Deceased
- Join Date:
- Jan 2007
- Location:
- Australia
- Posts:
- 6,263
- Plugin Contributions:
- 4
Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!
DivaVocals:
Nope.. Jury isn't out on this at all, .
I beg to differ. The is the 1% where we still don't agree.
DivaVocals:
but from your posts you sure seem determined to prove that there is truth to this.:smile: .
I'm most certainly determined to prove this one way or the other... if possible.
DivaVocals:
This little test ya'll are running isn't going to prove or disprove anything...
This depends on exactly which tests you are referring too. As you have hopefully observed, the cats have gone wild, all doing their own little tests, with no real idea what they are trying to show (or not show), and this no theory/test/theory/test process I agree, they will be able to prove nothing.
If only we didn't have that bit of panicing early in the peice, I could/would have guided the tests to prove one case or the other (which case, I've no idea. Not important). As it stands now, I'm not sure if we still have valid controls in place (a test site in a known and specific configuration, as defined by the initial control that were set up).
I thought all was lost in this regard, until the 'odd' behaviour of feznizzles site remaining in the top 2 in spite of the logic that suggested it should have been dropped. As long as feznizzle doesn't fsck things up going off on his own little tangent again, I hope I'll be able to bring his test sites back in line so that we will actually be able to prove something with empirical evidence. I won't be holding my breath though, as so far he has done nothing but throw a spanner in the works at every turn. If only I could make him realise that I'm not out to 'get' him, I'm not out to prove 'my' point. I simply wish to conduct a controlled experiment that we will all benefit from.
DivaVocals:
They only seem to support what BOTH sides say and that to me only serves to prove that there is no real discernible difference between native versus re-written URLs.. .
Jumped the shark again. To Google there is NO DIFFERENCE between native versus re-written URLs WHATSOEVER. This is BEYOND DISPUTE.
I try to avoid putting words in other peoples mouths (A courtesy I wish others would give me), but I'm going to make an exception here. I think/suspect/hope that what you MEANT to say was "to me only serves to prove that there is no real discernible difference between KeyWord laden URL's vs Non-Keyword laden URLs."
There is a huge difference between the two comments. You can see that can't you?
DivaVocals:
Is there anything posted by Matt Cutt or anyone from Yahoo or Bing that says that there is a SEO benefit to be had by the use of a URL re-writer?? I think that trumps any "results" that might be found in this "test"
This is one of the most absurd things I've read in a long time. You are basically saying you are willing to take someones word over something even though there may be evidence to the contrary! That defies all logic.
DivaVocals:
It seems logical that when someone from GOOGLE (or Yahoo or Bing) says that a "pretty URL" is somehow better for SEO than a dynamic/native one, that there really will be a definitive answer on this..
So can we stop this bickering and try to get back to trying to demonstrate it?
DivaVocals:
There is enough evidence that demonstrates that GOOD content, not the URL will deliver the best click through rates..
This has been unanimously agreed on MANY occasions, even by the folk at Google. I'm currently running my own test to prove this. I'm a little worried though. Up until yesterday/today I've taken this as a known and proven fact. Now I'm not so sure. Think about feznizzle's top two sites. This has thrown a spanner into the works in a big way... Totally unintentionally, but nonetheless, it has caused me to rethink whether 'Content is king' after all.... If content really is more important than the URL (for any given search query) then how is it possible for the current top two test sites to be there in spite of the fact that they contain** no content relevant to the search query **"Wurldbitzer Debibulator". The only thing that appears to be keeping them at the top is the content of the URL.
This is NOT something I would ever have expected if 'content were king'.
Do you (or anyone else) have any thoughts or theories that would explain this apparent oddity that defies everything we had all previously agreed on?
The only thing I can think of is that URL trumps content. This really doesn't sit well with me.. it is a challenge to one of my core beliefs, bit I don't have any other explanation. please discuss.
Cheers
Rod