I had always used Clyde Jones' awesome "Order Steps - Tableless" mod for ALL my clients so that the checkout page was cleaner and more intuitive looking for customers..
However, I had 1 or 2 clients who felt that signing up for a store account was confusing or intimidating for customers and wanted to look into the possibility of offering these customers an option of checking out without an account. The earlier versions of the COWOA mod had it's own set of issues which made it an undesireable solution for me to rollout to my clients. So I began looking into FEC as an option since it included the COWOA option.
I've not implented FEC on any of my client's sites, but I have been doing some extensive testing of it on my test site for a while now..
Ultimately once I got it all setup and working (sort of), my clients didn't like it at all.. In particular they did not like the WAY it looked.. They preferred the look and feel that the "Order Steps - Tableless" gave the checkout pages over the FEC look and feel..
For my side of things, I was concerned with the sheer number of new files that FEC included.. I also discovered that there are some conflicts with other mods (most notably the current version of the Gift Wrap mod), and frankly I found the whole "one screen" look not only a LOT more intimidating looking than the normal checkout, but it was a bit of a challenge to make this "one screen" layout look good with certain store layouts/templates...
Also with regards to the included Super Orders files, I had to do a fair amount of work to get it updated and merged with the latest version of Super Orders. Not to mention that the required changes to orders.php and packingslip.php were not all carried over exactly the same way to their Super Orders counterparts. There was no invoice.php with the FEC code so I had to create it and it's Super Orders counterpart super_invoice.php.
Attempting to integrate other checkout mods such as "Add Shipping Telephone" was a nightmare, and I never REALLY got it all working as it should..
All this said, I haven't yet tried throwing in Ceon URI Mapping to the mix yet, but I can already see that this will not be a happy marriage.. :no:
So now that COWOA is updated and supposed to be improved, I am going to give that a looksee.. The new versions seem to have worked out all the kinks from the earlier versions that turned me off of this mod.. AND on the surface it looks like it will play nice with Ceon URI Mapping..
My only "beef" with COWOA is the fact that it bundles in the "Order Steps - Tableless" mod. It's not that I am NOT a fan of this mod (I think I established that I am), I am just not a fan of mods which bundle in other mods as part of the core base.. It forces people to use a mod they MAY NOT want to use, AND IMHO it makes updates to COWOA twice as tedious for the mod authors because they not only have to keep up with Zen Cart changes, but they also have to keep up with changes to the bundled in mods as well..
That said my next client demo will be COWOA, Order Steps - Tableless, Add Shipping Telephone, and FINALLY Ceon URI Mapping.. I think this will be the combo my client's will like.. (and the combo that will give me the least amount of headaches)
conor:
Hi,
FEC is a poorly written module, so I don't recommend using it on any store, but many sites (hundreds) are indeed using it fine with Ceon URI Mapping.
Sites also seems to be using it with the even-worse-written AJAX version but I recently tried to help someone with integrating this with Ceon URI Mapping and although we could get most of it to work by adding some exclusions, we weren't able to get the Easy Sign up and Login functionality working perfectly.
Saying that though, this was my first experience with the Easy Sign up and Login functionality and it was a terrible one.. why anyone would put their customers through that I don't know.. I personally think it could only damage a store's sales as people will be put off by the large number of fields displayed on one page. I certainly found it an intimidating form to fill in. And that's before I encountered the problem of it constantly asking me to "pick a state from the dropdown" when it wasn't displaying a dropdown! A very frustrating experience.
So.. my recommendation is if you're going to use FEC, use the **better **normal version, not the AJAX version.
Anyone else here have any experience with these modules?
All the best..
Conor
ceon