seem have a very hard time answering direct questions. In fact every question I have asked so far has either received a vague response, or no response at all.

I'm not going to let that bother/worry me though, because it doesn't change things.

Feznizzle:

++++++++ <REQUEST_FOR_NO_RESPONSE>

None given.

Feznizzle:

I am in this because I am curious about just how negatively these things actually do effect the initial listings.

Fsck. You have gone from 'SEO redirects are good' to "Just how negative they are". If you can't see that you've totally swung your arguement around then there really isn't much hope in further discussion. I'm going to have to rely on the evidence to convince you.

Feznizzle:

I am curious, I do not have an axe to grind. Your glee in the pedantic (post 58 where I had to the time to clarify the word 'override'; yes, I live in the New World and you in the Prison Colony, but we both speak dialects close enough to the Queen's English that I should NOT have had to do that) is becoming tiresome. Please stop misstating my understandings.

You know what peeves me about this comment? The fact that it is you doing the pedantic nitpicking, not me.

I have no problems or issues if you wish to use the term 'Trump', 'Outweigh', 'Override', 'Gets a higher score', 'beats the other', etc, etc It all means the same thing. You didn't NEED to 'clarify'. It all means basically the same thing. It's not worth making an issue of.

Same with your other comment (same message)

Feznizzle:

Not to put fine a point on it, but 'friendly urls' misrepresents the question. A better term would be 'keyword loaded url'..

Don't need a 'fine point' here... Be BLUNT. I really don't care what you call them. They are just words. What one of us calls a 'friendly url' another will call 'keyword loaded url'. What some of us consider a 'simple URL' another will call it something else. IT ISN'T IMPORTANT. I will use whatever terminology that YOU are most comfortable with. IT ISN'T IMPORTANT. Calling it one thing or another changes nothing. Never has, never will.

The only time I've been the least bit pedantic during this entire thread is with the meaning of the words/phrases like "Must", "Must Not", "Should", "Should not" and "May" & "May not". Unlike the 'names' we call things, these have very specific meanings and cannot be substituted with each other.

Feznizzle:

We are aligned in the basic underlying facts.
I can't be 100% sure of that, because you failed to confirm it when I asked.

Feznizzle:

We disagree about the gravity of these things.

Excellent. As long as you keep thinking that this is the case (and assuming 'gravity' is a matter of 'degree') then I still have stuff to demonstrate.

Feznizzle:

If you point out that I probably should have used the word 'vernacular' instead of 'dialect' I will probably give birth to small cow. :).

Please don't throw your pedantry back to me.. Call it what you like, as long as we know what we mean then that is all that is important.
DON'T GET HUNG UP ON WORDS.

Feznizzle:

Look, if you ARE holding out on some information I am missing (you keep alluding to something you will prove)... well, that's just annoying.

I'm not holding out on anything.

Feznizzle:

Why can't you simply say it?

Because if I did you will argue about it without thinking about it.

I was hoping that the 'penny would drop' before the tests began (ergo, the pointless arguement would be averted). You've even made comments at times that made me think this was indeed the case, but then you've turned around and stated things like "We disagree about the gravity of these things", which tells me that you've either lost the plot again, or still not seeing the whole picture.

Feznizzle:

Are you afraid you might be wrong? Don't worry about that, this is just a conversation. I am putting my cards on the table, so should you.

I never fear being wrong. I've already been wrong with a few things in this thread, and have no problems admitting it.

Feznizzle:

Whatever. I guess your point will come out soon enough. I just hope it proves worthy.

Me too. I'm going out on a huge limb here ya know. I'm going to try to prove something to you that is generally accepted as being unprovable. It could easily backfire on me and I'll be left with egg on my face.

Feznizzle:

This business about the XML sitemap is silly.

Perhaps.......

Feznizzle:

Only someone really stupid would not run an update EVERY TIME they add new content,

This is now the second time you've managed to confuse 'stupidity' with 'misinformation' (or lack of information).

SPH has just provided the following information for his test site:

SEO redirection tool/method: Ultimate SEO URL version 2.212 (latest)
Sitemap in use? No, and not yet installed on this site

I suggest you apologise to Steve for calling him 'really stupid'. He doesn't even use a sitemap, let alone keeping it up to date when he adds new products.
Steve is not stupid in my books, but clearly he doesn't see why sitemaps are essential for SEO redirects to have any hope of working.

Feznizzle:

so I am completely lost as to why you want to run this experiment against stupid people.

Again, you are confusing stupidity with a lack of information and/or misinformation. (OK, perhaps I'm being pedantic here?) <G>

The thing is there are a LOT of people like SPH trying to do SEO redirects without knowing or realising that they are just wasting their time without them, or in your words "not having an XML map massively hobbles any re-writing efforts".

I'll even go as far to say that most people using SEO redirects aren't aware of this. Hhmmm.. we can even take this to the next level, in regards to SEO redirects/rewrites, in MY experience these are generally setup by developers and not the merchants. The developer may or may not include a sitemap.
The merchant is then left to add their own products, meanwhile the developer has long gone without informing the merchant the importance of keeping the sitemap up to date. (Something that isn't needed with native zencart behaviour).

Feznizzle:

How much fun would it be to watch Mario Andretti in race if you only let him drive a 50cc scooter?

It'd be a lot of fun actually, especially if you'd convinced him it was really a 500cc scooter. :)

Not unlike this discussion really... The bulk of the SEO redirect supporters have been convinced they are racing in the 500cc class (scenarios B & C), and I'm sitting here watching them run the race knowing that they are really only in a 'A' class with a 50cc motor.

Feznizzle:

Nevertheless, I will not update XML after adding the prod. The only thing this will accomplish is slowing the test a bit.

Actually, it goes a lot deeper than "slowing the test a bit". It can affect whether it'll ever get indexed or not (This is another clue that may help the penny drop)

Feznizzle:

You are aware that ZC automatically generates a site map?

No I wasn't. Tell me more.

Feznizzle:

The page will still get indexed,

Maybe. Maybe not.

Feznizzle:

though maybe a tad slower. Do you want me to remove the prod from native sitemap?

  1. There is no 'native sitemap'
  2. I asked that sitetmaps NOT be added/edited/deleted during the initial part of the experiment. (And you accuse me of having a comprehension problem).

Feznizzle:

Anyway, no more changes. I am fine with your proposal, let's just get moving. For my part, I will run this in both flavors (redirected and non-redirected).

Don't forget to supply us with your site details.

I wish to give you the best chance possible of proving your case. I know you are worried about the timing issue, especially in regards to the effect of the site map, so although it is now almost 24hrs since I called for the test to start, and you possibly even have the product in your store, I will do you the courtesy of waiting until you provide you details to confirm your store(s) are ready before adding it to our store.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

2 Jan 2013, 12:17 PM
#83
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

Was going to put test product on my main site using Ultimate SEO URL, but have a question about the description. Looks alot like spun gibberish .

Yup. Thats exactly what it is. (With keywords added).

SPH:

that I understand Google doesn't like.

Makes no difference. The important thing is we all use the same description.

SPH:

Is it okay to have this on a main production site?

Guess we'll find out eh?

Seriously though. Google isn't human. It doesn't read a collection of words and interpret it as some sort of meaningful paragraph. It's just a collection of words and perhaps phrases.

FWIW, the experiments/tests would produce the same outcome if the description was "The Wurldbitzer Debibulator is a mythical product created for testing purposes".

The reason I went for random text though is because if I created the text description using my own words someone would scream that I've somehow managed to embed a hidden message into it to sway the results in my favour. The offer was open for FezNizzle to create this, but it was declined. The random text is/was the next best thing I could do to avoid such accusations.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

2 Jan 2013, 12:20 PM
#84
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

It's Amazon.

Don't worry about the lorem ipsum (gibberish), won't matter and it will not effect your standings elsewhere. :)

Correction: You were right, gibberish not lorum ipsum. I didn't look at his desc before I spoke. Still won't matter. :smile:

Glad you agree. I was afraid one of you was going to insist we restart the experiment.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

2 Jan 2013, 1:15 PM
#85
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

Regarding Amazon, my understanding is that the big players such as this do not really need SEO

Wrong. On the internet ALL SITES ARE CREATED EQUAL.

If Amazon and Similar feed millions of dollars into Googles' coffers (as they do) it shouldn't be a surprise they end up near the top.

SPH:

(including with regard to any url theory) as everyone already knows them.

Isn't this a chicken and egg situation? How do people know them? Via Google (and other advertising). They didn't start out being 'known by everyone'

SPH:

Yet, since some big players do use re-writing (walmart in post above, target linked below) perhaps they see some value, maybe for customers.

http://www.target.com/p/reebok-competitor-rt-6-0-treadmill/-/A-14248392#?lnk=Other_HP_P1_ESPOT-0|ESPOT-0

What makes you think this is a rewritten URL? It could just as easily be generated by whatever store software they are using. No rewriting needed.

The fact is, unless we know what software they are using we have no way of knowing if this is a rewrite/redirect or natively generated. This fact was pointed out earlier in the thread (post #54, lankyankee) "There has been the repeatedly hammered point about human friendly URLs in the top of search results, but what you don't know and likely will never know, is if these are natively generated or from rewrites like the "SEO URL" mods from this site. "

My response was in #68

Shhhhhhh...... You are giving the SEO rewrite/redirect supporters a 'clue' as to exactly what I'm hoping/expecting to show them as positive proof that redirects are ineffective, and if they realise what this is, they are going to back out of the test, knowing they can't 'win' :)

BTW, 'you don't know and likely will never know' isn't technically correct. Have another quiet think about this experiment and hopefully the penny will drop.
If it does drop, please keep it to yourself for the time being. :)

SPH:

SEO theory, I think, would more help we much smaller players.

There is nothing wrong with SEO theory, and it doesn't help the smaller players any more than the larger players. We all play by the same rules.

What I will state though is that before the SEO can be of any use whatsover, you need to be in the game. In other words, you need to be in scenario's B or C (or D if we wish to be pedantic).

If you are playing with Scenario 'A' you aren't even in the game

Using Feznizzles vernacular, this is like watching Mario Andretti in 500cc class race when he's riding a 50cc scooter.

SPH:

EDIT: Hold on. Amazon (like Target) does use a partial re-written url:

http://www.amazon.com/Billy-Blanks-Tae-Ripped-Extreme/dp/B0058M07US

Hold on. I appreciate what you are trying to say, but a comment like "use a partial re-written url" is meaningless. A URL is either rewritten/redirected or it isn't.
The is no 'partial' about it. If you drive down the road and hit a detour, you take the detour, it isn't a 'partial' detour even if it does use some elements of the original path/road.

Please lets not starting getting bogged down with terminology. It doesn't change things, it doesn't help clarify things. The URL you gave is a URL irrespective of the 'name' you wish to give it. I can assure you that you'll never get any three people to look at that URL and agree whether it is a 'keyword loaded' URL, a 'hybrid URL' a 'complex URL' a 'simple URL', or a URL with a cherry on top. We shouldn't even TRY.

The important thing is the URL a result of a rewrite/redirect, or is it natively generated? (and as stated, unless we know the software being used, we have no way of knowing this)

Don't lose sight of the three possible scenarios:
A) http://mysite.com/user_freindly_URL (With Apache redirect to http://mysite.com/complex_URL)
B) http://mysite.com/user_freindly_URL (Application generated)
C) http://mysite.com/complex_URL_with_keywords (Application generated)

We are not discussing B & C they are irrelevant for this discussion. I'm even happy to say C) will trump B) all else being equal.

If this were a Mario Andretti race, A) is the 50cc class and B) & C) are the 500cc class.

Both you and feznizzle seem to keep forgetting this fact and bringing things like http://www.amazon.com/Billy-Blanks-Tae-Ripped-Extreme/dp/B0058M07US back into the equation where it really doesn't belong. This is scenario C).

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

2 Jan 2013, 1:24 PM
#86
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

lankeeyankee:

I think those links are a hybrid of natively-formed (not redirected) human and bot friendly URLs. They contain both human readable as well as dynamic aspects. As was pointed out in an earlier post, this forum uses human-friendly URLs and was suggested maybe the devs use this because they know better or something like that, but if you look you will still see dynamic aspects to the URL. My bet is the forum software natively creates this which is apples and oranges with a rewrite script like the ones being discussed.

You wanna know something scarey? It seems that you and I are the only two people here with a full grasp of things (probably not true, the others are just less vocal about it).

I'm a bit disappointed the other vocal participants haven't reached the same level of clarity yet though. I'm sure it'll come, eventually

I'm certainly not going to be betting against you in the way the forum URL's are generated.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

2 Jan 2013, 1:41 PM
#87
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

Date/Time Begin: 1 Jan 13 approx 8:00pm PST (California)
Your name/handle: SPH

Thanks Steve. I've copied this info so that I can combine it with the others as they come it. This way when we start discussing the results we see we'll have a complete list of the test sites and configurations all in the same format in the same place. It'll make the comparison results a lot easier to disseminate.

SPH:

Intend to run test on main site - prommart.com - in day or so. No link between sites that I'm aware of and try to avoid such cross links.

Sounds good to me, but please do submit another 'entry' for the store.

It also looks like you've got the jump on this one. Nothing to worry about ... if a day or three difference is going to be significant to skew the test results then I seriously doubt I/we'll be able to prove anything anyway... It'll basically place us back into the B & C type comparisons rather than a A vs BC, and this is still the 'biggy' of our tests.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

2 Jan 2013, 2:02 PM
#88
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

niccol:

This is my favourite thread ever. It is like watching old television shows over Christmas. There is a warm feeling of nostalgia about it.

LOL. Thanks for that. I'm glad I'm not the only one really enjoying it :)

niccol:

If you are going to test against each other then you need to reduce the other variables as much as you can. The way that most people do that is to run two sub-domains with identical installs. If you do not do that, or something similar, then nothing is going to be demonstrated at all

Let's wait and see shall we? I'm still confident that I can show the pointlessness of the 'A' scenario even though all else is not equal.
Yes, it is a challenge that I may not succeed in, but if I can/do, then logically we can kill the 'SEO redirects' arguments stone dead.

The chats/discussions/arguments between the B & C scenarios probably will go on forever though, for the very reason why you think the A vs BC comparisons will be undemonstrateable.

niccol:

Or alternatively, you could just accept the results of much investigation over many years about whether dynamic URLs are a problem or not.

I accept this wholeheartedly. Dynamic URL's are not a problem, never have been, never will be. Fact is, most websites won't even work without using dynamic URL's. That is NOT what this discussion is about.

niccol:

And equally if re-writing is a problem or not.

There's no dispute about this either. We all seem to have come to agree that rewriting/redirection come at a cost. There is no way to avoid this. It is the way it works. It can't be any other way.

niccol:

Or, while not wanting to appear like some kind of weird heretic, you might listen to what the search engines say about it.

This was covered much earlier in the thread. Alas, this didn't really help much because we appear to have a dispute over the meanings of the words "may" and "will". (It is also only relevant to the B & C comparisons) and says nothing about the 'A' scenario, so even though we can't agree that 'may' doesn't mean 'will', the fact that it is only relevant in the BC comparisons means that we can ignore this one and concentrate of the main area of contention.

niccol:

But I'd rather you didn't because this is my favourite thread ever .....

<smiles>. Hopefullly we'll have no further emotional outbursts. That is always the start of any good conversation falling into a heap where no one benefits.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

2 Jan 2013, 4:15 PM
#89
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Steve,

When you and I use rewrite mods, we fall into category A ("Apache redirect to http://mysite.com/complex_URL"). The example you gave with Amazon having keywords in the URL is most likely a result of C ("Application generated"), which is to say that site itself inserted those words into the URL w/o need for re-write, meaning there probably is no re-direct occurring. Obviously that is the most optimal way to do things.

What Rod is saying (and what we are about to test) is that using category A (re-write mods) will devastate your efforts to earn a good ranking. What I am saying [after first CLEARLY acknowledging that A and B (or A and C) are not the same thing; and that A will alway suffer penalty from SE's where B&C will not] is that any redirect penalty will not be horribly major and that this one factor is not negative enough to warrant avoiding rewrite mods.

Also Steve, since I did not insult you I don't need to apologize. What I will do is re-coach my point. IF you are using an XML sitemap, you should update it every time you add content. If you are not doing an XML map, then this does not apply. Further, I said that anyone using re-direct should have an XML sitemap. I was wrong, dead wrong. This is a helpful thing, but is not 100% necessary, so long as all links are indexable thru links that can be found thru a chain of links that originate on the index page.

I think you should definitely consider using an XML map, but I would not be horribly concerned if you do not.

You are aware that ZC automatically generates a site map?
No I wasn't. Tell me more.

Try this (just insert any domain where a ZC lives):
http://www.YOURZC.com/index.php?main_page=site_map

It is a defined page. Shows up in the footer unless you disable it in the EZpage area. At least that is how it is on all of my ZCs.

I did not create or alter this file as it occurs on my sites in anyway other than style (possibly) or installing Ceon URI (I have not gone back to see if Conor's mod alters this file). I will, therefore, not honor your request to make sure the new prod does not appear there (mostly because I am too lazy to figure out how it works).

But I am curious about something here. Since you do not seem to be aware of this very basic ZC function (index.php?main_page=site_map), does it's existence change your thought on the actual results?

Originally Posted by lankeeyankee
I think those links are a hybrid of natively-formed (not redirected) human and bot friendly URLs. They contain both human readable as well as dynamic aspects. As was pointed out in an earlier post, this forum uses human-friendly URLs and was suggested maybe the devs use this because they know better or something like that, but if you look you will still see dynamic aspects to the URL. My bet is the forum software natively creates this which is apples and oranges with a rewrite script like the ones being discussed.

That was my thinking as well, because of the "showthread.php?203958".

That said, this...

You wanna know something scarey? It seems that you and I are the only two people here with a full grasp of things (probably not true, the others are just less vocal about it).
…makes this...
<smiles>. Hopefullly we'll have no further emotional outbursts. That is always the start of any good conversation falling into a heap where no one benefits.
…very difficult.

Either I understand what is being said above (an understanding which predates this conversation by about a decade) or I do not. In the interest of objectivity, maybe Rod is correct that I am not understanding him? This is an honest request for clarity.

Will someone other than Rod, preferably lankeeyankee since he seems to see what I do not see, speak up and tell me if I am not understanding something here? I ask for someone other than Rod because I think we are miss communicating. If I am not getting his point, will you kindly rephrase it in different words to help me? If you think I have demonstrated that I understand this point (the essentiall difference between A,B,&D), then no need to rephrase.

If I am getting it (as I been saying all along), will you explain that to him in your own words? I think he might accept this better from someone else?

For my part, I'm not going to address particulars or passive aggressive* speaking points anymore.

*NOTE: "you and I are the only two people here with a full grasp of things" = one of numerous examples of 'passive aggressive' (unless you honestly believe it)

If you are going to test against each other then you need to reduce the other variables as much as you can. The way that most people do that is to run two sub-domains with identical installs. If you do not do that, or something similar, then nothing is going to be demonstrated at all

Niccol, I agree wholeheartedly. Sadly, I am on this roller coaster and I see no way to gracefully exit. The "client made me do it" is out the window. :)

I am with you in accepting existing conclusions from this well travelled path, but think there is value in re-examining the subject. Like all technologies, SE's are evolving. So it doesn't hurt to challenge long standing conclusions.

But I agree that the methodology should be much more controlled. And any experimenting should be conducted with complete neutrality from all participants.

We've come this far, might as well pop some popcorn and enjoy! :)

Rod, et al, this is the last bit of tripe I will respond to. Unless someone responds to my request above and helps me understand some mysterious fact that I don't get, I hope everyone following this will understand that me not taking the time to thoroughly respond to everything said should not be read as admissions that his points valid. I will only be responding to things germane to conversation and not correcting his rephrases or extrapolations of my words.

The reason I went for random text though is because if I created the text description using my own words someone would scream that I've somehow managed to embed a hidden message into it to sway the results in my favour. The offer was open for FezNizzle to create this, but it was declined. The random text is/was the next best thing I could do to avoid such accusations.
This does a pretty good job of demonstrating my frustration with this conversation. Theoretically, you could have stacked the deck by inserting your domain name into the content (I assume that is what you think would be objected to?). But this thought never even occurred to me.

I honestly think you are a smart guy. I have read your words, they caused curiosity and led me to believe it is time to rethink a very basic strategy, something I now do automatically. Although it is clear we are in this for different reasons (me because I am curious, you to prove a point) it did not occur to me to be concerned that you might 'cheat'.

My letting you take the lead was a) a vote of confidence in your intelligence, b) because I am ultra lazy and c) because you are the one who started us down the path in the first path. And I'm fine with the direction you have gone. It's not exactly representative of my curiosities, but it goes to an even more basic (integral) part of my questions. Thus I am very interested.

I have not put anything up yet, I was letting you take the lead (again). I will put them up shortly.

2 Jan 2013, 5:18 PM
#90
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

niccol:

Or, while not wanting to appear like some kind of weird heretic, you might listen to what the search engines say about it.

I think everyone can admit that both dynamic and re-written urls work, in that google/se's make them part of their results. But as a non-tech, non-seo guy - just a regular zencart user - my interest is if one works a little better...or worse.

RodG, Feznizzle,

Think I've become aware of at least two things in this thread:

  1. XML sitemap showing categories AND products seems to be more important with re-writing. I don't have that on my test site here.

  2. Native vs Redirected re-writing. Think I'm getting it. I still think it important information that the big guys use "native" re-writing; apparently there is some benefit to a human readable url: whether just for the customer or some search engine benefit I, of course, wouldn't know.

But it causes me to wonder if carts like Prestashop and Opencart, that have re-writing built in, are doing it "natively" or via the less desirable redirects.


I have another zencart, 1.3.9h on Simple SEO URL, which I want to add to test sometime tonight. Just looked and its htaccess rewriting code is remarkably small.

Steve
prommart.com

2 Jan 2013, 5:47 PM
#91
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

Steve,
IF you are using an XML sitemap, you should update it every time you add content. If you are not doing an XML map, then this does not apply. Further, I said that anyone using re-direct should have an XML sitemap. I was wrong, dead wrong. This is a helpful thing, but is not 100% necessary, so long as all links are indexable thru links that can be found thru a chain of links that originate on the index page.

Thanks for the info. The carts that do have an xml sitemap are updated regularly.

I've read, probably here at zc forums, that if ones template has good navigation, then an xml sitemap really isn't necessary. My current test cart here doesn't have a xml sitemap, yet the re-written products do appear in search results. Not sure how long our test product will take. I'm not on this test site alot but it seems that google visits it less often. Perhaps because it s u c k s right now re content.

Steve
prommart.com

2 Jan 2013, 5:58 PM
#92
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

Think I'm getting it. I still think it important information that the big guys use "native" re-writing; apparently there is some benefit to a human readable url: whether just for the customer or some search engine benefit I, of course, wouldn't know.

You've got it perfectly. Really though, this detail was an unnecessary point to drive home, IMHO. Unless, of course, the main reason you are in the discussion is to understand the origins of Rod's point of view (a very basic, very valid point that has been batted around for a decade). It's good to know, but doesn't really matter to you and me. All we want to know is which is better (rephrased to be more technical sounding: does a redirect penalty undo the point of using a redirect mod?).

Hopefully Rod is about to demonstrate something breathtaking and exciting that will benefit us all! :)

Extra thought: Steve, any chance you would mind going ahead and just adding this to your more active site? Waiting a few days probably won't matter much. If you don't want to, no worries. Figured it could not hurt to ask.

2 Jan 2013, 6:02 PM
#93
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!


** Your name/handle: **Feznizzle

** Test product URL: **http://www.stratesysgroup.com/Newsletter_Articles/06/Wurldbitzer_Debibulator (remove ****)

** SEO redirection tool/method: **CEON (allowed CEON to auto-generate)

** Sitemap in use? ** Yes to XML; however this prod has not been added to the XML

** Age of store (if known): **less than 4 months; current cart replaced a WordPress site

** Other Comments: **ZC150

** NOTE: **Rod (or anyone), if you paste my domains into future postings, please be kind and honor my desire to obscure the domains. In the event this discussion gets moved again, I do not want this discussion getting tied to my domains by SE's. Sorry for the inconvenience!


2 Jan 2013, 6:03 PM
#94
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!


** Your name/handle:** Feznizzle

** Test product URL: **http://www.bizsitehost.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=66&products_id=195 (remove ****)

** SEO redirection tool/method: **none

** Sitemap in use? **No XML sitemap

** Age of store (if known): **around 4 or 5 months; current cart replaced some flat html

** Other Comments: **ZC 150; pretty close to a fresh install with little modification

** NOTE: **Rod (or anyone), if you paste my domains into future postings, please be kind and honor my desire to obscure the domains. In the event this discussion gets moved again, I do not want this discussion getting tied to my domains by SE's. Sorry for the inconvenience!


2 Jan 2013, 6:04 PM
#95
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!


** Your name/handle: **Feznizzle

** Test product URL: **http://www.justusedmedicalequipment.com/Defibrillator/Wurldbitzer_Debibulator (remove ****)

** SEO redirection tool/method: **CEON (did not allow CEON to auto-generate)

** Sitemap in use? **Yes; however this prod has not been added to the XML

** Age of store (if known):** about 18 months

** Other Comments: **ZC 139h; notice the word 'Defibrillator' <lots&lots of smiles>;

** NOTE: **Rod (or anyone), if you paste my domains into future postings, please be kind and honor my desire to obscure the domains. In the event this discussion gets moved again, I do not want this discussion getting tied to my domains by SE's. Sorry for the inconvenience!


2 Jan 2013, 6:12 PM
#96
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Woops, sorry Rod.

I forgot that an image stating "No Image Available" gets inserted automatically (technically means there is an image for the product). :blush:

Please do the same for listing.

2 Jan 2013, 7:52 PM
#98
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Date/Time Begin: 2 Jan 13 approx 11:40am PST (California)

Your name/handle: SPH

Test product URL: http://www.fashion-mart.biz/blush-homecoming/wurldbitzer-debibulator

SEO redirection tool/method: Simple SEO URL

Sitemap in use? Yes, but not updated for this test

Age of store (if known) Domain Age 2 yrs, 4 mos per lookup. Not certain of store age, as domain was parked for some time. But zc admin/version says this: "v1.3.9h [2011-06-01 18:23:07] (Fresh Installation)" I think this was the cart store began with.

Other Comments: Another neglected domain but one I soon intend to develop in earnest. Leaving at 1.3.9h for now specifically for the un-1.5.x-upgraded Simple SEO URL, which I think comparable to CEON in someways, and like it better than CEON in some ways. If test shows promise maybe someone will take over and upgrade Simple SEO URL?

Just changed to my pre-loaded Apple Zen template. Wanted to see if its "source ordering" has any effect. This places the content (product name, description) high in the view source, while moving the categories to the bottom of view source. On this template I had already moved the product name even higher, so it should appear around line 110 in view source. Some of our strongest competitors have their "content" appearing very high, sometimes even higher.

As with promdressesforless, did not even include a model number.

Steve
prommart.com

2 Jan 2013, 8:39 PM
#99
lankeeyankee avatar

lankeeyankee

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Posts:
1,514
Plugin Contributions:
1

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

The native sitemap you are referring to is the human sitemap, not for SEs. Totally different kettle of fish.

I will answer the other points more in depth tonight, we are totally slammed packing orders from the 4 day UPS pickup holiday.


Zen Cart and it's community are the best!!

2 Jan 2013, 8:49 PM
#100
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

lankeeyankee:

The native sitemap you are referring to is the human sitemap, not for SEs. Totally different kettle of fish.

I understand that, no need for further explanation on sitemaps. All I was saying is that the native map provides yet another way for SE bots to spider a site, w/o need for xml. The human sitemap used to be more important for SE back in the day...

Glad to hear biz is good! Take your time, not in a hurry here.