Totally Zenned
- Join Date:
- Jan 2007
- Location:
- Los Angeles, California, United States
- Posts:
- 10,011
- Plugin Contributions:
- 3
Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!
RodG:
I guess he was having the same problem as I am, in that he was trying to make it clear that "pretty URLs" are/were not created for any misguided SEO reasons, and if it did affect SE rankings there was only anecdotal evidence to support it.
Sorry, but I haven't seen anything more than anecdotal evidence provided for either "side".. However, you guys can continue to debate this.. As far as I am concerned NEITHER side has "proven" their case IMHO.. All that these "tests" have succeeded to prove is what I know from my own experience (and you can call it "anecdotal evidence" if you like), and that is that using a URL re-writers on a client's site (speaking ONLY of Ceon URI -- don't use/like the others) doesn't cause the GREAT harm that some folks have tried very hard to put forward as the reason NOT to use them..
My clients for whom I have installed a re-writer (I don't use them for ALL clients) don't expect some SEO boost. They simply would prefer nicer looking URLS for use in newsletters and marketing materials, etc. Since no HARM has been proven by use of a re-writer, then there's no foul and therefore no reason to NOT use them if my client wants nice URLs. That said the thinking that there is some kind of SEO boost/advantage from one of these re-writers is mis-guided. There is no "magic" bullet to page rankings.. The ONLY indirect SEO benefit from a re-writer is that they allow you to create keyword ladden URLs.
RodG:
I suspect that if Conor had the time/energy/inclination he would also be ripping into the developers of these other products for making claims that they couldn't support with empirical evidence.Yeah.. No I don't think so.. If you had spoken to Conor privately you would know that he neither had time/energy or interest in doing any such thing...
RodG:
I've also made no distinction between CEON or any of the other SEO modules. I am aware that there is at least one SEO addon that does use redirects rather than rewrites, and this makes ALL THE DIFFERENCE. The simple action of performing a redirect comes at a cost... a cost that isn't paid when rewriting.
RodG:
Good question, and if I could give the answer I would have. In fact I'd have gone one step further and asked/suggested that one of the test sites should use the module because it would have been demonstrated the point I was hoping to show. It was over a year ago when I stumbled across the site using it, and to be perfectly honest, I didn't realise the relevance/significance of what it implied at the time, so I took no further notice of it.
Although it would have been good to demonstrate this one instance of a 'truly bad SEO tool', I also knew that if I couldn't identify which one it was it was still possible one of the others would have a similar flaw. I also knew that if this wasn't the to be, I'd end up with egg on face (stated as a good possibility many times).So what you are saying is that you do not know which module it was??? (your original statement seemed to indicate you knew which module it was)
So I have some follow-up questions..
- Do you know for sure that the site in question was using any of the known add-ons discussed (SSU, Ultimate, Magic, Ceon) versus some other re-writer module that no-one in this thread is aware of?
- How do you know from looking at the site you saw this module used on that the add-on was using re-directs versus re-writes?
- Finally can you share which site you saw this on? If you do not want to share publicly, a PM will be fine.. I'd like to see this for myself as a matter of understanding this more thoroughly..
My Site - Zen Cart & WordPress integration specialist
I don't answer support questions via PM. Post add-on support questions in the support thread. The question & the answer will benefit others with similar issues.