Warning - Configuration Error: [EXTRA CC ORDER info]

I get this error via email after an order:

WARNING: You have enabled the CC payment module but have not properly
configured it to send CC information to you by email. As a result, you will
not be able to process the CC number for orders placed using this method.
Go to Admin->Modules->Payment->CC->Edit and set the preferred email address
for sending CC information.

Okay, so I went to Admin->Modules->Payment->CC->Edit. But there is no "preferred email address" field... The only email field (split) has always been filled out with an email address.

Try setting it in Admin>Configuration>My Store>Store Address & Phone, if you haven't already done so.

Yes, that has always been filled out as well.