If this is your first visit, check our documentation. To post, register or login.
Forums / GPL and Licensing Issues / GPL Violation?

GPL Violation?

Locked

Started by k_inutt on 4 Dec 2006, 12:02 AM · Views: 5,884

Results 1 to 19 of 19
This thread is locked. New replies are disabled.
4 Dec 2006, 12:02 AM
#1
k_inutt avatar

k_inutt

New Zenner

Join Date:
Dec 2006
Posts:
5
Plugin Contributions:
0

GPL Violation?

Greets, i'm new here, bit longer diggin' through the code to understand how it works, but i'm a big follower of opensource/GPL/CC products, commuities and all this and it anger me when i see things like http://www.kiosk.iki.pl/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=68&products_id=181 or http://www.kiosk.iki.pl/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=68&products_id=182 and third version on the same site... http://www.kiosk.iki.pl/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=68&products_id=482 !!! and they call the 3rd one PRO !!!!!! i'm taking you do not understand polish so i'll tell you the more spicy things...

from the first link, paragraph before server spec requirements:

Application is based on the earlier prepared engine Zen Cart which was based on osCommerce. Few things differ it from the original, translated interface, environment suited for poland (taxes/areas etc.). This application is <b>Somewhat a clone of Zen Cart but it isn't a copy</b>no word about it beeing freely distributed open source software, no links to the orginal files, all they've changed is translated language packs and added few variables for polish environment... Few lines earlier it says that it is allowed thanks to GPL to freely edit the source code but blast! it doesn't mean translate the variables and sell !!

the 2nd one is base /cough on the first one, and updated to higher version of Zen Cart (1.2.41) and guess what it says...

this application is somewhat a clone of Zen Cart and Ram Zen Cart (the previous link) but it isn't a copy!...
the best for the end... this one almost made me cry...
Zen Cart updated to 1.3.0.1... and then to 1.3.0.2 and they are boasting that they have made to increase the performance by up to 15% WOW! THEY MADE !! isn't that nice of them? what further on? what you can see? they are selling the PRO not only with their translation but they also add extra languages (for extra money) and i BET (yeah...) that they are the authors of these translations, wondering why their translations are only for the languages that were earlier released on zencart and so on...

if they were taking money for extra support in polish... ok
if they were taking money for design... ok
if they were taking money for hosting... ok
but they take money for translating variables and selling code that isn't their, they sell the usability of it!
and from what i've read on their forums people were saying that some of the things after installation weren't fully translated to polish hahaha...

there is one thing i hate more then people who let other fool them...
FOOLS WHO MAKE OTHERS BEEING FOOLS!!!!!!

please tell me if what they do is violating the GPL rules cause my view on it was a bit different...

Regards
K. Inutt

<?php echo 'code is poetry'; ?>

4 Dec 2006, 1:58 AM
#2
Kim avatar

Kim

Obaa-san

Join Date:
Jun 2003
Location:
West Coast, North America
Posts:
26,748
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

Sorry, but as far as I can tell they are not violating the GPL as long as they have not removed our copyrights. I do not speak or read Polish but they seem to acknowledging Zen Cart everywhere.

Please do not PM for support issues: a private solution doesn't benefit the community.

Be careful with unsolicited advice via email or PM - Make sure the person you are talking to is a reliable source.

4 Dec 2006, 9:59 AM
#3
k_inutt avatar

k_inutt

New Zenner

Join Date:
Dec 2006
Posts:
5
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

Oh well, it seems the GPL is less strict then i tought, can't tell if they have removed the information from the code cause i'm not realy fancy to pay for things that are shared by its creators for free /sigh, the only one who deserves money for the hard work is you imo, cheers

and btw, their acknowledment to Zen Cart all around the page is pointing at Zen Cart PL, product they take for theirs, and somebody who doesn't know what Zen Cart is will not know that it is originaly provided for free, that's not fair imo and it makes use of people's unawareness

Regards
K. Inutt

<?php echo 'code is poetry'; ?>

7 Apr 2007, 8:48 PM
#4
darek1978 avatar

darek1978

New Zenner

Join Date:
Dec 2005
Posts:
5
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

*** obsolete information removed ***

7 Apr 2007, 11:52 PM
#5
kuroi avatar

kuroi

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Apr 2006
Location:
London, UK
Posts:
10,475
Plugin Contributions:
11

Re: GPL Violation?

Wow, that's some really out-of-date information. Makes me wonder whether the Zen Cart Certified Hosting claim is (still) valid.

Kuroi Web Design and Development | Twitter

(Questions answered in the forum only - so that any forum member can benefit - not by personal message)

8 Apr 2007, 12:17 AM
#6
merlinpa1969 avatar

merlinpa1969

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Mar 2004
Posts:
13,031
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: GPL Violation?

thats very old,
Jason and Eric have been gone for along time,
but did I miss something about the zc certified

Zen cart PCI compliant Hosting

8 Apr 2007, 2:27 PM
#8
drbyte avatar

drbyte

Sensei

Join Date:
Jan 2004
Posts:
63,512
Plugin Contributions:
176

Re: GPL Violation?

darek, thanks for updating the information.

But ..... what is the purpose of your posting this information here ?

.
Zen Cart - putting the dream of business ownership within reach of anyone!
Donate to: DrByte directly or to the Zen Cart team as a whole

Remember: Any code suggestions you see here are merely suggestions. You assume full responsibility for your use of any such suggestions, including any impact ANY alterations you make to your site may have on your PCI compliance.
Furthermore, any advice you see here about PCI matters is merely an opinion, and should not be relied upon as "official". Official PCI information should be obtained from the PCI Security Council directly or from one of their authorized Assessors.

8 Apr 2007, 4:48 PM
#9
darek1978 avatar

darek1978

New Zenner

Join Date:
Dec 2005
Posts:
5
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

8th April 2007 02:27 PM
DrByte: darek, thanks for updating the information.

But ..... what is the purpose of your posting this information here ?

the answer for K.Inutt

K.Inutt:

and btw, their acknowledment to Zen Cart all around the page is pointing at Zen Cart PL, product they take for theirs, and somebody who doesn't know what Zen Cart is will not know that it is originaly provided for free, that's not fair imo and it makes use of people's unawareness

the answer for Merlinpa1969

thats very old,
Jason and Eric have been gone for along time,
but did I miss something about the zc certified

8 Apr 2007, 5:56 PM
#10
merlinpa1969 avatar

merlinpa1969

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Mar 2004
Posts:
13,031
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: GPL Violation?

I also see that you are advertising a zen cart certified how,
I have never seen that host in the list,

Zen cart PCI compliant Hosting

8 Apr 2007, 6:49 PM
#11
gjh42 avatar

gjh42

Black Belt

Join Date:
Jul 2005
Location:
Upstate NY
Posts:
21,874
Plugin Contributions:
8

Re: GPL Violation?

If you read carefully, it does say "Zen Cart PL Certified Hosting", I presume meaning that "Zen Cart PL" is doing the certifying. So not technically wrong...

8 Apr 2007, 7:14 PM
#12
ajeh avatar

ajeh

Oba-san

Join Date:
Sep 2003
Location:
Ohio
Posts:
62,757
Plugin Contributions:
1

Re: GPL Violation?

I believe the point of them using the Zen Cart Certified logo from our Certification Program is stretching that just a bit ... don't you think?

Linda McGrath
If you have to think ... you haven't been zenned ...

**Did YOU buy the Zen Cart Team a cup of coffee and a donut today? Just click here to support the Zen Cart Team!!**

Are you using the latest? Perhaps you've a problem that's fixed in the latest version: [Upgrade today!]
Officially PayPal-Certified! Just click here

Try our Zen Cart Recommended Services - Hosting, Payment and more ...
Signup for our Announcements Forums to stay up to date on important changes and updates!

8 Apr 2007, 7:21 PM
#13
Kim avatar

Kim

Obaa-san

Join Date:
Jun 2003
Location:
West Coast, North America
Posts:
26,748
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

The Certified Hosting graphic is copyrighted and using it without our permission is copyright infringement. As is using any other graphics or copy or text from this web site. The code is GPL but removing our copyright headers or selling the code violates the license.

Please do not PM for support issues: a private solution doesn't benefit the community.

Be careful with unsolicited advice via email or PM - Make sure the person you are talking to is a reliable source.

8 Apr 2007, 7:27 PM
#14
gjh42 avatar

gjh42

Black Belt

Join Date:
Jul 2005
Location:
Upstate NY
Posts:
21,874
Plugin Contributions:
8

Re: GPL Violation?

Sorta what I thought. I didn't get around to checking to see if the whole certified logo looked like yours, but they had obviously lifted the "zencart".

8 Apr 2007, 7:47 PM
#15
darek1978 avatar

darek1978

New Zenner

Join Date:
Dec 2005
Posts:
5
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

Kim:

The Certified Hosting graphic is copyrighted and using it without our permission is copyright infringement. As is using any other graphics or copy or text from this web site. The code is GPL but removing our copyright headers or selling the code violates the license.

Excuse me - already altered!

8 Apr 2007, 7:58 PM
#16
merlinpa1969 avatar

merlinpa1969

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Mar 2004
Posts:
13,031
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: GPL Violation?

Derek,

just because you added a red PL to it doesnt make it a new image,
it is still a copyrighted image, and you are in violation.

Zen cart PCI compliant Hosting

8 Apr 2007, 8:13 PM
#17
darek1978 avatar

darek1978

New Zenner

Join Date:
Dec 2005
Posts:
5
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

Merlinpa1969:

Derek,

just because you added a red PL to it doesnt make it a new image,
it is still a copyrighted image, and you are in violation.

already altered!

8 Apr 2007, 8:14 PM
#18
merlinpa1969 avatar

merlinpa1969

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Mar 2004
Posts:
13,031
Plugin Contributions:
4

Re: GPL Violation?

sorry musta had it in cache

Zen cart PCI compliant Hosting

17 Aug 2007, 5:48 PM
#19
freelancer666 avatar

freelancer666

New Zenner

Join Date:
Aug 2007
Posts:
1
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: GPL Violation?

Kim:

The Certified Hosting graphic is copyrighted and using it without our permission is copyright infringement. The code is GPL but removing our copyright headers or selling the code violates the license.

But you not interested with realy free polish support site. I'am maked you 3 times this suggestion but your answer: ... nothing.
I'am member of polish forum at zencart.pl