Deceased
- Join Date:
- Jan 2007
- Location:
- Australia
- Posts:
- 6,263
- Plugin Contributions:
- 4
Hoping to pick the brains of some old pros!
SPH:
I think this goes back to where Ihungil first jumped in re that no url rewrite tool currently in this test uses redirects.
In spite of all my attempts, I've still not rediscovered which software/module did use the redirects, but near the start of this thread I proclaimed quite loudly and boldly that the redirect method is totally ineffective in regards to SEO and I would be able to demonstrate it.
Some of you already know the direction I was heading with this bold, but 100% accurate proclamation, many others will not. Some will dispute the claim no matter what I state(d), because they don't appreciate/understand the difference between a rewrite and a redirect.
I've given every opportunity and many 'hints' that would have demonstrated the difference for themselves, which would have helped understand why the redirects cannot benefit SEO in any way, shape or form.
I think that this thread has now just about run its course. I don't think I have anything more to teach (I'd just be re-repeating myself), so, time for the demonstration......... Hopefully the penny will drop.
Take the following URL:
http://shop.vcsweb.com/Nokia_3210_black
Clearly this is a 'KeyWord' loaded URL, and all discussion so far would indicate that this URL would have a 'slight advantage' over the ZenCart 'native' URL. Agreed?
Wrong!
Looking at the URL above we don't have any way of knowing if this URL is the result of a 'native' URL (prestashop method) or whether it has been rewritten (CEON, etc,method), or whether it is a RedIrect.
I'll tell you now. This URL is using a redirect (I added my own redirection to our store for the purposes of this demonstration. I'd rather have been able to demonstrate the same thing with a 'real' SEO tool, but obviously not possible until/unless I/we can re-identify one that still uses this method)).
If you click on the link you will be redirected to
http://shop.vcsweb.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=2_14&products_id=123
This is clearly a 'native' ZenCart URL.
The http://shop.vcsweb.com/Nokia_3210_black URL **doesn't actually exist **as a webpage.... It may have existed at some stage (for example, if my original store was prestashop and I upgraded to ZenCart), but it doesn't exist now, which is why I need to add a redirect for this to work.
If you attempt to go to (say) http://shop.vcsweb.com/Nokia_3210_blue you'll get the usual 'page not found' response. I haven't set up a redirect for the Nokia_3210_blue.
So, how does all this relate to the Google listings? At its core level, Google is little more than another web browser. It 'sees' what a user will see. This means that if Google follows the URL http://shop.vcsweb.com/Nokia_3210_black, the page it will 'see', and subsequently index, is the target URL, in this case
http://shop.vcsweb.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=2_14&products_id=123
It cannot index http://shop.vcsweb.com/Nokia_3210_black because it never 'sees' this as a web page. It has gone. It no longer exists. It will not be indexed. This in turn means that using a redirect 'for SEO' is totally and completely ineffective.
This is indisputable fact, and I've no intention of debating this point with anyone.
That is the 1st of two things that I wish to demonstrate.
The second thing to demonstrate is that** at the current time**, the only place the URL can be found is in this thread. Google can't read this thread. It has no way of knowing that the URL http://shop.vcsweb.com/Nokia_3210_black even exists, so now we have a double whammy... firstly, Google won't find the 'Friendly' link, but even if it did, it'll be redirected to the 'native' URL as detailed above.
I've had this redirect in place for several days now (hhmmm a little over a week). IF Google was able to find the http://shop.vcsweb.com/Nokia_3210_black URL it would almost certainly be in the index by now. Do a search. You won't find it, because Google didn't.
If a person using redirects doesn't realise this, then not only is the redirect ineffective for 'SEO' it can also be considered detrimental because Google won't be indexing the URL's they think it is/should.
Here endith the lesson (and hopefully this aspect of the discussion). It is a non debatable issue. It is simply fact. That is the way redirects work, and that is why it is important to distinguish the difference between a rewrite and a redirect. In both cases the URL's can be made to look the same, but the end result is totally and completely different.
Having said that, it is also a bit of a moot point, because none of the current SEO tools being discussed still use redirects (exclusively). This doesn't change the facts though, and some people will often add their own redirects for whatever reason (as I have done for this demo). Again, unless they are aware of what a redirect does (compared to a rewrite) they'll not get the results (benefits?) they were expecting.
Cheers
Rod.
)