Forums / Search Engines / seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Started by zvenson on 27 Jun 2009, 6:24 AM · Views: 7,987

Results 21 to 40 of 52
4 Oct 2010, 5:23 PM
#21
dutchy avatar

dutchy

Zen Follower

Join Date:
May 2010
Location:
London
Posts:
324
Plugin Contributions:
0

seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

gjh42:

There are thousands of sites all around the world paying thousands of dollars monthly to be in touch with the latest SEO trends

True, and there are thousands of people paying for all kinds of things being sold... does that indicate that they are all actually effective?

True, and all the information you need to do great SEO is included in the google webmasters guide and Matt's blog. You dont need to pay to have great SEO, if you have the time to learn and monitor. But most people don't have that time. Of course choosing a company / person to perform your SEO is a mine field alone.

However the OP asked which SEO mod is best. For me, it is CEONs URI Manager. And if used right, with good content and meta tag key words the OP will see better Google rankings and sooner than with out CEONs add-on

NB while meta tag keywords are not used to rank / index pages, google still use them to reference against content and the URI. Disagree with this statement? Well, it's all there, in their own guide/blog.

Google it, lol

5 Oct 2010, 10:23 AM
#22
website_rob avatar

website_rob

Inactive

Join Date:
Oct 2006
Location:
Alberta, Canada
Posts:
4,572
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

stormae:

I absolutely agree, however, the other people are placing arguments like:

There was a time when SEO friendly URLs made "somewhat" of a difference but that difference is now gone.That is absolutely untrue. You are relying on the fact that google indexes the urls now, yes it does!

But they index far slower and far worse then SEO Friendly URLs. There have been multiple publications about it and everyone claiming thats not true must do their reading on the internet before commenting here. You can never convince me that an url that looks like http://domain.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=45 will be better looking then http://domain.com/product-category-productname-productoption1-productoption/productoption3.

That is absurd even to think of. There are thousands of sites all around the world paying thousands of dollars monthly to be in touch with the latest SEO trends, go read some blogs and then comment.

Moral of the story, SEO Urls is for people who need optimization, it is not mandatory, but it helps.

Since you took the time to reply to my post, let me reply to yours.

Let us look at post #11, just 3 above yours, that provided a real world example.

CoolCarPartsOnline

I actually did a test on live sites to compare both approaches.

One used SEO mod. The second was left standard. After 2 months, the standard site was better indexed in Google and bring just as good sales as the other site if not more.

There is no one answer to this question. Every site is unique in it's own world, what might work for someone might not work for another. Just having SEO URL will not increase your sales on it's own. SEO is multiple things that work together and just doing one thing will not increase your profit or ROI. Seems you didn't read that post or ignored it because it would seem that it provides evidence to support what I said and evidence to show what you said is wrong.

Fact is, whether or not SEO URLs in today's world are helpful or not needs to be balanced by the time & cost of maintaining those SEO URLs. In my opinion, it is not.

I have my reasons (based on experience and facts) for such an opinion but since this thread is about which is the best ZC SEO module to use, no need to take the thread too far off topic. Just wanted to balance out your reply.

The learning is in the doing.

Potent Products

29 Nov 2010, 10:50 PM
#23
danilyn22 avatar

danilyn22

Zen Follower

Join Date:
Dec 2008
Location:
California
Posts:
102
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

This is an interesting post and I read it completely because I loaded SEO Url Mod which made very pretty URLS but when I run the Site Map Mod (by andrew) the url's in the site map are all the standard URL's. I also tried using Gsite Crawler which did the same thing. Google unindexed all my pages because it stated I am "redirecting", which I guess I am.

I am thinking of removing the SEO Url mod to keep google happy. Has anyone found a way for these 2 mods to play nice with each other?

As a matter of discussion I also run a store on the Volusion platform which is a SEO friendly store. I opened this store on this platform because I thought the SEO Friendly would index quickly. It did not and my Zencart store with standard URLS are doing much better.

29 Nov 2010, 11:26 PM
#24
schoolboy avatar

schoolboy

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jun 2005
Location:
Cumbria, UK
Posts:
10,327
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

stormae:

Moral of the story, SEO Urls is for people who need optimization, it is not mandatory, but it helps.

We employ one of the country's most experienced SEO people. He chuckles politely at your suggestion and then says quietly: "Re-written static URL's off a dynamic content site are usually risky and are now unnecessary. The SE's prefer the dynamic link - expecially if its structure is logical - as is the case with zencart."

He goes further. "Storm is probably trying to get his competitors to achieve lower rankings - that's why he's telling them to use url re-writers!"

Clever move, Stormae... I actually agree with you then.

HEY... ALL MY COMPETITORS... LISTEN HERE... GET GOOD SEO WITH URL RE-WRITERS! WE'LL EVEN INSTALL ONE FOR YOU FOR FREE! :D

20 years a Zencart User

29 Nov 2010, 11:38 PM
#25
schoolboy avatar

schoolboy

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jun 2005
Location:
Cumbria, UK
Posts:
10,327
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

My SEO colleague adds the following.

"Many people - too many people in fact - believe that search engines focus on the URL. They don't. They are after the underlying content.

"That is what is critical and the content, its format, structure, architecture and flow are what influence ranking. The big risk is that artificial "static" url's often do not provide access to the full content, which in a dynamic page can be - and often is - several hundred components all cobbled together. A dynamic URL will always generate a full, new page, and will do it properly, and compose it in the manner it was designed to. It will also provide access to data that may otherwise be hidden. A Static URL can actually mask some of this assembly - and therefore mask underlying content, or worse, give the impression of duplicate content.

"People who think that a "readable URL" is important to search Engines miss the point entirely. The critical issue is indexable and analysable content. If you blur the edges in this area, your rankings will suffer. Fact."

20 years a Zencart User

7 Dec 2010, 8:28 PM
#26
monkeyjr47906 avatar

monkeyjr47906

New Zenner

Join Date:
Nov 2007
Posts:
72
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Google URL guide

Just read it. I have no idea what the people in this forum are blathering about. Just direct users to the most recent and most relevant information. Don't clog the forum with rants and opinions, if you need to rant go to areas that are appropriate.

7 Dec 2010, 8:52 PM
#27
gjh42 avatar

gjh42

Black Belt

Join Date:
Jul 2005
Location:
Upstate NY
Posts:
21,874
Plugin Contributions:
8

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Essentially, a "perfect" URL rewriter would make the best of all possible worlds, giving all the information that is useful to people and crawlers and nothing else. Unfortunately, there is no such thing as a perfect, totally automated rewriter. Imperfect ones run the risk of actually making it harder for crawlers to derive the best info from a site. Either you get the best available software and constantly tune and maintain it correctly, or keep the dynamic URLs that Zen Cart generates automatically and let the crawlers work effectively. (Along with the built-in features for eliminating duplicates etc.)

7 Dec 2010, 11:09 PM
#28
zc_fan avatar

zc_fan

New Zenner

Join Date:
Sep 2010
Location:
SF Bay Area
Posts:
54
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

its really funny, the following links contradict each other...

This link is in favor of static URL
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=76329

This link is in favor of dynamic URL
http://googlewebmastercentral.##########################/2008/09/dynamic-urls-vs-static-urls.html

With all this complication and contradictions the point still remains - should dynamic URLs be converted to static or not?

If yes, which of the three does it the "most responsible" way as per the google webmasters blog - not just hiding the parameters but handling them so no information is dropped.

:unsure:

8 Dec 2010, 12:47 AM
#29
schoolboy avatar

schoolboy

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jun 2005
Location:
Cumbria, UK
Posts:
10,327
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

monkeyjr47906:

Google URL guide

Just read it. I have no idea what the people in this forum are blathering about. Just direct users to the most recent and most relevant information. Don't clog the forum with rants and opinions, if you need to rant go to areas that are appropriate.

If you don't like this thread, go to disney.com . This subject is valid, and interesting. The debate is hot, which is just fine, as this adds to the excitement. There's no blathering going on - unless you are too ignorant to understand what's being debated - and your ignorance is not something that the commentators are responsible for, I'm afraid. :D

20 years a Zencart User

8 Dec 2010, 1:07 AM
#30
schoolboy avatar

schoolboy

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jun 2005
Location:
Cumbria, UK
Posts:
10,327
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

zc_fan:

its really funny, the following links contradict each other...

This link is in favor of static URL
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=76329

This link is in favor of dynamic URL
http://googlewebmastercentral.##########################/2008/09/dynamic-urls-vs-static-urls.html

With all this complication and contradictions the point still remains - should dynamic URLs be converted to static or not?

If yes, which of the three does it the "most responsible" way as per the google webmasters blog - not just hiding the parameters but handling them so no information is dropped.

:unsure:

The notion that Search Engines favour "readable" URL's is erroneous. The nature of the URL is of no significance as to how a search engine ranks a site - but it can be of critical importance to how it accesses vital information ***behind the URL.


The SE's are after CONTENT, and dynamic links converted to static links run the severe risk of MASKING the full content, or worse, giving the SE the impression of duplicate content.

Many years ago, when dynamic content systems started to take over from flat html sites, the SE's kept pace with developments because they knew that the ability to spider and index content in a dynamic system would be of vital importance to accurate results delivery.

Today, ALL important websites are Dynamic Content Systems. And MOST business websites (well over 85%) are based on some kind of dynamic content mechanism.

The fact that ALL major search engines (and there really are only three of significance - Google, Yahoo and Bing) have publically stated that they prefer links to remain dynamic should itself be sufficient grounds to not tamper with URL's.

20 years a Zencart User

11 Dec 2010, 4:31 PM
#31
conor avatar

conor

Passed

Join Date:
Aug 2004
Location:
Belfast, Northern Ireland
Posts:
2,480
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Hi schoolboy,

How are you?

schoolboy:

The notion that Search Engines favour "readable" URL's is erroneous. The nature of the URL is of no significance as to how a search engine ranks a site - but it can be of critical importance to how it accesses vital information behind the URL.
Ceon URI Mapping's primary purpose isn't SEO but URLs for humans. It's silly to put a dynamic Zen Cart URI on marketing material. I've written the software to allow sites to use and promote their URIs as desired, especially in non-electronic media (e.g. mysite.com/november-special).

However, I've lots of people saying to me that from experience their sites' rankings jumped up after they converted their URIs to ones that have keywords in them.

Given the number of people who have said this to me, I think the search engines must still give a certain amount of credit to keywords in a URI.

Content is king, no doubt, but a small factor seems to be the actual URI.

Just search for your own name on the net for example.. if I do so, since I own a domain with my name it in I'm top, despite having one single line of text on the page. Other people with my name, with full blogs full of information come way below me. My name is first simply because of the URI, not because of the content. Now of course, I'm only speaking about a domain name here.. but I've noticed a very slight pattern with the same happening with keywords being present in the rest of the URI.

As I said, content is King and you can name the URI whatever you want if you have great content and it will rank better than a page that has poor content (taking all other factors like linking etc. as equal), but if two **identical **pages are listed and one has keywords in the URI it will rank higher than the other, in my experience.

schoolboy:

The SE's are after CONTENT, and dynamic links converted to static links run the severe risk of MASKING the full content, or worse, giving the SE the impression of duplicate content.

With canonical URI support, a Zen Cart URI with a mapping of mysite.com/books will always have just one URI, avoiding any duplicate content issues.

/books?sort=a /books?page=2 and /books?sort=d2&page=4 will all have the same canonical URI of /books and therefore will not be regarded as duplicate pages, same as if /books had been /index.php?main_page=index&cPath=12

schoolboy:

Today, ALL important websites are Dynamic Content Systems. And MOST business websites (well over 85%) are based on some kind of dynamic content mechanism.

As I show above, just because you use a static URI for the principal/canonical URI for a dynamic page doesn't mean that the page is no longer dynamic. No functionality has changed, the site is as dynamic as ever. It just has URIs which make more sense to humans.

schoolboy:

The fact that ALL major search engines (and there really are only three of significance - Google, Yahoo and Bing) have publically stated that they prefer links to remain dynamic should itself be sufficient grounds to not tamper with URL's.

If it doesn't make any difference to the search engines, why not have nice URIs? :)

To come at things from a slightly different angle.. and although this doesn't apply so much/strongly to shopping sites, but more for blogs etc...

I actually believe, in conjunction with Tim Berners-Lee, that one of the most important things is that once a URI is published that it remains valid forever. I.e., 1000 years from now, if a site is still going, yoursite.com/books should still work and show the list of books for sale on the site.

A better/more realistic example for "long term URIs" is that of articles: /2010/12/ideas-on-uri-formats should still be a valid link to that article years from now.

The technology used to create the page's content should never be part of the URI in my opinion. I.e. index.php would be meaningless 100 years from now when PHP has been replaced by some other technology. However /books would/should still be a relevant/valid URI.

So for that reason alone I think all sites are better to use "static" URIs.

And with that, all of the search engine optimisation talk simply becomes "backchat" to me.. interesting but ultimately, given the smallish effects noticed, not important! :)

Anyway.. must get back to finishing version 4 of the Ceon module, instead of chatting here, will never get a break for Christmas otherwise! :)

All the best..

Conor
ceon

NOTE: We are sorry that Conor is no longer with us.
We are grateful for all his contributions to the Zen Cart community.

11 Jan 2011, 4:55 PM
#32
fujiwhara avatar

fujiwhara

New Zenner

Join Date:
Jan 2011
Posts:
1
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Just wanted to make a quick comment about SEO since I do it full-time and have done it since the internet started. I also consult once a week in a meeting with leading SEO Experts across the globe.

There is absolutely no doubt that using keywords in your title, meta tags, and urls make a HUGE difference in keyword targeted traffic and ranking high on organic results.

Respectfully,

Chris Gordon
Search Engine Marketing
Fujiwhara, Inc.

11 Jan 2011, 11:04 PM
#33
ray_the_otter avatar

ray_the_otter

Zen Follower

Join Date:
Jul 2010
Posts:
278
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

I have just watched a very long and at times very boring weblog with Matt Cutts from a 2010 wordpress conference on SEO for blogs. Over 20 minutes of this this video log was all about creating the most appropriate 'human readable URL' from your keywords to get the best results possible in Google... what would he know about SEO! :P

Oh and for the dude that first asked... i use CEONs and seen my rank shoot up to the bottom/middle half of the first page within a few weeks. Now im floating around in the top 6. My Google position for my product images are all on the first page since getting rid of Image Handler 2 and replacing it with Image Manager 1.4 as my images are now named after my products and not k4jb5hk3h453k4h5kh3k4jh5kj3h45jkh34kj5kh.gif

I am unable to answer any private messages for any of the add-on's I am associated with. I have migrated to other cart systems so sadly cannot offer any assistance, all the best and I hope you get your query fixed soon!

12 Jan 2011, 6:07 PM
#34
schoolboy avatar

schoolboy

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jun 2005
Location:
Cumbria, UK
Posts:
10,327
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

As I've said elsewhere on the forum on this SEO URL topic, perhaps the ONLY mod you can trust to be totally reliable is Conor's mod.

So if you are to elect to have your URL's rewritten, then Ceon (Connor's) mod is definitely the one to choose.

20 years a Zencart User

1 Jul 2011, 5:04 PM
#35
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

schoolboy:

As I've said elsewhere on the forum on this SEO URL topic, perhaps the ONLY mod you can trust to be totally reliable is Conor's mod.

So if you are to elect to have your URL's rewritten, then Ceon (Connor's) mod is definitely the one to choose.

What is your basis for this statement? How is CEON better than Yellow's Simple SEO URL or the paid for Magic SEO URL?

Steve
prommart.com

1 Jul 2011, 7:33 PM
#36
divavocals avatar

divavocals

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Los Angeles, California, United States
Posts:
10,011
Plugin Contributions:
3

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

SPH:

What is your basis for this statement? How is CEON better than Yellow's Simple SEO URL or the paid for Magic SEO URL?
Never used Magic SEO, but speaking for myself I made TWO attempts on TWO different sites to get SSU to work. Both times I ran into issues with it interfering with content on the main page of BOTH sites.. I installed Ceon URI Mapping and with minimal fuss I had it up and running on both sites in VERY short order.. Haven't looked back since..

My Site - Zen Cart & WordPress integration specialist
I don't answer support questions via PM. Post add-on support questions in the support thread. The question & the answer will benefit others with similar issues.

1 Jul 2011, 9:21 PM
#37
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Diva, thanks for the reply and you now make me think that I misunderstood Schoolboy's statement. By most reliable, I assumed he meant works best for SEO. Now, maybe he meant works best with zencart?

We have various sites, two of them using Magic SEO URL (the paid one). Recent site upgrades brought us to point of considering a change. Biggest problem from our seo person: trying to maintain optimized urls.

We are using Yellow's Simple SEO on some live sites (basic default setting with -c & -p). And I am testing fully stripped version here:

http://www.prom-mart.com/flaunt/flaunt-8824-dress

Have CEON's URL here:

http://www.pageant-mart.com/designers/alyce-designs/alyce-8886

Both "work" insofar as re-writing. But both break my zencarts, in that if you go to a product, then to something like Contact Us, then hit back button at bottom of Contact Us, you either get a page not found or return to homepage. Not great on page 2 of checkout, when customer is sent off to conditions page.

Also, I noticed that CEON url no longer shows canonical link in url. I used version from zencart download; notice he may have a later version. Going too fast to see if any merging to 1.3.9h files were needed; could replace canonical link. Our seo person did seem to hesitate over CEON and preferred Simple SEO.

However, last evening I re-bought and installed Magic SEO for our upgraded site, that was going bare with dynamic urls for two days; if nothing else than to stabalize it while we think.

Curious thing about Magic SEO: no matter the cats/subcats, it writes url as https://www.mydomain.com/product-#.html. Does not show cats/subcats in url. Our SEO person thought that best, under circumstances. Maybe CEON or Simple SEO can do this; haven't gotten that far.

One thing about Magic SEO: it has always worked for us both with zencart integration and seo/google performance. From my experience with all of them, I'd say that Magic SEO Url is the most "reliable".

One thing I don't necessarily like about Magic SEO: all the strange code in some files and fact have to rely on person overseas. But maybe he's a seo/rewriter genius, don't know.

My personal main live site (below) was formerly on Magic SEO URL, now dynamic urls for last year. It is performing surprisingly well, so Schoolboy might be correct about that: dynamic urls work. I would like readable urls, though, if not for customer then for myself when working. Of course, when on Magic SEO, it also rocked; perhaps even better?

One thing I'm fighting: a kind of loyalty to some opensource philosophy rather than paid mods. But this loyalty probably isn't good from a business end. Or economic end, when I can spend weeks messing with some mod and install something else in a few minutes.

I would possibly go with Simple SEO if the "back button" issue were fixed. It rewrites existing cats/products and is opensource. Plus (as with CEON but apparently unlike Magic SEO) it can strip out all url characters, even product id. If this works with google, one can potentially take their url with them where-ever they go cartwise?

Okay, enough of this tome but the url/rewriter issue has been most pressing business issue for few days now.

SPH
https://www.prommart.com - currently dynamic urls.

Steve
prommart.com

1 Jul 2011, 10:28 PM
#38
niccol avatar

niccol

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2009
Posts:
2,138
Plugin Contributions:
1

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

I agree with Conor. Why not have pretty URLs? These days it seems that the search engines can index them whatever so if people want that then why not? And as he says there is a line of argument that says that the URL should be platform independent.

I have used Ceon - never had any issues. I have also used SSU when a site is using a large csv imported product base. SSU will cope with this better. Ceon, on my last checking, will not automatically generate URLs in these circumstances I believe. B ut I have had many more frustrating glitches with SSU than Ceon and would always use Ceon where possible.

Nick
iszent.com

1 Jul 2011, 10:42 PM
#39
divavocals avatar

divavocals

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2007
Location:
Los Angeles, California, United States
Posts:
10,011
Plugin Contributions:
3

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Yes I think you may very well have misunderstood..

SPH:

Both "work" insofar as re-writing. But both break my zencarts, in that if you go to a product, then to something like Contact Us, then hit back button at bottom of Contact Us, you either get a page not found or return to homepage. Not great on page 2 of checkout, when customer is sent off to conditions page.

Perhaps you should post this on the support thread for Ceon URI.. I can't replicate this behavior on any of my sites..

niccol:

B ut I have had many more frustrating glitches with SSU than Ceon and would always use Ceon where possible.This echoes my sentiments exactly..:clap:

My Site - Zen Cart & WordPress integration specialist
I don't answer support questions via PM. Post add-on support questions in the support thread. The question & the answer will benefit others with similar issues.

1 Jul 2011, 10:46 PM
#40
sph avatar

sph

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jan 2006
Posts:
1,556
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

DivaVocals:

Yes I think you may very well have misunderstood..
Perhaps you should post this on the support thread for Ceon URI.. I can't replicate this behavior on any of my sites..

Actually, I earlier looked at your site and some examples. I did find one site with rewritten urls that had both the back button/page not found problem AND did not see canonical url in view source.

The sites I looked at that had no back button problem had dynamic urls?

Re-looked, back button now working. May be cookie thing, not sure. It's sticking with my sites.

Still don't see canonical link in view source; at least where I'm used to seeing it.

Steve
prommart.com