If this is your first visit, check our documentation. To post, register or login.
Forums / Other Business Topics / Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Started by feznizzle on 21 Dec 2012, 12:30 PM · Views: 6,356

Results 101 to 120 of 624
2 Jan 2013, 11:19 PM
#101
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

Extra thought: Steve, any chance you would mind going ahead and just adding this to your more active site? Waiting a few days probably won't matter much. If you don't want to, no worries. Figured it could not hurt to ask.

I was waiting for RodG to put up a site, hopefully a main site.

Also, still kind of leery about that gibberish description. But will probably go ahead anyway when I see RodG. Hopefully others, also, with main sites.

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 2:08 AM
#102
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

What Rod is saying (and what we are about to test) is that using category A (re-write mods) will devastate your efforts to earn a good ranking. What I am saying [after first CLEARLY acknowledging that A and B (or A and C) are not the same thing; and that A will always suffer penalty from SE's where B&C will not] is that any redirect penalty will not be horribly major and that this one factor is not negative enough to warrant avoiding rewrite mods.

Almost perfect. My only objection is the term "devastate". Let's review what I have been saying..


if you are using a redirect without a sitemap (or some other link), then you are simply wasting time and effort.

I intend to show you that the redirects are 100% totally and completely ineffective for SEO purposes.

This combined with the fact that we now all agree that redirects themselves are bad for SEO can only mean one thing, this technique should never be used for SEO, it can only have a negative affect.

Just to be clear though, this experiment isn't designed to show how 'good' zencart is (we all know its the best). It is to demonstrate the effectiveness (or lack of) in using redirects as a viable SEO method.

My position has been and remains that using redirects for SEO purposes is pointless, and even detrimental.

There is a far bigger fish for us to fry (The one where I intend/hope to show redirects are completely ineffective in regards to SEO).

The aim is to demonstrate the (in)effectiveness of using redirects to emulate natively generated URL's.

I've nothing against rewriting/redirects when used as intended. I'm vehemently against it's use for 'SEO' purposes though

I've now gone out on a limb and instead of expecting you guys to demonstrate the benefits I'm pretty confident I'll be able to show you quite clearly that it is 1) Completely ineffective, and with lesser confidence Detrimental.

I also have faith that the Google code is advanced enough to produce a level playing field whereby 'content rules', and the attempts to fool the system by creating Human Friendly URL's via rewrites or redirects (which is what you guys will need to do) will either be inneffective (at best) and possibly even detrimental (at worst). IF I can prove this, then I'll have achieved what I've set out to do.

Like it or not, if you (or anyone) is going to promote a technology as a service then it MUST be something that can be proven, otherwise it's just 'snake oil'.

The purpose of this ongoing thread is to see if we CAN prove the technology. If it can't be proven, then it must be assume it simply does work.
This is logic. Not faith.

Google doesn't play 'favourites'. It's prime purpose in life is to provide the most relevant results for any given search query.
This being the case, unless there are other significant factors at play, the test item in my site (no SEO) should get pretty much the same ranking as any other site for this same item, keyword packed URL's included. If/when we find this isn't the case... for example, if my store is nowhere to be seen, then we'll be able to look deeper and perhaps understand why, and hopefully even isolate the component that has made the difference.

My argument is, and always has been, that using URL rewrites/redirects for this purpose is totally and completely ineffective and will cause more problems than it could ever hope to solve. This is NOT a valid method of SEO optimisation.

I'm hoping that this is what our experiments will prove/disprove... not whether it is a positive/negative result, but whether it is significant either way.
In fact this is about the only thing we will be able to determine with any degree of confidence, because if my stance is correct, then I'd expect all stores in the experiment will end up with roughly equal rankings. If my stance is incorrect then I'd be expecting quite a noticeable difference in rankings, with the SEO optimised sites taking top spots. If we can't observe this differential effect then it must be assumed that this form of SEO doesn't work, or is insignificant.

I don't know about you, but I'm actually feeling a little excited about this... I know what I'm expecting to find/see but whether I'll see it or not is another matter.
I'm going to be happy regardless of the results.


Where did the idea that it'd be 'devastating' come from?

Feznizzle:

But I am curious about something here. Since you do not seem to be aware of this very basic ZC function (index.php?main_page=site_map), does it's existence change your thought on the actual results?

Heck no. Seems we've had another misunderstanding. What we have here isn't a 'sitemap' at all, at least not with the same meaning that Google & Co consider a sitemap. This is comparing apples and oranges, and you must think I'm a real idiot if I didn't know the difference. I don't even know why you brought this one up even, it is totally and completely irrelevant.

Feznizzle:

Although it is clear we are in this for different reasons (me because I am curious, you to prove a point) ?

I can only repeat, and keep repeating, I am here because I HOPE to prove a point. Whether this is actually going to be possible or not is something only the tests will show, as such, I am as curious about the results as you are. If I can't prove what I hope to, it still won't tell us a thing about the B vs C scenarios, which will forever be in debate... (unless perhaps you can think of a way to evolve the experiment in some way).

The really important thing though (from a real world perspective) still isn't whether I can show that redirects are ineffective, but whether it can be shown that they have any beneficial effects. I realise that this would be a lot harder to prove though and as such I don't expect you to try. To me, all this means is that you (and a million others) are happy to promote a technology that cannot be proven to work at all. To me, that's simply snake oil.

If it weren't for my love of ZenCart I'd even be happy to let people think this 'snake oil' is essentially harmless, and from the SE perspective it probably is. My issue in this regard then stems back to the fact that more people get into more strife whilst attempting to implement the snake oil, than the ineffectiveness itself. Or putting it another way, I hate seeing Zenners cause themselves all manner of headaches when it can be avoided with no detrimental effects.

OK?

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

3 Jan 2013, 2:21 AM
#103
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

I was waiting for RodG to put up a site, hopefully a main site.

All sites are created equal. My site will be no more 'main' than yours.

If anything it should be considered as a 'control site' because it is 100% native zencart generated URL's with no additional SEO enhancements.

I expect it to perform no worse than the test sites that have been 'maxed out' with SEO techniques (or at least not significantly worse).

If this does turn out to be the case though, guess who's going to have a massive rethink about this entire technique? Yup, Me!!!!

SPH:

Also, still kind of leery about that gibberish description. But will probably go ahead anyway when I see RodG. Hopefully others, also, with main sites.

I'll be putting mine up in the next couple of hours. I hadn't planned to be the last one on board (after all, if time was important I'd like to have given myself the best chance of success), but this delay may actually turn out to be helpful.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

3 Jan 2013, 2:23 AM
#104
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Date/Time: 2 Jan 13 6:20pm PST (California)

Wow! See a google result already...looks like one of Feznizzle's:

http://www.google.com/search?q=Wurldbitzer+Debibulator&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:IE-Address&ie=&oe=

Sorry, got excited and accidently clicked on link at google. Won't do so again with results.

Anyway, that's impressive!

Edit: It is Feznizzle's rewritten article "product". Do ezpages perform better than actual products, I wonder....

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 2:40 AM
#105
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Or is that an actual product? In any case, looks like just one day to google with CEON. Regardless of the outcome with further testers, that's impressive.

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 3:26 AM
#106
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Name/handle: RodG

Test product URL: http://shop.vcsweb.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=3&products_id=222

Added to store: Thu 3rd Jan 13:30 Sth.Aust time.

**SEO redirection tool/method **: NONE

Sitemap in use? No

Age of store (if known): ~5yrs Zencart. (shop has always been a subdomain)

Any other comments that you think may be relevant/important to know.:
This is to be considered the control site for testing purposes. It has had no SEO enhancements whatsover.
This control site has no more (or less) 'authority' than any other site identified as devoid of SEO enhancements. Any discrepency in results between SEO free sites should be independently investigated to produce meaningful results.

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

3 Jan 2013, 3:27 AM
#107
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

No, not an EZ page, just a product. What was that, about 8 hours? Glad you are impressed, not something new here. :cool:

It will probably take a bit longer for the other two. If nothing else, at least we know the penalties from Ceon uri 301 bounces don't delay the indexing.

Thanks for mentioning that you accidentally clicked on the link, Rod. No worries, mate!

But for future reference:
Please! If anyone else searches google for our products, PLEASE do not click on the links (for now). Just copy and paste the URL into your browser if you want to see the page.

With the indulgence of those participating, I would like wait until all are indexed and then we can choose the lowest ranked page to click on for a few days to see if it climbs by virtue of traffic. Shouldn't take more than a week or so to get them all indexed. After that, feel free to click willy nilly. :)

++++
I was confused by you thinking this was an EZ page. Totally meant to test that also, simply forgot... figured it would not hurt to add, since we are not adhering to scientific standards.

I think what you saw that made you say it was an "article" (not sure how that becomes an EZ page) is only an "article" because I named the product category Articles (Newsletter_Articles). But everything in that category is just a product.

3 Jan 2013, 3:29 AM
#108
lankeeyankee avatar

lankeeyankee

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Posts:
1,514
Plugin Contributions:
1

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

Or is that an actual product? In any case, looks like just one day to google with CEON. Regardless of the outcome with further testers, that's impressive.

I think that's because it's the only one that's indexed right now, so it's not much to go by. I will have to do this tomorrow. I only just got in from work and it's 1030pm and I still have customer service emails to take care of. Let's give this a week or more to really get a better idea of what's what. But, with only a few sites it might be really difficult to prove one way or the other with a make believe product only listed on a few sites. A better test might be to list a real item and give it a month to see where all of the test sites rank vs each other in the general mix of multiple (hundreds or thousands) of real sites selling this product. We can always list them as out of stock so we don't take any actual orders for it.


Zen Cart and it's community are the best!!

3 Jan 2013, 3:42 AM
#109
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

Wow! See a google result already...looks like one of Feznizzle's:
Sorry, got excited and accidently clicked on link at google. Won't do so again with results.

Anyway, that's impressive!

Very impressive. This is exactly the kind of results I was hoping to see .... Errr, let me rephrase that... I wasn't hoping to see Feznizzle's site take the lead <g>, but I was hoping to see some noticeable results in a relatively short period of time.

Oh, I now see how google 'penalises' what it considers 'duplicate content'. Another of Feznizzle's sites is being 'hidden' by google with the following message " In order to show you the most relevant results, we have omitted some entries very similar to the 1 already displayed."

Clicking on the link to 'repeat search with omitted results included' reveals justusedmedicalequipment is the hidden entry (only one so far).

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

3 Jan 2013, 3:47 AM
#110
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Too late to edit my mistake on post 107. Sorry Rod, I attributed the clicking to you.

Thought it was strange you were concerned about the clicking since you don't care about it. But I am hoping you will humor me nonetheless. :)

Lankeeyankee is right, it will be more interesting after all are indexed. But I got a kick out of that, too. Been a while since I checked how fast I can get indexed. In this particular case, the speed is most likely a function of the XML sitemap (don't worry, I did not add the prod; but the sitemap has a standing request frequent return visits). Seems like the google bot practically lives there lately.

3 Jan 2013, 3:55 AM
#111
feznizzle avatar

feznizzle

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2010
Posts:
900
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Clicking on the link to 'repeat search with omitted results included' reveals justusedmedicalequipment is the hidden entry (only one so far).
That is why I mistakenly thought you were asking us to generate our own gibberish.

Mega bummer.

Maybe we should start over, this time using the caveats I outlined when I thought you wanted us to generate our own content (limit # of references to the prod words, etc)

Man. I don't know if I have it in me to continue this... :no:

3 Jan 2013, 3:55 AM
#112
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

No, not an EZ page, just a product. What was that, about 8 hours? Glad you are impressed, not something new here. :cool:

Well, for myself and I suspect the thousands of regular zencart users such as myself, that is impressive. But, looking back at post 35 in this thread, my old CEON link, I had some products reach google in just a few days. Fast for me, anyway. We'll see how my sites do in this test. I half expect them not to show at all.

It will probably take a bit longer for the other two. If nothing else, at least we know the penalties from Ceon uri 301 bounces don't delay the indexing.

Your indexed CEON site certainly proves that, and without an xml sitemap. Wasn't that one of the main issues to be tested?

But why do you think that your others might take longer?

BTW, I knew it was a product (not an ezpage) when I first saw your test post, and again immediately after I made my post. Was excited and yes, the articles name threw me for a moment.

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 4:03 AM
#113
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

So then Feznizzle has two sites already at Google, both rewritten urls. As a regular zencart user, I'd say that says something for CEON. But other site factors may be in play to get up there so quick, don't know.

I wonder which site was actually first; can that be determined?

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 4:09 AM
#114
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

lankeeyankee:

I think that's because it's the only one that's indexed right now, so it's not much to go by.

I thought it would take days, maybe weeks, for them to show at google. Especially mine. But perhaps you guys are go good at this that we're only speaking of how many hours to google. :)

Beyond arriving at google, as a regular zencart user, I'm interested in seeing who is on top...if google will show that with its duplicate results hidden.

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 4:26 AM
#115
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

RodG, Feznizzle,

Think I've become aware of at least two things in this thread:

  1. XML sitemap showing categories AND products seems to be more important with re-writing. I don't have that on my test site here.

I know that **Feznizzle **had a change of view about this one, he was in fact correct with his original view, in that an XML sitemap is pretty much essential for the redirection method to have any hope of working at all (failing this, some other kind of link(s) need to be provided to the product URL (friendly form).

SPH:

  1. Native vs Redirected re-writing. Think I'm getting it.

Not wishing to put you offside, but the fact that you are finding this a little difficult to 'get' doesn't really surprise me, because to 'get' it means that you have been able to follow the processes involved to produce the URL that the end user sees. As a general rule this is stuff a typical person/user will never need to know, it just 'works' and we accept the fact (rightly so).

SPH:

I still think it important information that the big guys use "native" re-writing;

I think it important to know that 'native re-writing' doesn't exist. The URL's are either created by the store software itself (Native) OR someone or something creates another different URL that then gets redirected to the Native URL.

SPH:

apparently there is some benefit to a human readable url: whether just for the customer or some search engine benefit I, of course, wouldn't know.

Any benefits gained in this way is purely for the customer/human benefit. However, for the sake of this discussion, it isn't relevant, and I'm quite happy to acknowledge/agree that the fallout from the human benefits will probably help the SE rankings. This is something we aren't trying to test/prove at the moment. Another time perhaps?

SPH:

But it causes me to wonder if carts like Prestashop and Opencart, that have re-writing built in, are doing it "natively" or via the less desirable redirects.

"re-writing built in" doesn't exist. You have somehow invented this yourself, which means you are making it more complicated than it really is.

Lets try this:
ALL stores/sites will create 'native' URL's. The content of these URL's could be complex/simple/keyword_padded/ or simply the domain name itself. It is simply how any given software has been coded that produces the results.

The redirects however are entirely optional. They can best be considered as shortcuts to any given Native URL. The native URL's are never changed or modified in any way.

Are you familiar with 'tinyURL'? It is exactly the same principle. feznizzle used it earlier in this thread with http://tinyurl.com/not-sure-why which (if working) when clicked will/should bring you back to this forum. "http://tinyurl.com/not-sure-why" doesn't actually exist as a webpage.

Have I made this clearer for you, or did I somehow manage to muddy the waters even further?

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

3 Jan 2013, 4:29 AM
#116
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Date/Time: 2 Jan 13 approx 8:15pm PST (California)

Your name/handle: SPH

Test product URL: http://www.prommart.com/wurldbitzer-debibulator-p-2210.html

SEO redirection tool/method: Ultimate SEO URL 2.212 (latest)

Sitemap in use? Yes, the free zencart google sitemap xml plugin, but not regenerated for this test.

Age of store (if known): 9 yrs, 3 mos per lookup. Began with a couple of monthly pay commercial carts. My zencart profile says I joined 10 Jan 2006 so probably about when I began with zencart.

Other comments: Site should be doing better than it does, and has done well in past. Possible hit by first Panda...and my messing around too much. My "All Products" currently indicates 1,930, which appears to be the most thus far. Wonder how google will find test product among so many. At least google is currently on site.

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 4:46 AM
#117
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

RodG:

I know that **Feznizzle **had a change of view about this one, he was in fact correct with his original view, in that an XML sitemap is pretty much essential for the redirection method to have any hope of working at all (failing this, some other kind of link(s) need to be provided to the product URL (friendly form).

RodG, with all respect (truly), don't Feznizzle's indexed CEON sites that are, to my understanding, not using an xml sitemap for the test product, prove that a xml sitemap is not necessary? Or is zencart's "human" default sitemap with its categories, and the category navigation system itself, sufficient?

My first test site, promdressesforless.us, does not have an xml sitemap at all. Yet products show at google. Now, how long that takes...perhaps we'll see with the test product.

BTW, don't yet see anything at Yahoo/Bing. Do we care about them? And are some carts perhaps more optimized for Google (and what would be that difference, one wonders.)

Steve
prommart.com

3 Jan 2013, 4:53 AM
#118
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

Feznizzle:

No, not an EZ page, just a product. What was that, about 8 hours? Glad you are impressed, not something new here. :cool:.

FWIW, I'm expecting similar results with our Native ZenCart entry. (If I'm wrong, I'm going to start using CEON) :)

Feznizzle:

If nothing else, at least we know the penalties from Ceon uri 301 bounces don't delay the indexing.

I'm hoping to see several things like this come out of this experiment. Some will surprise me, others won't.

I don't know if this is too early to call yet, but already I've found it interesting that SPH's first entry
Test product URL: http://www.promdressesforless.us/wur...ator-p-36.html
SEO redirection tool/method: Ultimate SEO URL version 2.212 (latest)
Sitemap in use? No, and not yet installed on this site

Was the 1st of the sites to add the test product, but at time of writing this it doesn't appear in Google yet.
Both your's and SPH's sites use a redirection tool, but SPH doesn't have a sitemap (only real obvious difference). I suspect that it is quite probably the sitemap that has made all the difference. Would you agree?

Steve. Please don't panic over this, and please DO NOT add a sitemap to the site (just yet). I'm curious as to how long it will take to be indexed (assuming it gets indexed at all). I'd like to suggest that if it doesn't show up in 7 days (from the time the product was added) it isn't going to show at all. In which case, if you then add a sitemap and it shows within the following 8hours or so, we should be able to conclude a sitemap is essential.
Does anyone disagree with this?

Feznizzle:

But for future reference:
Please! If anyone else searches google for our products, PLEASE do not click on the links (for now). Just copy and paste the URL into your browser if you want to see the page.

A reasonable request. Accidents will happen though.

Feznizzle:

With the indulgence of those participating, I would like wait until all are indexed and then we can choose the lowest ranked page to click on for a few days to see if it climbs by virtue of traffic. Shouldn't take more than a week or so to get them all indexed. After that, feel free to click willy nilly. :)

Excellent idea! Not part of the initial experiment, but most definitely a worthwhile doing as a secondary experiment.

We might as well learn as much as we possibly can from these tests, because seriously, I'm not aware of any other similar tests ever being conducted before.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

3 Jan 2013, 5:19 AM
#119
rodg avatar

rodg

Deceased

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Australia
Posts:
6,263
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

SPH:

RodG, with all respect (truly), don't Feznizzle's indexed CEON sites that are, to my understanding, not using an xml sitemap for the test product, prove that a xml sitemap is not necessary?

I'm tending to think the opposite is being proven true. I agree/acknowledge he hasn't added the product to his sitemap, but I'm thinking that his existing sitemap has enough information that has allowed google to find his product very quickly, and that your lack of sitemap is why your hasn't shown yet.

However, I also concede that many other factors could be at play here though, such as the initial popularity/age of the site.

SPH:

Or is zencart's "human" default sitemap with its categories, and the category navigation system itself, sufficient?

Assuming my site shows as quickly as Feznizzle's then we could be looking at the situation whereby ZenCarts default sitemap/navigation is shown to be sufficent. A site using redirects and a suitable XML sitemap is also good, but a site using redirects without a sitemap is unacceptable. If not totally unacceptable, then at bare minimum it is negatively affecting the time it takes to be indexed.

SPH:

My first test site, promdressesforless.us, does not have an xml sitemap at all. Yet products show at google. Now, how long that takes...perhaps we'll see with the test product.

This is one of the things I'm wanting/hoping these experiments will show... Even without an XML sitemap google will index it eventually, but when it does so, I'm expecting that it'll be zencart's native URL that gets indexed rather than the redirection URL.
Don't know if my expectations will be met or not. Time will/should tell.

SPH:

BTW, don't yet see anything at Yahoo/Bing. Do we care about them?

We should care about them if we are really interesting in getting the best exposure for our stores/products, but I don't think it worth considering them in regards to these experiments.. Unless perhaps you notice they produce significantly different results.

SPH:

And are some carts perhaps more optimized for Google (and what would be that difference, one wonders.)

If by some carts you are refering to zencart, osc, prestashop ,etc this will have to be studied in another experiment. If the some carts means different zencart stores then we are pretty much all on equal ground. Sure our templates may have an effect, but by definition, the templates should only affect the way the cart 'looks'. The underlying content/functioning doesn't change.

Cheers
Rod

NOTE: We are sorry that Rod is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

Ozpost - The Ultimate Shipping module for Australian Merchants. Click these links for its Homepage, or Download from Zen-Cart.com.

3 Jan 2013, 5:23 AM
#120
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!

RodG:

I don't know if this is too early to call yet, but already I've found it interesting that SPH's first entry
Test product URL: http://www.promdressesforless.us/wur...ator-p-36.html
SEO redirection tool/method: Ultimate SEO URL version 2.212 (latest)
Sitemap in use? No, and not yet installed on this site

Was the 1st of the sites to add the test product, but at time of writing this it doesn't appear in Google yet.
Both your's and SPH's sites use a redirection tool, but SPH doesn't have a sitemap (only real obvious difference). I suspect that it is quite probably the sitemap that has made all the difference. Would you agree?

I'd agree that is a difference. But as a non-tech guy, don't see why some urls in an existing xml sitemap would enhance a test product not yet in it. Actually, to my thinking, not being in the xml sitemap would indicate to google that the test product doesn't exist on the site. But then, I'm learning on this thread. :)

Steve. Please don't panic over this, and please DO NOT add a sitemap to the site (just yet). I'm curious as to how long it will take to be indexed (assuming it gets indexed at all). I'd like to suggest that if it doesn't show up in 7 days (from the time the product was added) it isn't going to show at all. In which case, if you then add a sitemap and it shows within the following 8hours or so, we should be able to conclude a sitemap is essential.
Does anyone disagree with this?

No panic here. I'm like you: just want to learn something, if something works or not.

But my second site - fashion-mart.biz - and my recently added prommart.com do both have xml sitemaps, just not regenerated for the test product. So if my test products there still do not show, despite the xml sitemaps, then perhaps we can conclude: 1. CEON is the superior re-writer, or 2. my sites just s u c k for google...or maybe both.

As I recall Feznizzle also has a dynamic url site in the test. What is the reason it has not shown thus far? Are perhaps the other two sites just more favorable for google, apart from CEON? Or is it because it lacks an xml sitemap, which apparently even dynamic urls need? (Like with rewriting, maybe the Zencart team doesn't consider xml sitemaps that useful or important.)

EDIT: by different carts for google, I meant zencarts. Some just more "google SEO optimized".

Steve
prommart.com