You rock. That wasn't it; like I said, I hadn't touched anything recently so the paths weren't going to suddenly be off. But I chose to not renew my SSL for that website. I just turned off SSL in that very file. I never ever would have figured that out in a million years. Now to remember the password......not stored in my browser history since the path names is different.
So weird that every file on my server was touched.... oh well. A total red herring.