Forums / Search Engines / seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Started by zvenson on 27 Jun 2009, 6:24 AM · Views: 7,987

Results 1 to 20 of 52
27 Jun 2009, 6:24 AM
#1
zvenson avatar

zvenson

New Zenner

Join Date:
May 2009
Posts:
61
Plugin Contributions:
0

seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Hi !
I`m thinking about installing one of the seo url contributions for zen cart but found 3 solutions for this :

Ceon - http://www.zen-cart.com/index.php?ma...oducts_id=1269

USEO - http://www.zen-cart.com/index.php?ma...roducts_id=231

Simple SEO - http://www.zen-cart.com/index.php?ma...oducts_id=1013

so now im a little confused about which one to install - i figurered out, that with ceon the urls are not generated automatically which could be a plus, but anyway im not sure which contribution is the best - of course the goal of seo urls is (like the name says) to get better results in search engines - so with this in mind, if anyone has a suggestion this would be nice! thank you!

www.acousticsdb.com - soundproofing and room acoustics matters | webdesign hamburg

27 Jun 2009, 6:35 AM
#2
kiddo avatar

kiddo

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jul 2006
Location:
SF Bay Area
Posts:
837
Plugin Contributions:
1

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Why not set up a test shop (or three) and try them all.

I did this and ended up choosing the Ceon mod. Your opinion may be different.

27 Jun 2009, 7:10 AM
#3
shoesbuyonline avatar

shoesbuyonline

New Zenner

Join Date:
May 2009
Posts:
78
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Hi,

I used the simple seo url from yellow to test locally. It is nice and could offer what you need though sometimes you need some settings.

Have a nice day,

27 Jun 2009, 8:32 AM
#4
zvenson avatar

zvenson

New Zenner

Join Date:
May 2009
Posts:
61
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

yeah trying all three would defenitely the best solution, but who has time to do this :). Thanks for your answers - i think i first try the ceon thing because of the advantages mentioned above - i let you know how this works out for me!

www.acousticsdb.com - soundproofing and room acoustics matters | webdesign hamburg

3 Sep 2009, 8:23 AM
#5
mixxin avatar

mixxin

New Zenner

Join Date:
Sep 2009
Posts:
6
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

What did you end up going with?

27 Nov 2009, 9:26 AM
#6
thirupathy avatar

thirupathy

New Zenner

Join Date:
Nov 2009
Posts:
20
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

I have installed ultimate seo url in mystore. after installation and configuration of this module. i went to my store.

It shows the following error.

The requested URL /demo/dvd-movies-c-3.html was not found on this server.

I think something i missed while installation . So can anyone please find and notify to me.

regards,
THIRUPPATHY.M :smartalec:

LOVE TO LEARN NEW TECHNOLOGY

27 Nov 2009, 9:48 AM
#7
jcdk avatar

jcdk

Zen Follower

Join Date:
Oct 2009
Location:
Netherlands - NB
Posts:
144
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

I use CEON and I love it.

It works great and let you choose which product / category pages to be optimized.

Easy installation and great documentation as well.:cool:

27 Nov 2009, 10:13 AM
#8
schoolboy avatar

schoolboy

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Jun 2005
Location:
Cumbria, UK
Posts:
10,327
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Ironically, you don't need any of them. And in fact, using these so-called SEO modules could do more harm than good.

The search engines all prefer you to LEAVE the dynamic URL's, because they now index these faultlessly. Some "SEO" modules are unreliable and risk creating duplicate links (content) for which you are penalised on the big search engines.

Much more important are good xml sitemap generators, and Andrew Berezin's XMLSitemaps is excellent.

(CEON - Conor Kerr's module, may be the one exception to this - but I don't use it.)

20 years a Zencart User

4 Oct 2010, 8:36 AM
#9
stormae avatar

stormae

New Zenner

Join Date:
Oct 2010
Posts:
16
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

schoolboy:

Ironically, you don't need any of them. And in fact, using these so-called SEO modules could do more harm than good.

The search engines all prefer you to LEAVE the dynamic URL's, because they now index these faultlessly. Some "SEO" modules are unreliable and risk creating duplicate links (content) for which you are penalised on the big search engines.

Much more important are good xml sitemap generators, and Andrew Berezin's XMLSitemaps is excellent.

(CEON - Conor Kerr's module, may be the one exception to this - but I don't use it.)

Most absurd comment ive ever read.

Obviously this guy has no clue of SEO.

4 Oct 2010, 11:03 AM
#10
stevesh avatar

stevesh

Black Belt

Join Date:
Feb 2005
Location:
Lansing, Michigan USA
Posts:
19,793
Plugin Contributions:
2

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

One of you doesn't.

Google itself has stated it can index dynamiic URLs just fine.

The standard automotive analogy:

Fifty years ago, automotive motor oil wasn't very good, so an aftermarket industry sprang up selling additives to make the oil do its job better. The STP Corporation became, and remained, the giant in the field.

Now, motor oil is infinitely better, but STP still sells millions of bottles of their (now worthless) additives every year, because 'everybody knows' it's necessary (and because of a lot of advertising).

Same thing with URL re-writing for 'SEO' purposes. The only people who still sing that tune are those who profit from those programs' use.

4 Oct 2010, 11:38 AM
#11
coolcarpartsonline avatar

coolcarpartsonline

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Feb 2008
Posts:
1,386
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

I actually did a test on live sites to compare both approaches.

One used SEO mod. The second was left standard. After 2 months, the standard site was better indexed in Google and bring just as good sales as the other site if not more.

There is no one answer to this question. Every site is unique in it's own world, what might work for someone might not work for another. Just having SEO URL will not increase your sales on it's own. SEO is multiple things that work together and just doing one thing will not increase your profit or ROI.

4 Oct 2010, 12:00 PM
#12
dutchy avatar

dutchy

Zen Follower

Join Date:
May 2010
Location:
London
Posts:
324
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Im sorry, but I have to disagree with those that state human readable URLs make no difference to search engine rankings.

As CarParts has pointed out, good SEOing is a combination of many things, but even Google's own Matt Cutts has said in his blog and on video that human / clean URLs do perform better in Google than dynamic URLs.

While 'content' is king regarding a sites indexing / ranking, sites with great content AND clean / human readable URLs do perform better than those without clean URLs. The focus is on the keyword(s) being in the URL.

It is also better for us humans to recall a websites page.

SchoolBoy, I have read the Google blog thing about it not making any difference, but if I correctly recall, that was published in 2007. I have come across in the Google webmaster guide (within your google account) infomation on how to properly achieve clean URLs. Published after the blog post.

And if clean URLs are make no difference, why are clean URL rewrites becoming built into other carts and cms?

If I were to follow advice on URLs, I would follow the advice given by Matt Cutts. IMHO

4 Oct 2010, 1:03 PM
#13
coolcarpartsonline avatar

coolcarpartsonline

Totally Zenned

Join Date:
Feb 2008
Posts:
1,386
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

The whole argument is based on whether Zen Cart module are better than Zen Cart standard URLs. I hate when people generalize their answer. I assume we are on Zen Cart forum so the question was specific for Zen Cart hence the answer.

A lot of people run small websites so it's easy to remember the URL but some people such as myself has large websites and it would be impossible for a customer to remember the URL so that can prove that URLs aren't helpful if you are trying to make customer remember them. Let alone duplicate content and duplicate URLs which can be hard to find on larger scale website.

Also let me bring to your attention that some of the well known website don't use the standard SEO style URL but are ranked better than most of the small websites.

Content is king so hoping to bring in more sales by just using SEO url can be waste of time especially if you are a newbie and trying to start a business.

I have one site with standard Zen Cart and about 3 mods installed for back-end control that brings about 30 orders/month with Zero time spent in SEO or maintenance using standard Zen Cart. So that can proof that time spent in 3 party mods if you have to learn how to use them and configure them can be wasted time for a newbie. Even if you have the best SEO Mod installed.

Remember when everybody start focusing on one thing to try to spam search engine in ranking them it would soon loose it's value just like the Keyword Meta tag. When people try focusing on it too much Google stopped paying attention to it.

4 Oct 2010, 1:36 PM
#14
website_rob avatar

website_rob

Inactive

Join Date:
Oct 2006
Location:
Alberta, Canada
Posts:
4,572
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

These are the facts.

People remember Domain names... not URLs

Bookmarks use the Page Title... not URLs

There was a time when SEO friendly URLs made "somewhat" of a difference but that difference is now gone.

The learning is in the doing.

Potent Products

4 Oct 2010, 1:44 PM
#15
dutchy avatar

dutchy

Zen Follower

Join Date:
May 2010
Location:
London
Posts:
324
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

oops, i forgot to add my choice for zen cart.
Ultimate URLs i have never tried – no comment

SSU did give me slightly better google results but caused some problems. Installing was a pain, having to find an older version of Module Manager. Also, after a customer checked out, they were unable to change their product notifications. The author was not supporting this add-on fully on the zen cart forums. After 6 months I removed it from my store as support requests went un-answered.

Ceon URI Manager worked brilliantly. Slightly daunting at first as the install information is a plenty. But very well written. Sadly URLs are not automated like SSU thus requires more man hours to apply.

On a 3000+ product store, using Ceon's URI manager, writing great content, applying good keywords throughout the content, URIs and the zen cart meta tags manager has taken roughly 200 work hours. But very well worth it.

About 40% of my products are on googles first page. 30% on the second page. SEO management is constant, not a project but a programme or never ending work. But I 100% feel that my ranking would not be as high only using content and meta-tags.

Still recommend you read through the google web-master guide and read/watch Matt Cutts. IMHO, If the man from google says clean URLs perform better with great content, than great content alone, then I am inclined to disagree with those here that say otherwise. And for me, i have seen the proof on my own store.

4 Oct 2010, 2:03 PM
#16
stormae avatar

stormae

New Zenner

Join Date:
Oct 2010
Posts:
16
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

dutchy:

Im sorry, but I have to disagree with those that state human readable URLs make no difference to search engine rankings.

As CarParts has pointed out, good SEOing is a combination of many things, but even Google's own Matt Cutts has said in his blog and on video that human / clean URLs do perform better in Google than dynamic URLs.

While 'content' is king regarding a sites indexing / ranking, sites with great content AND clean / human readable URLs do perform better than those without clean URLs. The focus is on the keyword(s) being in the URL.

It is also better for us humans to recall a websites page.

SchoolBoy, I have read the Google blog thing about it not making any difference, but if I correctly recall, that was published in 2007. I have come across in the Google webmaster guide (within your google account) infomation on how to properly achieve clean URLs. Published after the blog post.

And if clean URLs are make no difference, why are clean URL rewrites becoming built into other carts and cms?

If I were to follow advice on URLs, I would follow the advice given by Matt Cutts. IMHO

I absolutely agree, however, the other people are placing arguments like:

There was a time when SEO friendly URLs made "somewhat" of a difference but that difference is now gone.

That is absolutely untrue. You are relying on the fact that google indexes the urls now, yes it does!

But they index far slower and far worse then SEO Friendly URLs. There have been multiple publications about it and everyone claiming thats not true must do their reading on the internet before commenting here. You can never convince me that an url that looks like http://domain.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=45 will be better looking then http://domain.com/product-category-productname-productoption1-productoption/productoption3.

That is absurd even to think of. There are thousands of sites all around the world paying thousands of dollars monthly to be in touch with the latest SEO trends, go read some blogs and then comment.

Moral of the story, SEO Urls is for people who need optimization, it is not mandatory, but it helps.

4 Oct 2010, 2:30 PM
#17
dutchy avatar

dutchy

Zen Follower

Join Date:
May 2010
Location:
London
Posts:
324
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

Also, aside from the topic of URLs, I have found that using Image Manger 1.4 by Boudewijn rather than Image Handle 2 has also improved my search engine ranking. As my product images are being index according to the name. I noticed this after another IM user pointed this out. But that is a whole other area for debate.

4 Oct 2010, 2:30 PM
#18
gjh42 avatar

gjh42

Black Belt

Join Date:
Jul 2005
Location:
Upstate NY
Posts:
21,874
Plugin Contributions:
8

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

When did anyone say that dynamic URLs are better looking than pretty URLs? That is not the point here; the point is whether it makes a significant difference to search engine results, and also whether, FOR E-COMMERCE SITES, the individual product URL really matters.

4 Oct 2010, 2:36 PM
#19
stormae avatar

stormae

New Zenner

Join Date:
Oct 2010
Posts:
16
Plugin Contributions:
0

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

gjh42:

When did anyone say that dynamic URLs are better looking than pretty URLs? That is not the point here; the point is whether it makes a significant difference to search engine results, and also whether, FOR E-COMMERCE SITES, the individual product URL really matters.

I meant look better to search engines, but then again, to clients it looks much better too id guess.

4 Oct 2010, 4:29 PM
#20
gjh42 avatar

gjh42

Black Belt

Join Date:
Jul 2005
Location:
Upstate NY
Posts:
21,874
Plugin Contributions:
8

Re: seo (urls) - what is the best contribution?

There are thousands of sites all around the world paying thousands of dollars monthly to be in touch with the latest SEO trends

True, and there are thousands of people paying for all kinds of things being sold... does that indicate that they are all actually effective?