I went through them all on winmerge and the only thing that seemed like it needed to be carried over was the language files, which I did and they're showing up fine.
Category pages are showing fine, it's only the individual product pages.
I did switch to the other template and the pages are showing...and this is the only error I'm showing inside my error log files.
PHP Fatal error: Call to undefined function zen_lightbox() in /home/lehigheq/public_html/includes/templates/lehigh/templates/tpl_modules_main_product_image.php on line 24
Forgive me, I'm not an expert at this. I followed the migration and upgrade steps one at a time and did it. It was working fine in the temp folder before I moved it all over live...now I'm not sure which files I've missed.