Return Authorization Module (RMA)

[rbarbour]

Whether it be via message-stack or inline form error messages, these error messages need to be displayed one way or another (if you want required fields).

This mod uses inline error messages, IMHO, i do not think this was change for change sake, with so many forms using CSS tool-tips and jQuery to display inline error messages, I think it was to give the form a more up-to-date presence.

If one chooses to convert to message-stack by all means, try my MessageStack LightAlert Light Box.

I have to agree with @DivaVocals, the inline error messages do provide better usability hence all the new CSS tool-tips and jQuery form builders.

A Return form DOES help sales and confidence with a customer IMHO.

[dw08gm]

A Return form DOES help sales and confidence with a customer IMHO.

We are not disputing the value of Return forms, but rather only where the error messages in the updated mod are to be placed.

My comment regarding form layout dirsuption seems to have been overlooked.

cheers

[rbarbour]

We are not disputing the value of Return forms, but rather only where the error messages in the updated mod are to be placed.

My comment regarding form layout dirsuption seems to have been overlooked.

cheers

Not overlooked, I ran into the same issue on a site I updated - def something to reconsider as far as adding constraints for the displayed (span) error which should be easily accomplished as I used css.

[DivaVocals]

My comment regarding form layout dirsuption seems to have been overlooked.

cheers

Not sure what you are referring to here.. what layout "disruption" (not sure if this is misspelled or not in your post) are you referring to???

[DivaVocals]

Whether it be via message-stack or inline form error messages, these error messages need to be displayed one way or another (if you want required fields).

This mod uses inline error messages, IMHO, i do not think this was change for change sake, with so many forms using CSS tool-tips and jQuery to display inline error messages, I think it was to give the form a more up-to-date presence.

If one chooses to convert to message-stack by all means, try my MessageStack LightAlert Light Box.

I have to agree with @DivaVocals, the inline error messages do provide better usability hence all the new CSS tool-tips and jQuery form builders.

A Return form DOES help sales and confidence with a customer IMHO.

I agree.. inline messages are used more often in applications these days because they ensure that end users have fewer issues understanding EXACTLY what is required when a form fails validation on submit. It's not change for change sake at all.. it is IMPROVED usability, and I don't understand how that is a BAD thing..